I did not imagine there would be a time in Teton County Idaho that the proposal of building a new Church would be controversial. The LDS Church proposed a new Church House along the Highway just North of Victor that would provide services for people from county Road 4000 south to the Wyoming State line.

churchWhat is the controversy? Some feel that a church is not a good fit for the scenic corridor along the Highway. Some had issue with the height of the steeple. The church would like a steeple that is higher than the currently allowed height restriction.

County commissioners voted to deny the application 2 to 1. News Channel 8 story on the County’s decision.

My thoughts:

·         A church of any denomination would be a great thing to have in the scenic corridor.

·         Although one Commissioner stated traffic as an issue – Sunday mornings are not a busy time for traffic at this location.

·         In a time of economic hardship – let’s embrace new construction.

·         When a good use is not consistent with the comprehensive plan – change the plan.

With so many problems facing us in our community, our country and our world, why is this an issue?

 

            TetonPropertySearch       http://www.TetonPropertySearch.com

 

208-787-4554 or Mobile: 208-709-4555   73 North Main, Victor Idaho 83455

harley heatherlogo

 

30 Comments on Controversy over a New LDS Church in Teton Valley Idaho

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All

APR
23
2012
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Elizabeth - Perhaps. I hope not. This little valley was settled by Mormons. Most folks that think Mormonism is a "Cult" do not know much about the religion. I am for Churches, regardless of denomination, and I am for them to be where they can be seen. I just feel the architecture of churches are pleasant to look at and the values for which they stand is something to be proud of.

1:17pm • #11
680,554 Points 51 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Called Shot Master

Really. Can't they find anything better to be concerned about?

1:25pm • #12
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Connie - Yes Really, crazy world we live in.

1:46pm • #13
125,085 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog

I say as long as they follow the rules then build away. New jobs and folks having a place of worship never hurt anybody.

2:46pm • #14
510,688 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Wow, what next? I agree that maybe the height restriction should be enforced, but any tastefully designed church should be acceptable. Are there any design regulations for the corridor that the church would violate? Otherwise, I think they should go for it!

Gretchen

4:32pm • #15
1,652,585 Points 134 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Harley, do you think that it had anything to do with the denomination that was requesting?  

6:14pm • #17
980,599 Points 114 Featured Posts Outside Blog Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

I wonder if they'd be opposed to a cross of the same height.  It really is a steeple and doesn't really draw that much attention.  Sad that the height restriction was an issue of contention. 

7:24pm • #18

The CUP was not disapproved because of steeple height as the variance for the steeple was withdrawn before the BOCC public hearing!  As commissioner Benedict (D) stated as he was about to render his deny decision, he "Learned more about the LDS Church during the hearing than he did reading the application", and that he could not permit the amount of activity the LDS members would be participating in.  How's that for denying religious practice and constitutional first amendment rights?!  It says something about the liberals in the community when a church building is denied (Victor impact area) but an over-height vodka distillery is approved in the scenic corridor (north-end Driggs impact area).  VARD colluded with the 2 BOCC democrats to deny the church CUP but where were they for the distillery?  It's high time to vote out the corruption!  See you May 15th at your polling places!

Tony
9:38pm • #19
421,375 Points 16 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Harley, it is unfortunate that many of the ills in the world today are due to the same people who are pro distillery and anti Church.

11:49pm • #20
APR
24
2012
523,054 Points 10 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master

The church is going to generate traffic.  And, that is good.  More people participating keeps them from needing the products of the distellery.

5:23am • #21
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Hey Chris - I believe in rules. I also feel if rules do not make sense CHANGE THEM. A development seminar I attended had a speaker that said if you have a great plan and it doesn't fit the ordinance - change the ordinance, his recommendation to P&Z. I think Regulation is easy to create and hard to change.

6:34am • #22
251,032 Points 16 Featured Posts Called Shot Master

Wow....they should be much happier they are dealing with a church rather than a Walmart box store, a Hooters, or some sort of adult entertainment store.  (Not placing Walmarts in the same category as the other two....but those are the types of places that generally draws huge controversy not a church. 

6:34am • #23
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Gretchen, the problem with some regulation is that it is subject to too much interpretation. We have conditional use permits here for a lot of things. CUPs are negotiated approval and as different powers come into office the ordinances are interpreted differently. Good planning is clear and easy to understand. Thanks for the comment.

6:36am • #24
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Judi, I hope not. We should have freedoms of religion in the USA.

6:37am • #25
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Carla - There are height restriction variances granted for wind turbines. Agricultural grain silos are allowed up to 60 feet. The height of the steeple is not the real issue.

6:39am • #26
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Tony, thank you for the clarification. I hope the people of our county will become more informed about the real facts and quit listening to the propaganda machine of VARD.

6:42am • #27
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Bob - For the record. I am pro distillery and pro Church. This is America - I thought we had the right to choose.

6:43am • #28
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Hey Ron - Some will drink Vodka on Saturday and take Sacrament on Sunday. :)

6:44am • #29
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Thank you all for your comments. The most important thing today is to become aware of the issues and take part in our government at every level. Vote - it is the greatest opportunity for your voice to be heard. If you don't vote do you have the right to complain?

6:46am • #30
114,429 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

EXACTLY  Sondra. Thank you.

6:47am • #31

20 Most Recent Comments Displayed Show All


What does the graphic say?
Leave a response…


(optional)
Spam Prevention:
 
Harley_1 Rainmaker_large

Harley Wilcox

Harley Wilcox

Victor, ID

More about me…

West Group Real Estate

Address: 73 North Main, Box 362, Victor, Idaho , 83455

Office Phone: (208) 787-4554

Cell Phone: (208) 709-4555

Email Me

Harley Wilcox: Investing, Selling and Buying Real Estate


Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find ID real estate agents and Victor real estate on ActiveRain.