In Texas home buyers almost always get a free home warranty, courtesy of the seller. The average price is from $300-$450. Each company offers an opportunity to pay more so you can have extra items covered, like pipes and pool equipment.
When we bought our current home I opted for the pool coverage, and all it's equipment - so I thought. My main booster pump was covered but the Polaris motor pump wasn't. Guess which one went out? The next time we called a rep out we were denied because we hadn't changed out our A/C filter in what he said was... "recently."
So are all home warranty companies worthless? Do they all dodge replacing or fixing everything? I have to remind myself daily that they are only collecting about $400 a year from each customer. If they went around replacing water heaters and air conditioners at the drop of a dime there's a good chance they'd be out of business a lot sooner. So how in the heck are these guys profitable? What is the trick/game/secret?
Here's a little advice I've learned along the way:
1. After you purchase your home, SAVE your inspection report.
2. Get your a/c, water heater & other warrantable items serviced on a regular basis - save your paid invoices & receipts.
3. Change all filters on a regular basis, in accordance to the manufacturer.
4. Read your home warranty and every little letter on each page. Know what you're paying for so you can understand what to expect. The seller will only pay for one years coverage when you buy a home, rarely more.
5. Don't go cheap! You get what you pay for in real estate and more often than not, the "cheapest way" isn't necessarily the best!
6. Purchase the pre-existing coverage if offered.
Don't expect home warranties to automatically fix or replace anything. It's YOUR responsibility to read your documents and follow through with ongoing maintenance. Realtors have more exposure to home warranties than title companies.
Any Realtor who financially benefits from suggesting a Home Warranty is required to disclose such benefits. The Home Warranty company I often suggest, Home Warranty of America gives me nothing each time I refer them. I simply trust their good history and level of trust.
Houston Newsletter
Our Super Cool Listings
Homes We've Sold

The information contained in this blog is believed to be reliable and while every effort is made to assure that the information is as accurate as possible, the author of this blog, and its comments disclaim any implied warranty or representation about it's accuracy, completeness or appropriateness for any particular purpose. All information is copywritten and the property of Greg Nino.
7 Comments on Are Home Warranties Worth A Damn? IMHO * Not for rental homes
Thank you for reblogging the post. I had missed the original post.
I have heard that about the Warranty companies and rentals, 4 hrs( many times even longer) is a long time when you have some major issues
Great points to bring it and unfortunately those things happen. It seems always when its most inconvenient too...
Wallace,
We don't take them either. They typically end up costing the owner additional $$, wasterd time and tenants will walk or not renew over them.
I don't recommend them to sellers or buyers either. I just haven't found them to be that helpful, as they essentially do everything they can to avoid paying for things!!!! If they paid for all items they couldn't possibly be profitable.
All the best, Michelle
A home warranty is only as good as the company itself. I have been promoting a few but learned recently of some issues with what Greg said. I found one that has an outstanding 35 year track record of paying claims and has a 5* rating. I guess I'll be recommending them now.
We use Old Republic so I am very happy cannot tell you how many new A/c Units I have gotten in the last 17 years. I tell the repair people to call my yard man when they are headed that way and he supervises. For $36. a month you can get a lot of repairs done.
Tenants do not like waiting for that 4 hour window. Come on people! Time is money.
Login or register to leave a comment