It's pretty easy... 

John ConyersHouse of Representatives Democrat John Conyers of Michigan knows how to do it.  He has outlined a simple plan. 

  • Allow bankruptcy judges to set aside mortgage balances in favor of "good faith attempt" to pay off mortgages... and the borrower gets to keep the house. 

While the plan has been modified to only include certain mortgages, it would still be devastating in SO many ways.  It would literally destroy the dream of home ownership as well as the entire US economy.  People would wish of rthe days of the Great Depression if Conyers got his way.  

Some of the results would be:

  • Mortgage rates that would look like credit card rates.

The credit card issuers do not have protection via secured assets that mortgage lenders have.  So, they know that a consumer that declares bankruptcy can walk away with the "stuff" and leave the creditor holding the bill.  So, they have to set their rates accordingly.  If homes were treated the same way, and the debt could be set aside without the loss of the asset to the borrower, mortgage lenders would have to set their rates to account for THAT risk... Hello 18.9% mortgage.

  • Difficult hoops to jump through for a mortgage.

Image the type of approval process one would have to go through for a mortgage if the borrower could later just walk away and leave the lender with the debt...

  • Absolute destruction of home value and equity.

So, very few people can qualify for a mortgage.  If you think it is slow now, wait until only 3% of the would be buyers can get a mortgage.  Prices would crash and then burn... and then crash some more.  

  • And then building would stop. 

Not slow.  Stop.  How would a builder compete when existing home prices drop 60 or 70%?  Not to mention that demand would be all but zero, since so few people could qualify for a loan.  

  • Now comes the jobs crash.

Construction jobs would all but dry up.  Mortgage jobs would be toast.  Real Estate agent would drop like flies.  Right there we have added another 5 or 6% to the unemployment line.  When we start adding in the jobs that are dependent on those workers, add another 5 or 6%.  Does a 15% unemployment rate sound like a good idea?

  • But there is one segment that would rally like no other.

Companies that rent property would have a boom.   Since the demand to buy would have to remain pent up, and buyers would not be able to qualify, it would be an incredible time to own rental property.  Those rental owners would be able to jack their rates freely.  In effect they would have a captive consumer base.  Supply and Demand would not work in the favor of the consumer.  

One day the people in DC will learn about unintended consequences.  While trying to help a few people that made poor decisions, they quite literally have the capability of sending all of us down a path to economic ruin.  And they don't seem to understand it.  

As stated here previously, the market WILL deal with this issue in the most efficient and least damaging manner.  People WILL be hurt, but fewer will be hurt by the actions of the market than will be hurt by those trying to "fix" it.

Feel free to visit Rep. John Conyers (D-MI) web page to see the new version of the plan.    

 
Post is included in group: Silent Majority

9 Comments on Want to destroy the economy and dreams of home ownership?

Lane- I heard a talk show on this, they said all the same things that you said. If this is allowed to happen we are in trouble.

03/05/2008 01:54 PM by Solaris Realty


Pam - In all fairness, the plan has been changed to just be for "high risk" mortgages... but it still carries a lot of risk to the market.  It sets a VERY bad precedent. 

03/05/2008 01:57 PM by Lane Bailey - REALTOR & Car Guy (Diamond Dwellings Realty)


Go Democrats go.  They sure know how to kill small business.  they do not live in reality.

03/05/2008 01:59 PM by Adam Brett - Fullerton, California Realtor (RE/MAX NOC)


I will be politically correct and not print what I would really like to say.  But this is as bad as some of the stupid law suits you read about.  A waste of time, money and it further rattles a market that is trying to stabilize.

03/05/2008 02:08 PM by Joyce Windschitl - MN, FL, WI & CO Mortgage Consultant (Prime Mortgage)


The government just needs to stay out of the whole situation. Period

03/05/2008 05:41 PM by Hugh Krone Sussex County NJ Century 21 Realtor (Century21BillSemmens)


Lane:

Congratulations!

This post has earned featured post status on the Silent Majority group in ActiveRain.

 

 

 

 

 

03/05/2008 08:32 PM by ยป Bill Burress Nationwide Mortgage Originator


Thank you for bringing clarity to this issue.

I'll avoid the political issue mentioned.

Hopefully less panicked heads will prevail as this issue is discussed ad infinitum in government corridors and backrooms. Then again, who will this benefit? Certainly a few "common folk" - certainly banks - now, do banks care much about one segment of their existence? only if it's major. And for some larger entities, mortgage is not a major part.

We'll see. I wait with bated breath...

gk

03/05/2008 08:34 PM by Gina Kay Landis (Real Living Realty Services)


Lane - in a post yesterday somebody mentioned that while discussing one of the current 'housing rescue' bills, a member of Barney Frank's committee was heard to ask - "So what's this PITI thing?"  Any truth to that? Would it surprise you? Good. I feel better about that then.

03/05/2008 08:42 PM by Gene Wunderlich - Selling Southwest California Homes / Temecula & Murrieta (Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage)


Adam - I wish I could say it was just them.  The GOP did oppose this, and opposes the current version as well, but they have their own business killing bills. 

Joyce - I understand.  I think that the country would be better off if Congress and other lagislative bodies took a few years off.

Hugh - But how do you REALLY feel?

Bill - Thank you.  

Gina - There is no way shape or form that this would benefit banks.  Or anyone else after the effects start to actually be felt.  

Gene - Hadn't heard it, but I wouldn't be shocked.  But, honestly, after having dealt with the staffs of legislators, they don't know a lot of things.  It's just that people expect them to.  Most people aren't expected to know as much about as many different things as they are... but they pass laws about the things they don't know about it... that is a problem.  

03/05/2008 11:26 PM by Lane Bailey - REALTOR & Car Guy (Diamond Dwellings Realty)


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Real Estate Agent: Lane Bailey - REALTOR & Car Guy (Diamond Dwellings Realty)
Lane Bailey - REALTOR & Car Guy
Lilburn, GA
More about me…
Diamond Dwellings Realty

Office Phone: (678) 279-4700
Cell Phone: (678) 200-5895
Email Me
GarageHomesUSA Logo

Links

Tags (Tag Cloud)

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find GA real estate agents and Lilburn real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved