Well as you know I received my first listing appointment from my web site the other day, and was I excited! Being new, I wanted to do the best job as possible on the prospective client's home comps. I had our title company pull the title records and went from there. No worries.

First, the owners had only been in the home for only a year, and our market has been a little flat lately, listings are on the market close to 100 days, and lots of price drops, or concessions being given out. So I was concerned for any equity that they might have would be eaten with all the closing costs and commissions. Still blissful.

Also there is possible capitol gains to worry about for not living in the home 2 or more years, and California passed a law last year to hold 3 1/3% against any capitol gains state tax that might be due, also to be held in account. This was aimed at the flippers, because they weren't paying their state capitol gain taxes. Now I was starting to get a little worried.

In talking to the clients, they wanted to move for job reasons, and the move was more than 50+ miles away. They had put $20,000 down, and had a 1st and 2nd. They had only paid the interest on these loans so far. The original purchase price was $455,000. The house was in beautiful condition and had lots of upgrades through out. This  was a 2 story 3000+ sq ft 4 bedroom, 3 bath home, in a fairly new subdivision, and new ones being built all around the close vicinity. More worries.

I searched for comps just in the subdivision of the home, and found quite a lot of homes active, sold, or expired, with 2 pending as well. I found 2 model matches on the market, 1 at $475,000 and one at $484,900 - $494,900 (value ranged ala  Broker Bryant). And the new homes being built just up the street were being offered at $475,000 with upgrades and $20,000 for closing costs. The two matches had been on the market 85+ days each, and both had price reductions. Now a headache was starting.

Talking to the home owner, they informed me that one agent had already been out for an interview, and given them a value of $499,000. They didn't like that number! They needed more so they could get some equity, in order to buy a new home. So I really looked at the comps in the area and taking into account that they wanted to move quickly, the $499,000 amount wasn't all that bad in our market, in fact it was probably high. And I know they didn't want to be on the market more than 90 days. Give me some alka-seltzer!

In the span of a few days, I went from Everest to Death Valley. 

p.s. The numbers stated above are just a little off, too protect the innocent.

 

 
Post is included in group: Tarbell, Realtors Group

5 Comments on My First Listing Comps.

JAN
29
2007
1 Featured Post

Michael,

We know that sellers want the most for their money, but we need to educate them about the market condition on their area, I learned my lesson very well about some properties that I started listing, when I tried to do what they wanted to do and for that reason, homes are not sold, because we need to help seller to contribute with the set of the price for good.

Good Luck

 

Thanks Ray, yes I want to consider myself more of a consultant, than a salesperson. Just to be honest and upstanding with my clients.

6:46pm • #1
1 Featured Post

Michael, At least you got to practice:) It definitely sounds like these folks are ina bad situation. You did the right thing. NEVER take a listing you can't sell. There will be more. Keep on truckin"

BTW thanks for the link.

 

Thanks BB, yes it was a lot of work, but I enjoyed it!  One of the homes in my comp was by an agent with my company. The house started out at a higher price and dropped 2 times without a call. Then she value ranged it and has started to get calls. 

8:51pm • #2
1 Featured Post

Michael,Not

Death Valley.  If you lose the educational enterprise on this one, you are just Readily Available for the next prospect.  And you have a story to tell from personal experience.   also, document your proposed price, track the sale, and see how close you were.  You can tell folks, "I tried to tell them..."

"NEXT!"

BTW, ever take any crap about your name?  I like your initials...

Mike J.

 

Thanks MJ, I like yours too!  Knowledge is always good to pick up, hence I enjoy being on AR for all the great inspiration. And my emotions went from very excited to slight depression, hence the metaphor.

9:10pm • #3
1 Featured Post

Sounds like two things here...

1. The other price opinion may have been given to "buy the listing", which most likely gave the seller a false expectation of the market value of their home

2.  "Short sale" if the listing does sell - meaning you probably wouldn't get paid - yikes!  Make it a habit when interviewing a seller to ask what their 1st mortgage & 2nd (if applicable) is and then calculate it against market value, closing costs and real estate fees to see what they may net.

Good luck!

 

Thanks Art, the first comp didn't seem to be too off for a "normal" market condition, and they did have a little equity, but I think it might have been dipped into if they didn't get the price they wanted their home to sell for.

11:51pm • #4
1 Featured Post

Michael, I have seen these in  our area. I try to build a relationship for referrals as I give them honest information. I further tell them that they can contact me but as I know they will lsit with the agent that will tell them what they want to hear I will be unable to call them while they are under contract. So if they want an honest answer or two to either call or email me after they sign that contract. I will lay it out and show them what is selling and why and impress with them not to be placed in a spot where they have no choice.

In other words an honest written evaluation then walk away knowing you are not that lying %$%#@ agent who will just take the listing. Then ask them to referr me to people that would like an honest agent. Just do the best I can and walk. Who knows some good may come of it....

 

Hello Doug, thanks for the comment. There was a lot more to be considerd here than just the selling price, or the wanna be selling price. Honesty always!

11:58pm • #5

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Michael Jordan

Murrieta, CA

More about me…

Tarbell, REALTORS

Address: 39815 Alta Murrieta Drive, Suite C1, Murrieta, CA, 92563

Office Phone: (951) 698-0699 x 311

Cell Phone: (951) 816-8335

Email Me



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find CA real estate agents and Murrieta real estate on ActiveRain.