When speaking to Realtors, and even other mortgage brokers/lenders, etc., those that frown upon Reverse Mortgages often list their costs as way to high as one of their reasons they steer their clients away from them. As a Certified Mortgage Notary Signing Agent, I see all kinds of loans, and while I have always said that I felt their costs were in line with regular mortgages (IF you could take out the required Mortgage Insurance) I never actually sat down and computed the difference. Until now!
I do not remember how to calculate all the statistics as far as probability, and +/- differences, but here are the hard facts from about 5% of my loans. Most figures did not surprise me, some did, so here they are:
Average Reverse Mortgage Loan Amount - $205,462
Average Loan Origination Amount $4,059 - 2.0% (Highest 2%, lowest 1.8%)
Average Mortgage Insurance Amount $4,088 - 2.0%
Average other closing Amount $4,739 - 2.3%
Total closing costs $12,886 - 6.3% > > >>>(without Mortgage Insurance $8,798 - 4.3%)<<< < <
Average Regular Mortgage Loan Amount - $171,067
Average Loan Origination Amount $4,390 - 2.6% (Highest 4.9%, lowest fee 0.3% - one was 0%!)
Average Mortgage Insurance $124 - .1% Average VA Fund $24 - 0.01%
Average Amount to bring to 1st of the month $165 - .1%
Average other closing Amount $2,190 - 1.3%
Total Closing costs $6,894 - 4.0%
I noticed the loan origination fees were always the 2% maximum allowed on the Reverse Mortgages except one which was less. On the forward mortgages, they average 2.6%, and two actually impressed me and had very little origination fees - including one that had none. I wonder about that one, as maybe there was a YSP, or something just not listed anywhere, but that was how it was listed anyway! 60% exceeded 2%, so the other 40% were less than the 2% charged, as well as only 15% that were lower than the 1.5% fees - probably soon to be the maximum origination fee for Reverse Mortgages. In other words 85% charge a higher origination fee than what will likely be the Reverse Mortgage origination fee cap. Prior to doing the actual computations, I thought forward mortgages averaged a much higher rate, so that actually surprised me that it was only .6% higher than average Reverse Mortgage origination fees. Another thing that caught my attention was how the other closing costs were a bit higher on Reverse Mortgages than forward mortgages. Although, in the end, like I have been saying all along, IF you could back out the required Mortgage Insurance, the closing costs ARE right in line with all other mortgages 4.3% RM to 4.0% Regular. As I said in the beginning, without doing all the actual statistics, in my opinion, to differentiate in closing costs by only 0.3% is pretty much very close! (On $100,000 loan, that amounts to a difference of $300 - not much!!)
In my mind, I always said that the closing costs were close (without the MIP) and these statistics back up what I felt all along. Some surprises, but not too many! Of course, the MIP is required for a very good reason, and certainly with it, it does boost the final costs, but always knowing both you and your heirs will never be burdened with a loan that exceeds the value of your home is not only a requirement for a good reason, but certainly a great piece of mind!
===============================================================================
Title companies & mortgage brokers, help your borrowers- arrange to have their loan signed and notarized in their home, at their convenience by a Certified Notary Signing Agent (CNSA)
Browse The Rain for a qualified and Certified Notary Signing Agent in your area.
Southwest Florida Notaries is open for your mortgage closing 24/7 at your location (Based in Murdock, FL, near Port Charlotte FL, but covering all of Southwest Florida)
Ron,
I'm confused why you are considering MIP, since MIP is not required for loans over 80% LTV and reverse mortgages will never approach 80% LTV. Would you explain your assumptions?