Special offer

Just because You Believe a Home is a Good Deal Doesn't Mean it's a Good Deal for YOU

By
Real Estate Agent with Casa Latino Four Corners, REALTOR, CDPE

For those working with me or soon to work with me, YES, foreclosures/bank-owned properties CAN be a good deal and short sales CAN be nice houses and good deals but if you are a first-time buyer or if you are getting an FHA loan, PLEASE, PLEASE think first before you consider writing an offer on them.*  Just because YOU believe a bank-owned home, short sale, or pre-foreclosure is a good deal--or a STEAL--doesn't mean it's the home for you. 

What I mean is, those deals are PERFECT for the right Buyer.  Cash Buyers that are true investors are good Buyers for these homes.  Buyers that don't have to move quickly may be appropriate (many times, there are extensions to a contract and if you're needing to move now, it can get tricky).  Buyers that have at least 5% down or more are potentially good buyers for these homes.  Buyers that can stand to lose a couple bucks for inspections (if there is even any utilities turned on), have the guts to waive inspections completely (NOT a good idea for buyers, usually), or have their $1,000 of escrow money held up indefinitely can be good Buyers. 

However, if you are a first-time buyer, are using any state, federal, or city/county-sponsored down payment program or if you want to utilize AmeriDream or Nehemiah, or if you just need your closing costs paid for you, then the bank-owned/short sales are probably completely inappropriate for you.  They are typically inappropriate for financing with an FHA loan, especially if you are going to use Nehemiah or ask for any closing costs be paid for you by the seller (unless you're using the FHA 203K/"Rehab" loan). 

I'm SO sorry, but that is typically the case.  Banks won't pay closing costs and they won't make repairs.*  They are NOT in the real estate business; they are in the loaning money business.  Short sales don't work with these types of loans b/c the owner doesn't have any money to make repairs and they owe the bank more than the house is worth.  Sometimes, pre-foreclosures can work if the homeowner has equity in the property but many times, the listing agent or the Seller may not understand the process and can slow it down so much that the pre-foreclosure becomes a short sale.   

The good news is that there are a lot of other homes that are for sale in my area, so you can still get a good deal on something in spite of a lot of homes not being appropriate for you. 

So, basically, if you don't have the 5% down payment or if your credit score isn't what it needs to be to qualify for a conventional loan and you have to get an FHA loan, it's cool to buy a single family home, as long as it's not bank-owned and the owner can't be in trouble with their mortgage.  If it's a townhome ownership, that's cool and the association fees are very small usually with townhome ownership. If it's a condo that you're looking into buying, then you should make sure your real estate agent is ONLY showing you FHA-approved condos.   

A leading real estate broker in my market gives his view of foreclosures and short sale properties: 

http://activerain.com/blogsview/423281/The-Dark-Side-of  Take a look.  He's a great writer and obviously care about those he works with. 

I hope this helps. 

* Waiver:  I am not, nor have I ever been a short sale specialist, loan officer, etc.  The information contained in this blog is only my own thoughts, beliefs, and interpretations and may/may not be accurate according to some people.  :) 

Loreena and Michael Yeo
3:16 team REALTY ~ Locally-owned Prosper TX Real Estate Co. - Prosper, TX
Real Estate Agents
Lisa, this is such a great informational post. I wish more people will read this message. I have so many clients that always ask me if foreclosures are the best deals out there. Well, it depends. I also tell them it's the right house for them when their finances are right, not when or whom tell them it's right.
Mar 15, 2008 09:54 AM
Serena Brown
Taylor-Brown Real Estate - Hammond, IN
This is true.  Not all homes are eligible for FHA/VA financial.  I recently had this issue.  I had to explain to my client that if the property needs repair it will not qualify for a FHA loan, but it will, however, qualify for a FHA 203k loan.
Mar 15, 2008 09:57 AM
Lisa Spalding
Casa Latino Four Corners, REALTOR, CDPE - Longwood, FL
REALTOR, CDPE

Loreena--  Thank you for the comment.  I get (and I'm sure you do, too) SOOO many calls from people asking about properties that are great deals and that are obviously not going to be great deals for them.  A guy walked right into my office about 3 weeks ago saying he's looking for a "foreclosure deal" and couldn't tell me a price range or a realistic area, just that the home had to be a "good deal."  Eeek.  What am I supposed to do with THAT?!  A true Buyer knows WHERE (or a close area), HOW MUCH, and WHEN, or at least ONE of those.  Not "just that it has to be a great deal."  There are so many deals and steals out there right now, you can pretty much take your pick.  Well, before I get off on another tangent, let me just say thanks for the post.  :)

Serena--  Yes, I have run into this recently.  The Buyer has an out-of-state loan office, of course, which poses some problems in itself but the gist was they are first-time Buyers, wanted to buy and update a property with an FHA loan and the loan officer/company doesn't do FHA-203K rehab loans, so she told them absolutely not.  I suggested a local guy I work with that does these all the time but the Buyer will not consider him.  They would prefer to continue to work with an out-of-state lender.  Plus, many Sellers and good Seller agents will not seriously consider an out-of-town lender b/c THAT poses many problems. 

 

Mar 15, 2008 11:53 PM
Rob Arnold
Sand Dollar Realty Group, Inc. - Altamonte Springs, FL
Metro Orlando Full Service - Investor Friendly & F
You are right, the short sales and bank REOs are great deals for investors.  Often they will not work for regular owner occupant buyers.  Those buyers need to just negotiate a great deal on a regular listing.
Mar 16, 2008 03:17 AM