RELOCATING HOME OWNERS ARE FACED WITH A SIGNIFICANT LOSS OF FINANCIAL CAPITAL

WHEN BUSINESSES CONSOLIDATE TODAY, EMPLOYEES ARE AT THE MERCY OF THE MARKET.

                                                 * * * *   HARD CORE REAL ESTATE TALK * * * *

                                                TRUE STORY OF A LOCAL HOME OWNER FRIEND

You don't want to relocate.  You had no intention of relocating.  Goodness, you just purchased your
home in September of 2005
, at the peak of the market for the area.  That didn't bother you because
you planned to remain in your home for the next 20 years until retirement, or longer.  You have a
lovely home in a quiet residential community of average 5 acre lots.  Your lot is just over 8 acres
with wonderful privacy, a manageable amount of grass to cut and a house that you love to call home. 
In fact, shortly following moving in 2 years ago, you added a two level addition to your 20 years old
home thinking that it would give you more room than you'd need for overnight guests and visiting family.

You finally have your dream home and now you find that you must sell.  Your employer is moving
your division to New Jersey.  You have worked for 15 years to gain the management position in the
company and you would prefer to move rather than starting over with a new company.  The most
difficult part of changing job location is selling the home you love and buying another one in New
Jersey.

FACT:  Homes in your area have decreased in average price by about 17% over the past two years. 
That's not good news because you paid top dollar to get the home you wanted. 

FACT:  The average time on the market has increased from an average of 45 days when you purchased
your home to an average of 159 days today.  The market is very slow due to the general slowdown
of real estate in general.  Not a good time to sell, you say.  But, you have no choice. 

FACT:  When you purchased your home, the average buyer paid about 96% of the list price.
Today, the average buyer pays an average of 90% of the list price.  So, you have to expect to negotiate
the price when you do get offers. 

FACT:  The contract with the relocation company requires that you use an agent referred by the
relocation company or you will not receive reimbursement for your real estate commission and
selling closing costs and you will not receive your relocation benefits to pay your closing costs
in New Jersey. 

FACT:  The relocation company has referred three "approved" agents to be interviewed.  The first
one was extremely rude and stated that you'd be lucky to get back 80% of what you paid two years ago.  That may be true, but it wasn't what you wanted to hear before an agent even looked at your home.  The second agent is fairly new and has little experience.  He has one listing that didn't sell.  The third agent states that he only lists homes to sell quickly and that he would list your home for about 76% of what you paid two years ago.  None of the relocation company agents referred are encouraging, but you have no choice but to use them. 

FACT:  You did everything right.  You made an honest fully documented loan and have a secure low
interest 30 year fixed rate mortgage.  Now you have to sell and you'll be taking the same losses
that are experienced by the home buyer who speculated on buying and flipping their purchase,
buyers who obtained home loans with fraudulent loan applications and buyers who purchased homes
with loans that they knew they couldn't afford but relied on an ever appreciating market to refinance or
sell short term. 

FACT:  Based on a purchase price of $525,000 two years ago and a likely sale price of about $435,000 today, you will likely lose about $90,000 just on the sale of your home.  If prices continue to decline, the loss could easily be well over $100,000

THE MEDIA ARE NOT LOOKING AT THE FINANCIAL HARM TO RELOCATING HOME OWNERS.

You did everything right and yet, you're a casualty of the mortgage mess. 

 

19 Comments on RELOCATING HOME OWNERS ARE FACED WITH A SIGNIFICANT LOSS OF FINANCIAL CAPITAL

Oh, Lenn- I saw this ending coming.  What are the relo's doing without company participation?

12/22/2007 05:12 PM by Options Realty


YUP, we had buyers this summer that had boought a house 3 months before they were told he had to relocate plus they were getting married in between when I was showing homes. I felt bad for them then felt bad for me as they ended up renting in Massachusetts. LOL

12/22/2007 05:16 PM by Jay McGillicuddy~Real Estate Broker (Prudential Verani Realty)


So true and well said. What a dilemna for relocating homeowners.  Keeping the house and travelling on weekends, or renting are both not options I guess.. I would suppose that a lot of individuals in this situation might not be in a position to pay the $90,000 and might be stuck and unable to sell.

12/22/2007 05:17 PM by Miriam Bernstein, CRS, Westchester County, NY (RE/MAX Prime Properties)


Laurie.  I don't understand your question.  The company has a contract with a relocation company.  The employee must use the services of the relo referred agent, here and in NJ. 

12/22/2007 05:18 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Miriam.  They're not paying the $90,000 but that's about the minimum they'll lose on the sale of their home.  They'll still be able to settle because they have a 70% loan, but just look at the money they're losing.

12/22/2007 05:20 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Jay.  Your folks, like mine are casualties of the mortgage mess. 

12/22/2007 05:24 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Lenn, It is an unfortunate situation to be in. I talk to folks going through the same thing quite frequently. They have difficult decisions to make. One would be to not relocate and look for other employment. Personally, I don't think this is anything the media should be concerned with. There are many times in our lives where we have to make difficult decisions. Even in a normal market they would be real close to being upside down after only two years. Hopefully, if they do move they will remember this and not buy for a few years until they are sure they are staying for more than a couple of years.

12/22/2007 05:24 PM by Bryant Tutas-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc


OMG, Lenn- MY APOLOGIES!  I read the first few paragraphs and was jumping into the reality of no equity and a job transfer- the 17% had me convinced of the point.  That these relo's are forced to accept representation is ridiculous, in light of their financial stake; that they did, indeed, close on the purchase with full disclosure is commendable; that they are now compromised by the contingent that wanted to scam, engage in fraudulent practices, and essentially close the door to practices that benefit the well qualified- well...this market sucks.

12/22/2007 05:30 PM by Options Realty


Yup...this is a tough market and a bad situation
to be in if you bought recently and now HAVE to move.....

I am glad being in real estate does not mean I will be
relocated if the company goes belly up or relocates
my residential division...

I can just pull up my stakes and go elsewhere....

I feel for those who do not have that luxury....

Those who bought for profit got caught...one of my
clients was included in that picture.... he just broke
even after loosing about $50,000 on a flip deal....

I did try to warn him BEFORE he went off on his own
and THEN asked me to help him out of it.

12/22/2007 05:44 PM by Central Florida real estate - Alexander Harb PSEM®, E-Agent® (Beach and Luxury Realty Inc.)


Bryant.  Could anyone every be really sure that they would be staying for more than two years???  Their experience now is going to make them think they could always be moved again.  Renting for two years isn't going to reduce their risk. 

Alexander.  Thanks for dropping by.  I have one like that too.  He purchased at the peak of the market and then tried to flip for WAY more than it would sell for, got stuck and now wishes he could unload it after renting it for a year. 

Laurie.  Hurray.  You got my point.  THIS MARKET SUCKS.

12/22/2007 06:03 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Our market is not anything close to that tough, but we have areas that are starting to see short sales.  mostly due to over-development in a few communities.  I find those to be rough also.  The people who sold them their new home is not their competitor and the cause of their pain.

12/22/2007 06:31 PM by Randy L. Prothero - Hawaii REALTOR® (Century 21 Liberty Homes)


Randy.

When you look at the stats for my area, you have to expect more short sales.  The couple in this post have sufficient equity to cover a loss.  If they didn't, they'd be in real trouble. 

12/22/2007 06:34 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


"Renting for two years isn't going to reduce their risk".    As long as they rent, they won't have to relo again--it's Muphy's Law.

Lenn, how much longer do you think it will be for your market to turn back around?  I know, you don't have a crystal ball but I'm sure you have an educated guess.  I've got a buyer who has multiple properties to sell and one of them is in Maryland. 

12/22/2007 08:46 PM by AMANDA HALL*Broker*HALL TEAM HOMES* FORT WORTH REAL ESTATE (Serving all of DFW and surrounding areas within N Texas)


Amanda.  Depends on where in Maryland.  Maryland is many markets.

 

12/23/2007 06:53 AM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


OUCH is right.  I have some past clients in a similar situation - though not as bad.  First they called apologizing about 100 times because they had to use the dreaded "approved" relo agent instead of me.

Then they called a second time saying "How they hate him".   As if losing money wasn't insult enough - they have a Listing Agent who doesn't seem to give a rats behind.

12/23/2007 09:30 AM by James Downing - REALTOR® - Washington DC Real Estate (Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage)


I've been watching the house on the corner of my street that's been on the market for the last 137 days.  Those folks bought their home about three months before I did for $600,000.  They listed it this time at $610,000 (which I knew was a mistake as soon as it came on the market).  They've now lowered it to $552,000.  Since they're represented, I haven't inquired whether they're relocating or short-selling, but I'm not amused by the drastic reduction.  

12/23/2007 09:37 AM by Gregory D. Maley - Metropolitan Washington, DC REALTOR (Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage - Chevy Chase)


Lenn, you make so many right on points that I don't know where to begin.  The only people who don't suffer in relocations are those who are moving to areas where the market is equally crappy or even worse.  Then they would at least be able to buy another house that has had a similar price decline.  I only hope the imbecile relo agent (and certainly they are not all imbeciles) on the buying end knows how to negotiate, which many do not.  

12/23/2007 10:17 AM by Patricia Kennedy (Evers & Company)


James.  I looked up the record of the two agents between whom they must select.  One has NO sales and the other has about 9 transations this year, all in much lower price ranges.

If the companies that hire the relo companies understood that the referring agents were qualified by their willingness to forfeit 35% of their commission, perhaps the companies would think differently about the requirement that their transferees use the relo referred agents. 

The decision makers in these companies really throw their employees to the wolves by requiring that the transferee use the relo referred agents. 

In the present case, this transferee either gives up his benefits or uses the relo referred agents, none of whom are worth $0.02. 

Oh well. 

 

12/23/2007 02:41 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Gregory.

One of the hardest things for a home owning consumer to understand is that the price that you paid for real estate has absolutely no bearing on the market value when it's listed for sale.

Patricia.  Listing agents don't encourage a lot of negotiating in this market out here is Western Loudoun County.  They are just so glad to have a showing, they become my best friend when I show their listing.

Negotiating skills aren't going to help much when buyers have a mindset of getting a real bargain.

 

12/23/2007 03:23 PM by Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Real Estate Brokerage: Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate
Lenn Harley
Rockville, MD
More about me…
Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Real Estate

Office Phone: (800) 711-7988
Email Me

Links

Tags (Tag Cloud)

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find MD real estate agents and Rockville real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved