Special offer

Banker, Lender, or Broker?

By
Real Estate Agent with Keller Williams Grand Rapids North

Interest RateEveryone shopping for a mortgage loan wants to obtain the lowest rate possible, that's obvious.  However, I do not believe everyone knows where to shop for the lowest rate.  The actual rate a home owner ends up with will ultimately depend on the financial markets and the ability of the loan officer to properly read market conditions for the optimum timing to lock their clients rate.  However, if all elements were equal then how do you know who can offer the best deal?  There are three primary places to obtain a mortgage loan and those are from a banker, broker and lender.  Below is a brief description of each, and my opinion of their services.

The Banker: Loan officers working at a brick and morter bank where consumers also have checking or savings accounts.  These institutes might also provide additional services for consumer loans, investment choices, insurance and more. This type of mortgage operation is typically more of a corporate structure, has mutliple locations and the loan officers usually have to conform to the same rate and fee structure to keep a consistent offering between all branches. The loans offered are sold directly to the investor and not much brokering outside of the banks own product line is offered.  A positive note, bankers typically service the loan after closing so consumers can visit the branch to make payments and ask questions about their loan. A negative, bankers typically have higher rates because they have to pay for several layers of management, a large support staff, and have more buildings to maintain. 

The Broker: Loan officers working as a mortgage broker make up 50% of the loans delivered to consumers. Typically a broker will have more of a personal approach to their business since they may not have the name Low Cost Mortgage Loanrecoginiton of a large bank associated to their business. None of the loans offered will be serviced by the broker, meaning after close the consumer will need to contact the lender for questions concerning their loan.  However, the loan options offered are endless since a broker will have several lender relationships established to cover nearly any lending requirement a borrower may present. It isn't acurate to say that broker fees are higher than a banker because they are the middle man.  The fact is, a broker is a independent agent working for himself and has the ability to set his or her own fees according to their own business structure. However, a broker will almost always offer a lower rate than the banker because of the lower overhead a broker has. Little known fact; consumers receiving a rate qoute from their banker will be surprised to learn the same loan from their bank can actually carry a even lower rate by going through a broker.  

The Lender: Loan officer working as a lender has all the advantages as a broker, but also works for a company which has the ability to sell and service their own loans. Typically, these types of loans are a niche product which is a loan not being offered by the larger institutions.  

Brian Schulman
Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage, Lancaster PA - Lancaster, PA
Lancaster County PA RealEstate Expert 717-951-5552
I didn't know that the same loan from the bank can actually carry a even lower rate by going through a broker.   Interesting...
Dec 29, 2007 02:39 PM
Kevin Fase
Keller Williams Grand Rapids North - Grand Rapids, MI
Seems unbelievable, doesn't it.  Before I became a broker, I was able to compare a wholesale rate sheet from a broker who could deliver the same loan to the bank I worked at. The wholesale rates were considerably lower than what I could offer working there.
Dec 29, 2007 02:47 PM
Dave Woodson
Dave Woodson - Chesterton, IN
Not the Average Agent
I love being a broker.  I could not nor would never work for a bank. 
Dec 29, 2007 02:58 PM
Kevin Fase
Keller Williams Grand Rapids North - Grand Rapids, MI

Right on Dave. I spent too many years as a banker and wouldn't consider going back.

Dec 29, 2007 03:02 PM
Dan Moralez
Northpointe Bank - NMLS #709729 - Holland, MI
Grand Rapids & Holland, Michigan Mortgage Lending
Kevin, nice post.  However, I do believe it is painting all brokers and bankers with a wide stroke.  As a banker, I can tell you I would never work as a broker.  When you work for the right bank, not only can I compete with a broker, I can often times make a deal a broker can't.  I have worked for several banks that broker outside the bank when there is a niche product or price that is better than what we could deliver directly.  I can tell you I get plenty of referrals from brokers who can't get deals done. 

While I am not slamming brokers, I am simply saying that you can't make a blanket statement about all bankers.  Those who know what they are doing and work for the right company can give a broker a run for their money all day long, especially in today's market where wholesale and correspondent lenders are dropping like flies.  While I agree that many in our business are order takers, there are those, whether they be brokers or bankers that truly are professionals who earnestly have their clients best interest at heart.  After all, the best rate on the wrong mortgage is still a bad deal :)
Jan 28, 2008 03:23 PM
Kevin Fase
Keller Williams Grand Rapids North - Grand Rapids, MI
Thanks for the comment Dan.  I appreciate you reading my blog and welcome your feedback.  My intent was to be broad with a quick read.  To go into depth would have required a longer blog and I didn't want to lose the readers interest with a 10 minute article. I understand there are many great banks around Grand Rapids with loan officers doing a great service and a lot of business. Especially those offering niche prodcuts. No doubt, you are obviously part of that elite group doing a great job and an exemption to my blog. "In general" and certainly not all banks, as my blog states, who offer conventional and government loans will have higher rates than what a broker will offer.   Keep doing a great job!
Jan 29, 2008 05:24 AM