Ar_home_b_search
 

It has not been a slow news cycle lately and I have barely had time to digest the flow of events to bring the level of analysis needed to the issues presented.  Really interesting issues like Bear Stearns and the Second Amendment will just have to stand in line, I guess. As always I preface my comments about Senator Obama with the disclaimer that I am not likely to be voting for the man – I do not like his policies or his voting record.

I listened to Senator Obama’s speech this morning [complete text link here] concerning his association with Jeremiah Wright.  It should be noted that Pastor Wright is not a convicted felon and is not accused of anything more that speaking in a manner that is offensive to outsiders – to whom he was not directing his words at the time. 

I am appalled at the statements made by Pastor Wright which seem to be unamerican, factually incorrect and offensive to me.  But in MY America – he has the right to say what he thinks – even if it may be offensive to me. 

So we have two issues presented here.  First, how Senator Obama plans to deal with the issues of race in America and, second, whether he has displayed good judgment, as a candidate for President, by being associated with Pastor Wright. 

At a bit over sixty years of age I have gained some wisdom (the kind you get from being around a while) and have been an eager student and observer of history’s forces and events that have shaped the last half of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st.  I have been proud to live in a time of giants in the social changes that have occurred in our country.  In the American Civil Rights movement I have been inspired by Martin Luther King and Thurgood Marshall (civil rights attorney who rose to Supreme Court Justice) who both saw as their goal a color blind society that offered respect and opportunity to members of all races. 

But the next generation of Black leaders after the sixties, in my opinion, was not cut from as fine a cloth.  I have heard more racism and bigotry flowing from the self appointed black leaders than from segregationists.  The churches have been central to the Black communities and have preached hatred for the white power structure that oppressed and victimized their people for generations as a way to connect with their congregations.  In tapping into these emotional issues in this way, I believe they have perpetuated the very problems they sought to address – but the plain fact is that I do not have a damn clue what it was like to be a black man living in an urban center city or in the deep south in my country – and I will not judge Pastor Wright or the other community leaders that have had to fight and beg and claw their way just to obtain simple justice for their communities and for members of their race. 

Barack Obama is a graduate of Columbia University and Harvard Law School and was, I believe, the head of the Harvard Law Review – a title of considerable academic achievement.  The normal career path would have been a year as a law clerk for an appellate judge and then a year as a clerk for a Supreme Court Justice.  Barack Obama went back to Chicago where he had worked as a community organizer to take a job running a voter registration drive and ultimately worked as a civil rights attorney.  He met Pastor Wright as a young man (prior to Law School) working in the neighborhoods of Chicago while Wright was doing the work of his Church in the same neighborhoods.  And I would expect that in addition to the spiritual comfort that Barack Obama found in the Trinity United Church, he also found a political structure that could help him with his work and his political ambitions on a local level.  Their subsequent association of more than twenty years gave spiritual comfort to Barack Obama and his family who have lived in Church and personal relationship with their pastor in much the same way as others who have long standing relationships with their ministers.  In addition the social and political work of both men flourished as well.  I would have been surprised if there were not a strong personal bond between these two community leaders and I am sure they are both proud of the accomplishments of the other. 

I see the public persona of Senator Obama but I have little knowledge of Pastor Wright.  The list of books authored by Pastor Wright include such urban terrorist manuals as Sermons of Joy and Strength by Jeremiah Wright, Africans who shaped our Faith, Good News: Sermons of Hope for Today’s Families and Why most Black Men do not go to Church.  I have not read these books – but the titles suggest that there is more to the man than what is being presented on the news this week.

So how does all this bear on the two questions I asked at the beginning of this article. 

So far in the campaign, Senator Obama has avoided racial issues as a distraction from the issues he has preferred to feature in his presentations.  As of this morning, he has met the race issue head on.  He describes the racial problems of our country as an unfulfilled promise that a new nation made to its citizens at its founding.  I agree.  He condemns the language of the last generation of Black leaders – specifically the questioned sermons of Pastor Wright, as devisive when what is needed is unity and and not as a static remnant of the past but as an inspiration that recognized the progress that has been made and seeks to move into the future for the benefit of all Americans. 

As to the question of his association with Pastor Wright – Senator Obama condemns his racial and antisemitic language but refuses to disown the man whom he regards as family.  I respect him for it.  Mrs Clinton would have cut his throat and left him by the side of the road.  I do not view Senator Obama’s actions as weakness – I view them as loyalty, which I prize. 

But there is another issue here, and please forgive me my cynical view.  Obama is not really free to throw away Pastor Wright who is a well known part of the Black community.  To put it bluntly, he needs the votes and cannot afford at this point (shortly before the Pennsylvania primary) to insult millions of black voters that he will need in the general election. 

The new media will determine how this story plays out.  I am certainly looking forward to the first tracking polls that factor todays Obama Speech into their considerations.  I urge the readers to view Senators Obama’s speech in its entirety < link here >.  The American public will have to decide this issue.  But it appears to me that Senator Obama will enter the convention with a majority of the committed delegates. and the superdelegates will have to make a difficult decision.  Undo the results of the state elections and turn to Mrs Clinton or send forth a wounded candidate in the form of Senator Obama into the general election.  It is certain that we have not heard the last of Pastor Wright and his church. 

I wonder who is being served by the media firestorm on this topic.  Pastor Wright’s clips are offensive but not dangerous.  We objected to Muslim leaders blaming 9/11 on American actions because we were attacked by radical Muslims.  I am not sure that those words have the same impact coming from Pastor Wright.  He is wrong – but he is not advocating the overthrow of the government by force and violence. 

It is late (actually early) and I have not gone to sleep yesterday yet.  I have many friends at AR who will disagree with me on what I have said here and I would like to have time to polish this article.  But I want to present a contrarian view to what seemed to be coming from the pundits last night on the cable channels.

 I value the rhetoric of Senator Obama and the message of hope and change that he brings to the electoral process.  I value the inspiration that he brings to younger voters.  The opinions of his Pastor should not be the deciding factor about the Obama candidacy.  I take issue with his voting record and liberal beliefs which mirror Mrs Clintons – but believe his candidacy is good for America and its cultural and ethnic communities. 

 

7 Comments on Mr Obama's Problem - and Mine

MAR
19
2008
305,261 Points 17 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Attended Rain Camp Called Shot Master

Very well said.  This is a difficult issue.  Mr. Obama is personally compelling and well spoken.  He expresses the issues facing our society with a clear voice of the experience.  What is not mentioned is that Oprah also belonged to the same church and has been very quiet.  Neither coming to her candidates defense or expressing anything at all.  It has been reported she left the church for exactly the reason that peopel feel Mr. Obama should have left it.  If a preacher preaches and no one is there does the preacher get a message?

5:12am • #1
1 Featured Post Outside Blog
Sometimes the people that you support and befriend are the ones whose views you share, whether you speak it or not. If I had an offensive friend who I did not agree with, I would probably leave them alone and move on. Since he hasn't, I feel he supprts those views. He has the right to those views and his speech, and I will support his rights to the end. I just don't have to agree with him, or vote for him.
5:35am • #2
1,139,235 Points 139 Featured Posts Outside Blog Called Shot Master
Ted. You do make some valid points here, and I agree with Mariam that Obama is facing a very difficult decision. He is a charismatic person but he is still a politician that will say anything and do anything to make it to the oval office. Too bad we do not have better qualified candidates running in this race.
5:39am • #3
Thank you for the interesting read this morning. You are very well spoken on this issue. I pretty much think our next President will be Republican and most of this will be forgotten 6 months therafter. Myself I would not vote for Obama for the very reasons you have set forth here in this article. I would not vote for Hillary Clinton either so that only leaves me one other place to place my vote so that my vote will count for something. Sad as it may be, I am quite disappointed with the playing field right now and I think there are many Americans out here that feel the same way. 
7:20am • #4
389,811 Points Outside Blog
Ted, One of the many things that I find interesting is where is Rev. Wright through all this. He would have a national platform to defend himself on. He doesn't seem like the shy type to me.
9:01am • #5
188,613 Points 23 Featured Posts

Ted - If I may share a thought or two from the other side of the equation. The election process has been bamboozled again.  I often support the more liberal of candidates. At least, I thought so. I can trace those thoughts back to 1968. In the primary I worked for and supported Bobby Kennedy. In the aftermath of our spring and summer of violence, I ended up voting for Richard Nixon. The younger folks can read that and wonder but I think a close review of the revision of social programs will reveal Nixon had much to do with ending the perpetual dole and his opening doors to China is only today understood as a large step towards the ending of the reign of terror in that area of the world (Tibet may be their last hurrah).

In 2000, I could not understand why Gore was the candidate. His stiff and condescending deliver obfuscated any thing he had to say. Florida did not steal and election. The democratic convention, in their choice of a candidate, left the majority of American's no choice but to vote for the winner (the angst ridden that decry the results really need to move on or they will miss this years boat as well). In President Bush's first four years in office, he has faced more dilema's than any other President. He has been ridiculed and mocked by "monday morning" quarterbacks. He has remained steadfast in his goal of protecting this country from another attack. This seems to be lost on the pundits. The lack of a subsequent attack is used as proof that the concern is not valid. Balderdash!

I can only say that President Bush's fears are deeply rooted. Those that are critical of his methods have that right. Those that question his intent are more self centered and ignorant than the most fervent muslim radical. It is too easy to seperate the man from the position. Too many people overlook the fact that George Bush realizes that it happened on his watch. I have no doubt he lives with that realization every day. It was not his fault. It occured while he was holding the position of commander in chief. I can only imagine the enormity of that fact in his psychi.

From the head, we live in fear. I could happen again. We object to and bemoan yet still believe in the war on terror. We accept eroding civil rights in the face of the need for better knowledge and security. We do not like the infringement, but the tiny voice in the back of our mind whispers the alternative is possible death.

This is the nation today. Divided. Red and blue rich and poor, white and non white, man and woman, straight and gay, left and right, etc. are all labels which foster and feed division. Obama speaks to healing those wounds. He does it well.

I must also say that his opposition to the war was void security information that was provided to those in Washington DC. Denial today does not refute the absolute unified drum beat that was followed after 9-11. I also believe that if Gore had won the white house....he would have sent us to war as well. He may be many things, but he would have  been commander-in-chief and he would have been reading the same reports.

It shocks me that we have so easily forgotten the images of that day. We have so easily forgotten the days that followed. The days that there were no blacks, no whites, no asians, no hispanics, no democrats, no republicans, no chritians, no jews, no muslims, no atheists.....no anything here but Americans. Americans united in pain, anger and sorrow. Americans under attack. Americans united.

Obama calls on that feeling as well.

I can not say if we have become so innured to the audacity of hope that we will ignore the messenger. I can only hope that we hear the sirens song, take the call to action as our own and move forward as one nation, united in purpose towards a brighter day.

In closing this little response, I would only challenge anyone to understand that George Bush, despite his policies and procedures, has never just told American's what they wanted to hear. He has spoken from his heart exactly what he perceives the country has to hear. Many of the truths he has had to share have been drowned out by late nite humorists and political hacks and pundits. Despite all that may be wrong today, this nation remains the greatest of all.

9:12am • #6
258,086 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Hugh - in my view he will remain silent because it is the best thing he can do for the Obama campaign.  I suspect that his retirement in february 2008 (after 36 years of service) from the Trinity United Church may have been with the knowledge that this was all coming.

 

John - You get my vote.  Thank you for that

 

As I have indicated, I expect to vote for Senator McCain in November.  But there is a part of me that responds to Senator Obama's message (not his voting record) and a part of my mind's eye that wonders about the impact on our society and our position in the World of his candidacy and possible Presidency.  Senator Obama is a candidate of potentially universal appeal - and that part of his message is as important as Pastor Wright's language was onerous and outrageous.  I see the light of a candle in the window on a stormy night and I do not wish to see that light snuffed out by fear mongering or the political agenda du jour - and the tempest over Pastor Wright is both. 

I would have my candidate (Senator McCain) discuss and debate Senator Obama in the election process on their respective visions for America and the positive policy differences that separate them and their parties.  The American People (WE the People - remember them? ) can make their choice then in November, according to 220 years of law and tradition.  

Senator Obama at 46 is potentially a positive force for our culture for a generation.  His vision of inclusion and potential is important whether or not he becomes President in 2008.  We can all learn from his message and be better for it.  Let's be careful out there. 

 

10:34am • #7

This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Ted_drawing Rainmaker_large

Ted Baker - MidFloridaMediation.com

Winter Haven, FL

More about me…

Carmody and Associates LLC

Address: 305 Bay Street, Auburndale, FL, 33823

Office Phone: (863) 877-0047

Cell Phone: (863) 332-4016

Email Me

Ted Baker Carmody and Associates LLC

Blog title: Sound and Fury is from Shakespeare's Macbeth. The quote: "It is a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,
signifying nothing."

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed here are my own and do not necessarily represent the views of my employer or any group with which I may be affiliated.

Twitter ID @webted2




Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog