Special offer

Are Based on Sold Price Re-Assessments Ethical?

By
Real Estate Agent with RE/MAX Five Star Realty

On the heels of the recent "Sold Properties" re-assessment appeals being initiated by several local school districts, the local Penn State University Campus located in Schuylkill Haven PA recently hosted a forum were invited Legislators listened to and questioned several local Realtors & Appraisors attemps to plain language a legal nightmare.  Based on the trouble the politicians had understanding the vocabulary and concepts of re-assessment Appeals based on Sold Price vs. Spot Assessment, I became convinced that our representatives were not up to snuff on the mechanics of the on-going School Districts attempts to raise financial dollars through what I copnsider, is an obvoiusly unethical if not illegal process.

While continued efforts to achieve the No-Child Left Behind goals of our governor are admirable, the open-handed "Welcome to Our County...Here's your New Tax Bill" mentality of the School Districts is rapidly shrinking County competivness in both economic and consumers levels.

Based on Sold Price re-assessment offers nothing in consideration as towards the quality of quantity of the home, put places the onus on the amount of money a ready, willing and buyers was prepared to pay for the home. Nor does it account for the fact of whether the property value was increased do to a lack of available product options.

Let's suppose you are an aspiring boro-employee or a teacher and will need to reside in the District in which you were are be newly employed. At the time when you needed to purchase a home there is only one available to fit your family needs. But there were 2 other buyers who also needed the property for similar reasons. A price war ensues...market value rises, but only temporarily. This is evident by the thousands of upside-down mortgage holders filling the news every day.

This temporary inflation of Market Values holds no fairness for the Buyer, when several existing properties of like kind and design are located only doors away, yet continue to pay the pre-determined taxes. Some increases initiated by the Districts have reached as high a 110%.

A complete overhaul of Property Real Estate Taxes is desperatly needed throughout Pennsylvania. The continued Appeal of Based on Sold Price Property Values is an unethical travisty and is quickly becoming an economic roadblock to the very growth and expansion it was meant to support.

 

R. B. "Bob" Mitchell - Loan Officer Raleigh/Durham
Bank of England (NMLS#418481) - Raleigh, NC
Bob Mitchell (NMLS#1046286)

I don't get it...if they don't base the assessment upon "sold price property values" what would they base the value upon?  True, it sucks when the values go up and you have to pay more tax, but if values go down....you would hope at least, that taxes would go down as well?

 

Bob Mitchell

ValueList Real Estate Services, Inc. 

Feb 27, 2008 04:56 AM
Dave Stramara
RE/MAX Five Star Realty - Orwigsburg, PA
REALTOR, RE/MAX Five Star Realty

There's the rub...This is not an assessment, this is an obscure legal but unethical loophole, an appeal by a government agency, in this case the school districts, to re-assess individual properties based on what the property recently sold for. The time frame for any party to to appeal is limited to 1 year.

Re-ssessement is the legal authorized general reveiw and adjustment of all the properties in a venue initiated by the counties assessment office in order to adjust and apply milleage factors.  Condition not price.  A re-assessment can also be initiated by an owners application for a remodeling permit authorizing an increase the square footage of a structure's exterior footprint.  Size not price.

This "spot" appeal has no regard for your neighbor who has a duplicate property or even nicer.

Let's say both your neighbors home and yours are duplicates. Both of you paid $Xk in 1990. You had exactly the same taxes. You sell your home because your family needs dictate a change. Due to temprary market value increases, "the bubble", the buyer of your home is paying an increased price for the home. The new buyer of your home has been summoned to court to have his taxes appealedby the local school district. He loses, due to court uniformity, his taxes for the exact same home your neighbor has are 59% higher. Same home, same condition, same sq footage, different price.

Sounds like a penalty or even smacks of discrimination against home buyers.

Let's say these buyers were your parents on a fixed income, and bought the home to downsize and economize. BAM!! School District Appeals have knocked them into an unforeseen higher price bracket. We are seeing monthly hits of 59% increase and up on a regular basis.

No...taxes don't go down...not without a lawyer and an appeal and so-on

...and the "Bubble" is leaking...you can't sell to recoup but only take a loss and get out.

 

Feb 28, 2008 02:29 AM
Michael J. Perry
KW Elite - Lancaster, PA
Lancaster, PA Relo Specialist

Google "Common Level ratio _______  Co.  . Our RELO message  - http://actvra.in/4jHG

Jul 18, 2014 11:46 PM
Anonymous
Himanshu mishra

Nice article from here you will know about mesothelioma in biphasic cancer so our article may helps you to get causes it's symptoms and it's diagnostic from here.

May 21, 2019 11:01 PM
#4