...with little hope of becoming a beautiful swan.  While companies like AmNet (American Mortgage Network) were busy originating 100% loans in the form of 80/20s and Pick-a-Pays, it was Countrywide who was buying and servicing the loans.

That portfolio, a beautiful swan in 2005, has become the industry's biggest ugly duckling.  Late payments on option ARMs, according to today's Wall Street Journal, are increasing in the lender's portfolio, as are mortgage lates in conventional A-paper loans and subprime loans in the portfolio.

According to it's annual filing with the SEC, Countrywide said that 71% of it's borrowers with Option ARM mortgages were making the minimal (less than interest only) payment on these loans.  That means that the principal balance of the loan increases every month.  This is happening at the same time that the underlying security for the loan--the home which is mortgaged--is decreasing in value.  Fully half of the loan volume owned and being serviced by Countrywide is concentrated in two states--Florida and California.

Only last October, CEO Angelo Mozilo was predicting a fourth quarter profit.  That disappeared when unanticipated losses on HELOCs originated or purchased by Countrywide hit more than $700 million.  Further losses loom.  Because borrowers can pay down HELOCs, and then draw down the money again, Countrywide is quoted by WSJ's James Hagerty as saying that the "maximum obligation cannot be defined."

When risk can't be defined, the value of the underlying portfolio is affected, sometimes disastrously.  Bank of America may yet rue its $4 billion acquisition of Countrywide.

And that's the opinion of this Tucson, Arizona mortgage lender,

Mike in Tucson
Mike Jones (Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC): Loan Officer in Tucson, Pima County, Arizona

photo courtesy of Wikipedia

 
Post is included in group: All About Mortgages/Mortgage Networking

24 Comments on Countrywide's Portfolio of Loans is the Ugly Duckling...

I agree.  Did you hear of him selling all his shares too? Talk about insider trading...

03/03/2008 09:13 PM by David Buck (RE/MAX 808 Realty)


Mike:  This is an unbelievable statistic: 71% of it's borrowers with Option ARM mortgages were making the minimal (less than interest only) payment on these loans!  Someone seriously needs to reach these consumers and teach them simple economics.  I'm with you on the BOA possibly having 'Buyer's Remorse'!!

 

03/03/2008 09:33 PM by Debe Maxwell (Helen Adams Realty)


Debe,

The next two or three quarters will not likely reverse the trend.

David,

I hadn't read that, but then again, I don't get out much.  LOL

Mike in Tucson

03/03/2008 10:14 PM by Mike Jones (Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC)


Mike, I've thought since day one that the BoA deal seemed like a bad move. Time will tell, but it's certainly not getting any prettier.

03/03/2008 10:39 PM by Maple Valley WA Broker/Owner Colleen Fischesser 425-432-5400 (RE/MAX Select Real Estate)


This is interesting because during the hey day, Countrywide was among the most difficult to get people approved through.

03/03/2008 11:07 PM by The Best Spot Realty/Norris Lake Real Estate/Ooltewah Real E


Mike, I thought CW was moving to lock down borrowers ability to tap into their HELOC... seems like I read something from them a few weeks ago. Was this a limited shift in policy or did it just not materialize. I would think shutting down that LoC would be an immediate concern... why keep extending money on an asset that's decreasing in value by the moment?

03/04/2008 01:16 AM by Fairbanks Real Estate Broker Jesse Clifton (Jesse & Kathy Clifton, REALTORS - 907.699.6024 - )


Mike,

The fact that a whopping 71% of homeowners with option ARM mortgages are only paying the minimum presents a grave danger to Countrywide's portfolio. In that light Bank of America's purchase of Countrywide appears a bit treacherous.

03/04/2008 01:31 AM by Esko Kiuru - Las Vegas NV Mortgage Consultant (Sinifox Financial)


Mike:  I'm parked here to read comments and learn more about your industry and all that is going on with subprime and option ARM mortgages.  The effects are far reaching.

03/04/2008 02:29 AM by Donna Yates, Georgia Realtor North Georgia Blue Ridge Real Estate (Mountain Investments of North Georgia)


Mike, What an amazing stat!.  I am sorry I really did not see that one. Thank you for letting us know.  The option arm is not a bad loan. However, to many bad LO's places people in them and never explained how it worked.

03/04/2008 06:17 AM by My Favorite Mortgage.net - Matthew J Blum


Mike, Indeed, I wonder if Bank of America is biting it's nails.  (Does that make sense?  Do banks have fingernails?)

03/04/2008 06:29 AM by Bradenton Florida Real Estate - Dan Forbes (Sarasota Metro Properties)


great post Mike. I gues B of A thought they were buying at a bottom price otherwise it does not make sense

03/04/2008 07:30 AM by


Mike!  Bernanke thinks foreclosures could add to the housing inventory problems!  Who knew?  CW is not the only one with "stinky" portfolios though - the pension funds are the ones I'm concerned about.  Many of the funds purchase mortgage loans - and when they start loosing values - I think things will get worse.

03/04/2008 08:22 AM by Eleanor Thorne, Cary Mortgage Loans (Meridian Residential)


Mike - this is interesting - I feel so sorry for all the homeowners that got caught up in this mess!

03/04/2008 09:08 AM by Bill & Barbara Jo - Florida Realty Professional - AHWD (Charles Rutenberg Realty)


There is a "ton" of chatter out there about the 2nd wave of mortgage losses coming in the next 12 months from ALT-A Pools and Option Arm pools; ALT-A bonds are trading at 70cents on the dollar right now, and a year ago they were trading at PAR.

