The thing I love about real estate is that it allows you to leverage your money.  Here's what I mean.

Let's say that you have $40,000 to invest. 

Option 1.  You find an income producing property, maybe a little run down that is only $200,000.  You put 15% down, or $30,000 and still have $2,000 for closing costs and $8,000 for upgrades. 

Option 2.  You invest it into the stock market.  Say $20,000 in mutual funds and $20,000 into an aggressive stock.

Now, move forward one month.

Option 1.  The mortgage payment, even with PMI at today's interest rates is around $1070/month.  This home in my local area, this house would rent for $1200-$1250/month.  And yes, there are deals for $200,000 in my area that are habitable!

Now, there is enough money to pay your mortgage and other monthly expenses associated with this property.  The upgrades also added additional value to the home, so let's say you just made an instant $20,000. 

You now have a financially independent asset that is not only bringing you a small monthly income, but it continually appreciating.  (Yes, in Snohomish County, WA we are still appreciating in our prices and will continue to do so.)

With the "active appreciation" from the upgrades, you now have a property worth $220,000.  Your total equity is $60,000, all from your $40,000 investment.  Not too bad after 30 days.

Option 2.  Let's be aggressive and say the stocks have increased 10% but the mutual fund hasn't moved much.  You now have $42,000 in that market from your $40,000 investment.  Only $2,000 in 30 days?  I don't know if that is even minimum wage.

See how that works?  By leveraging your money, you are able to create more money, more quickly.  Even if your stocks increased dramatically, you will still have to wait a long time to see the same level of profit.  This is why leveraging your money is so perfect!

Now, what happens if eventually the stocks crash and are worthless?  What happened to your investment in the stock market?  Your real estate investment will still be physically sitting there and is far less likely to lose money.  You can even drive by it and take a look, just to be sure it's safe.

Why do you think that interest rates are far lower for mortgages than for personal loans?  Your bankers know that real estate is a safe investment.  The safer the investment, the more likely they are to write you a check.

Just for fun, let's look at it backwards.  Between March 2000 and October 2002, the Nasdaq fell 78 percent.  Since that time, there have been multiple instances of fraud and manipulation by stock brokers and promoters.  That means your $40,000 is now worth $9,240 after the loss.

When was the last time you saw a piece of property lose 78 percent of its value?  Ever in just over a year?  Even if it did, your $40,000 is worth $48,400 - still ahead of where you started.

Want to know the best part about this?  Take a look out a couple years when the investment property has appreciated even more.  Now you can pull equity from that home to invest it into another property.  Not only are you leveraging your money, but it's kind of like recycling too.  And, I like things that are good for the environment and my pocket book.

I'm not saying investment properties are for everyone; they certainly can be a lot of work and are a huge liability.  Done right, they are profitable.  If you're ready to make money with the equity in your home, let me know.  There are great deals in every market; you just have to know where to look.

Jen Hudson, GRI (360) 652-1200 or jen@jenhudsonhomes.com

 
This post has been included in Washington Information Snohomish County, WA Information
Post is included in group: Puget Sound - WA Real Estate

50 Comments on Why Real Estate is Better than Stocks.

DEC
29
2007
245,448 Points 1 Featured Post Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
Here Here, Real estate will always be better as a long term investment. My goal in 2008 is to pick up a property or hopefully two and take advantage of this great market.
5:49pm • #1
233,030 Points 11 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
Jen - great post! I have never lost money in real estate but I have in "the market" :)
5:55pm • #2
232,937 Points 9 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
Jen - excellent post - I love the working backwards part, too!  All the best for 2008!
5:55pm • #3
162,273 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
As my Granddad always used to say, "things come and go, companies rise and fall, but good land can raise generations!"
6:08pm • #4
374,411 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Real estate can be a very good investment, but as we can see from current events ..... it can turn around and bite you too if you are not careful.

Sean Allen

6:34pm • #5
129,752 Points Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Jen - Great Post! We should always be ready to give an account of why Real Estate is the way to go. 

Sal Poliandro - Bergen County Realtor  

6:41pm • #6
1 Featured Post

Thanks Heather! That's a great goal and is one of my as well.  I certainly plan on taking advantage of our great market here.

Thanks Jo!  I'm glad to hear that you haven't lost money in real estate yet.  I'm just waiting for the argument about "how horrible" it all is.  But, we know better.

Thanks Courtney!  The backwards part was just fun, I had to do it.

Kent, that's a great saying.  Good land can and still does raise generations in my area.  There is still a lot of farm land around our new developments.  There is something about the history that goes with it, that I just love.

Thanks Sean!  One of the tricks with investing is knowing what you are getting yourself into and knowing the market.  There are a lot of "seasoned" investors who I don't think really have an idea.

Sal, how can we not give an account why real estate is the way to go for long term investing?  That's what we are all about!

Happy Investing to all!  Oh, and a Happy New Year too.

6:54pm • #7
1 Featured Post
Real estate is absolutely the best investmnet for most people! I like to drive out and touch my money. You have more control over your investmnets and it's not a computer entry floating around.
7:04pm • #8
1 Featured Post
Thanks Wayne.  Call me old fashioned, but I feel more comfortable when I can touch my investments too.
7:20pm • #9
Outside Blog
Even though the market is a little challenging, I think real estate is a good long term investment. If I was in a position to sell my home, I would buy in this market. I think now is a great time to pick up some properties to rent as well.
8:30pm • #10
570,706 Points 34 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router
BTW, you should know that you can leverage stocks and funds, too.  The level of commitment ($$$$) determines how much you can multiply your money... but real estate is still a better long term investment.  You can live in it, or rent it and actually have someone else pay for it. 
9:26pm • #11
1 Featured Post

Thanks Pam.  I think now is definately a great time to pick up some investments.

Thanks Lane.  I'm not nearly as familiar with stocks & funds, so it is good to know you can leverage your money there too.  I know real estate, so of course, that's what I prefer.  Thanks for the tip, I'll have to look into that a little further.

9:52pm • #12
Outside Blog
Interesting perspective.  Probably good if you have the cash to cover carrying expenses on a Suzie Orman type logic. Hopefully both markets will balance out, because the current state with housing values, short sales, stocks, etc. is not good currently.  I am readng Alan Greenspan's book right now and it is fascinating.
10:30pm • #13
I honestly believe if you pick the right investment (house investment) you will always beat stocks.
10:50pm • #14
254,883 Points 34 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Very Good Advice Jen! Stock is very scary to me. I know and believe in RE and I have a pretty good gut feeling when it comes to investment property. When it comes to stock it's like the blind leading the blind. I always go with the safer bet when it's my money involved! Interesting post! Have a great 2008! Deb
10:59pm • #15
Another reason to buy real estate is there is no more dirt being manufactured and it will not go away but stocks can disappear fast as we have seen from supposedly solid stocks. So always buy dirt.
11:19pm • #16
1 Featured Post

Thanks Heather. I thought about picking up his book the other day.  I'm sure I would learn so much from it.  It's on my list to read one day. 

Thanks Kevin.  I think I'd have to agree with you there.

Thanks Debra! I'll be the first to admit that stocks are not my forte.  I have an IRA and funds set up, and they've done fairly well.  BUT, I think longer term RE is the way to go for me.

11:22pm • #17
1 Featured Post

Thanks Clark.  That's certainly true.  No one is manufacturing dirt, so what's left will always be valuable.  Along that note, half of my sales have been in vacant land, and I actually enjoy selling dirt and the potential that goes with it.

11:24pm • #18
DEC
30
2007
211,841 Points 3 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Like I tell people,this is the only form of investment that you can live in,put a roof over your head and at the same time produce income for you. Stocks,bonds,mutual funds or any other form of investment cant do that for you. Much success to you in 2008. Great post.

12:46am • #19

While I agree in principal, I must disagree about the investment in Real Estate being superior to stocks since Real Estate is not a liquid asset. Stocks can be bought and sold in a minutes notice whereas RE may take a lot of time (particularly now). If an emergency were to occur, which would you rather have?

My home in North Atlanta has increased by over 200% in 15 years while a stock I acquired about 12 years ago (AFLAC) has increased 550% in a shorter period of time and is totally liquid. A lot depends on your personal needs and financial goals. With stock, I do not have to maintain property, worry about rent collection and I avoid a lot of the hassles involved with Real Estate ownership.

Real Property should be part of an investment portfolio and can create long term income if acquired at a good price and all factors are taken into perspective. If the market continues to unwind (which I think it will) some real bargains will be available that will make good economic sense for investment with a positive cash flow without "voodoo" financing. Unfortunately, most "investors" have been only concerned with a short-term profit and are major contributors to the current state of the RE market!

 

9:17am • #20
1 Featured Post

Thanks Bill.  You bring up a good point about liquidity, which is why I would never put all my eggs in one basket.  For security and emergencies, you need something liquid.  Stocks or a money market are perfect for that.  What happens if you lose a job, a renter moves out or you need to replace the roof?  These things require cash today and you can't sell your house overnight.  But, I'm not going to rely on those accounts to really make me money.

Then, there is the longterm investment where I think you can be more creative with what you want to do.    For my investments that focus on growth, I think real estate in my area is definately a way to go.  I wouldn't try to flip any houses for a quick profit today, but if you can hold on for 5, 10, 20 years, you'll be set.  And, it depends what you want to deal with.  Having managed rentals, they are a lot more work than watching the computer screen and I wouldn't recommend it to everyone.

I don't have anything against the stock market, I just happen to like real estate more.  Thanks for reading!

10:28am • #21
174,797 Points Outside Blog
Very good analogy. Real estate trumps stocks everyday. Faster rate of return and something that's tangible. Also you can turn around and sell and hopefully make your investment or take a portion of your equity to purchase another.
10:39am • #22
1 Featured Post
Thanks Robert! I happen to like things that are tangible, especially when it comes to where I want to put my money.
11:04am • #23
124,168 Points 3 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Yep it's nice to earn interest on the bank's money as well as ours. Some basic "Rich Dad, Poor dad" philosophy.

12:01pm • #24
1 Featured Post
Thanks Al! I like your philosophy.
12:07pm • #25
3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
I love the idea of leveraging.  But I am in agreeance with some others that it is not good to put all of your eggs into one basket - real estate is much more tangible, but spreading your assets out is a good move!
2:01pm • #26
1 Featured Post
Thanks Emily.  Even I agree that you shouldn't put all your eggs in one basket and have now been inspired to write a new post that should clarify my position.  Thanks for reading!
2:23pm • #27
Jen - you did such a great job with this post.  Thank you for sharing!
2:34pm • #28

The key in real estate is that it is just that - "REAL". People always need a place to live - if you buy a cash flow, guess what that cash flow will be there. You have to remember that each piece of real estate you buy is a business upon itself. Therefore do your homework, check the schedule E, and factor in your financing before you acquire your "business."

I'll always remember what I heard when I got my first taste of the business 13 years ago, "You might as well buy real estate, because they ain't making anymore of it."

Good luck for a prosperous '08!

8:38pm • #30
1 Featured Post

Thanks Frank! I love the way you put that... Real estate is REAL.  I couldn't have said it any better.

8:48pm • #31

"Real estate trumps stocks everyday."

Why have stocks then outperformed real estate for the last 40 years? This article is misleading. You basically bent the assumptions to fit your expected answer.

I believe real estate is a good investment in any diversified portfolio, but the assessment given here between the two options is poor.

Sorry to be harsh... 

 

 

 

Andrew
9:21pm • #32
1 Featured Post

Thanks for your honest opinion Andrew. I think it comes down to what the individual is more comfortable with. I would never recommend anyone put all their money in one basket (see my article about this subject).  That isn't whay I'm trying to imply.

In addition to that, remember that real estate is local.  It certainly depends on the market you look at, but for my area, history has shown that overall real estate is a good long term investment for some of your dollars. 

Thanks for reading & Best of luck in 2008!

9:31pm • #33
Jen that was very well put. It is a good piece would you mind if I reproduced it?
10:26pm • #34
338,737 Points Outside Blog
Thanks for the post. All the best. Good information. Have a good 2008.
11:08pm • #35
DEC
31
2007

I can't agree more with your posting.  I am real estate investor full time and have this conversation with people everyday.  They believe that there home they live in is an investment and that they are safe in mutual funds.  A lot of people owned bond funds because they were safe and have lost huge chunks of their net worth in '07.  Any investment that is tied to human emotion such as the stock market is always in an inferior position to real assets.  Own businesses not paper.  The rich don't own mutual funds or regular stocks, they own businesses.  They also know how to use leverage.  If stocks were not just a game then you could borrow 80% of their value to buy them.  I am also now inspired to write a blog on this topic.

Thank you and God Bless

Steve

11:05am • #37
1 Featured Post

Thanks Graham. We might be able to work something out.

Thanks Bob & Carolin. I wish you great success in 2008 too!

Steve, Thank you! I am so glad to hear the opinion from someone who really knows real estate investing.  It's a breathe of fresh air.  Take care & best of luck in 2008.

11:11am • #38
JAN
03
2008
9 Featured Posts

A good concept, generally speaking, but two big problems with your example.

1)  A $160,000 mortgage on a property that generates $1,250 a month will generate negative cashflow.  The mortgage alone, assuming a 7% interest rate, would be around $1,070 per month.  Add to that taxes, insurance, repairs, fees, realtor commissions, and PMI.  And add to that the biggest factor of all: vacancies.  Unless you're speculating that the market will zoom I wouldn't advise a client to buy a $200,000 house that only rents for $1,250. 

2)  The instant equity argument generally doesn't work.  There are some investments, like upgrading the kitchen and bathrooms, that can add to the house almost 100% of their cost, but I'd be hesitant to advise a client that she's going to invest $8,000 in a $200,000 house and suddenly it'll be worth $220,000.  That only happens when the general tide of market appreciation is pulling all the values upwards. 

I do think, in some cases, that the real estate market beats the pants off the stock market, but only in certain markets.   In the scenario you've outlined (high property values and low rental income) the investor isn't creating a financially independent asset; he's creating an alligator that's going to be chewing on his checkbook every year and will only generate a return if the market zooms. 

And there's nothing wrong with that, by the way, as long as the buyer realizes that he's speculating. 

2:33pm • #39
1 Featured Post

Christopher, you are absolutely right on both counts.  With those numbers, this is not necessarily a property I would invest in.  The point is, it is just an example to get people thinking.

As for the instant equity, for the market today, that's a tough call and really depends.  I'll be the first to admit that in a lot of areas, upgrades mean the home sells faster and not necessarily for more money.  But, each market and even neighbor is different.

The other issue is that rents don't typically increase in line with appreciation and housing prices.  The challenge is finding a rental property that makes sense and has numbers to work.  As a side note, with the recent changes in the lending industry, I do think that rentals are going to become a lot more popular and I would invest in something long term.

It sounds like you know what you're doing.  Thanks for reading!

4:49pm • #40
9 Featured Posts
Great!  I'm always interested to read what Realtors and brokers are writing when it comes to investing in real estate.  Keep it up!
6:26pm • #41
1 Featured Post
Thanks Christopher.  Will do! 
8:23pm • #42
JAN
05
2008
I love the way you worded your blog!  It's hard for the average person to wrap their head around the fact that as an investment real estate is best becaue the percentage of your own cash being put up is minimal compared to the amount of money you receive in return when you sell.  Nicely worded I enjoyed it!
2:48pm • #43
JAN
06
2008
1 Featured Post
Thanks Ray!  I like to make things simple, it's easier that way.
12:31am • #44
JAN
17
2008
1 Featured Post

Jen,

 Very good.  You should read my "Is this loan for you?".  Along the same lines

12:56pm • #45
JAN
19
2008
1 Featured Post
Thanks Ron!  I like your article & I think the title says it all.  Some people would not be a good fit for it, but I like that you get two portfolios established, one in real estate & one in stocks if you do it right. 
2:00am • #46
JAN
20
2008

This has been a debate for a while.  In my opinion, real estate is good for someone that does not have a lot of capital to begin with.  Since you have the power of leverage, you can make a lot out of a little.  But once you have a good amount of capital to work with, I think that stocks start to get an edge as a better investment.  This is especially true if you take the time to do research on companies and invest in individual stock. 

If you look at many of the great capitalists of our time, many of them started with real estate but then made their real fortunes through investing in stock.

www.housewealthy.com

8:09pm • #47
JAN
21
2008
109,021 Points 11 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Jen, I like the general tone of your post but I would rather see a longer time frame. Real estate cannot compare with short term investments because of illiquidity and transaction costs. But long term there is no comparison. The leverage and appreciation really pay off.

Bill Roberts

9:23am • #48
FEB
04
2008
1 Featured Post

Jen-

Nice post!  Glad to see you got one featured! 

I hope to see you in another education class soon!

Live good. Be happy.

-Mimi

Mimi Osterdahl / The Muljat Group Realtors / Bellingham, Washington / www.LiveGoodBeHappy.com

10:26am • #49
MAR
13
2008
156,239 Points Localism Sponsor Outside Blog
Jen, great post. I wholeheartedly agree that investing in real estate is so much better, safer, fun and more rewarding than playing the stock market will ever be.
2:18pm • #50

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Jen Hudson - Stanwood, Camano & Arlington,WA

Stanwood, WA

More about me…

RE/MAX Signature

Office Phone: (360) 652-1200

Cell Phone: (206) 293-1005

Email Me

What you should know about real estate in Stanwood, Arlington & Camano Island, WA. And, maybe some other tips too.


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find WA real estate agents and Stanwood real estate on ActiveRain.