Watch what happens with Thornburg Mortgage...their margin calls (which they can't keep paying) are going to spread to other folks as well...the next tipping point unfortunately!

03/04/2008 10:13 AM by Rich Sweum (Homestead Mortgage)


Mike, I feel Countrywide is under a lot of management pressure to approve only A+ paper quality loans.  In the last 2 months, I have had nothing but trouble trying to get loans approved by them.

03/04/2008 12:06 PM by Kevin Fase, Senior Loan Officer (Chase)


Kevin,

I haven't submitted a loan to CWBC since last fall, but I hear that they're still pumping 50,000 loans a month through the system.  Applications, though, are double that number, so there's significant fallout.

Rich,

Thanks for the heads up on Thornburg.  We'll keep our eyes peeled.

Bill & Barbara Jo,

A lot of borrowers don't deserve your pity.  I turned down one young woman in 2006 who had bought a condo, and wanted to buy a second to flip it.  Knowing her financial situation, I suggested that she wait a little before biting off the second condo.  "What?"  she asked.  "I'm going to lose, like, three or four months appreciation."  She went somewhere else, bought the condo, held them both too long, and went bankrupt last fall.  Poor homeowner?  Not!

Eleanor,

Bernanke is urging banks to forgive a portion of their mortgage portfolios where the borrower is at risk of default.  Let's see how many line up for this!

Dan,

Biting them to the quick, I would guess.

Matt,

I'm in agreement with you on this!

Donna,

You're getting your money's worth.  Put another quarter in the parking meter!

Esko,

B of A made a bad bet.  It went south on them.

Jesse,

They tried to do that.  Unfortunately for them, the HELOC is a contract.  Contract law prevails.

Gayle,

I didn't originate many loans through Countrywide during the heyday, but the wall street firms whose money I lent sold the paper to Countrywide.

Colleen,

Can you say "Ugly?"  That's the picture.  Thanks for commenting.

Mike in Tucson

03/04/2008 02:41 PM by Mike Jones (Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC)


Mike.... I don't see the BofA deal happening and stuff like this makes more sense to why it wouldn't go through.  And in regards to Kevin's comment, right above your "polar bear in the snow storm" comment... why even use them when their pricing sucks. They are literally 1 1/4 pt off than many other investors. Gee, that means that you could either make more or get your client a better deal.  Just my .02... but I love stats as these.

Overall, it just showed that this was a toxic loan because too many loan officers sold it to make money and I would put money on it, that they sold the client, never really showing the worse case scenario... and if anything, telling them that it won't ever get that bad nor go up in payment... what clients always want to hear, right?  Good news that can't be predicted...  lol   Sad, but so true...

jeff belonger

03/04/2008 06:02 PM by Jeff Belonger -- The FHA Expert.com -- FHA Loans -- FHA mortgages -- Mortgages (Infinity Home Mortgage Company, Inc)


Jeff,

I don't see them backing out.  Thanks for a thoughtful comment.

Mike in Tucson

03/04/2008 08:05 PM by Mike Jones (Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC)


Jeff and Mike, I think that the end result will be BofA buys the Bank side of CW, cherry picks the loan production channels from the mortgage side that are profitable, and jetisons the rest.  With the pending lawsuits from shareholders, I don't see any portion of the acquisition being completed until 2009.  The shareholders are arguing that the buyout price is too low, and if I held stock, I would argue that as well.  I'm not a shareholder, and personally think that CW stock is worthless.

03/05/2008 01:02 PM by Rich Sweum (Homestead Mortgage)


Countrywide is not alone doing the Option-ARMS.  Washington Mutual, actually has a bigger percentage of these loans.  Countrywide always gets scrutinized since we are the biggest lender out there.

B of A got a bargain at $4billion.  Anyone who can't see that obviously is not familiar with Countrywide, the company.  The company is not as in bad of shape as the media potrays.  You have a right to your opinion and I'm obviously biased since I work for Countrywide, but we will see who is still standing when the smoke clears.

If you guessed B of A and Countrywide, you are correct.

03/05/2008 03:07 PM by Marc DeSantis (Countrywide Home Loans)


I'll be curious to hear how Mozillo explains all this to Congress in the upcoming hearings.

03/07/2008 08:08 AM by Kathie Morgan


Mike,

I have to agree with Jeff I also do not see the Countrywide deal happening.

I also am curious to see how all of this mess is going to pan out over the next months to come.  I was told by my appraiser that over 1 million ARM loans are to mature in September 2008.  What will happen when this starts?

03/07/2008 04:12 PM by Gary Miljour - Mortgage Lending for Tempe Arizona (Cherry Creek Mortgage Company)


I love the photo in this blog. 

03/12/2008 09:18 PM by Lu Kalaj (The Michigan Group)


Thanks, Lu!

Gary,

It will keep us all on the edge of our seats, no doubt.  New foreclosure numbers come out tomorrow.

Kathie,

They'll be too busy talking about the governor of New York and his sex scandal to notice!  LOL

Marc,

I hate to disagree, but they just got taken.

Rich,

I'm not buying any.  We'll see how this pans out.

Mike in Tucson

03/12/2008 10:26 PM by Mike Jones (Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC)


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Loan Officer: Mike Jones (Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC)
Mike Jones
Tucson, AZ
More about me…
Tucson Mortgage Company, LLC

Office Phone: (520) 320-3683
Cell Phone: (520) 349-9090
Email Me

kvoa.com

screen resolution stats


Links

Tags (Tag Cloud)

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find AZ real estate agents and Tucson real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved