I was one of those "company men" that worked and still does work for a Large comercially well known Mortgage Bank....I was set in my Ways of how I thought things worked or were supposed to work in regards to Institutional lending....I am your "typical" type A personality that thought I had it ALL figured out...

I WAS WRONG

I was Blown away when this finally sunk in....Be prepared to be shocked...continue reading....

"The Asher Institute for Consumers is a non-profit consumer advocacy organization that was formed in 2003 to educate and inform consumers about various issues so they can make informed decisions in regards to finances, banking and mortgages. The 25 page article, a.k.a. consumer guide, they wrote is entitled, "Profiting from the Banking Industry's Biggest Secret."

We will show how the mortgage profit game works and how consumers are misled into making a decision that ends up costing them their single best opportunity to be wealthy.

The Truth about the 30-Year Fixed Loan

When it comes to mortgages, most consumers are fairly knowledgeable and are able to choose between the various loan products available and select the one that best fits their needs and risk tolerance. The most highly promoted and most sought after loan is the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage.

Why? Because consumers like the stability of a low fixed rate and a low fixed payment. However, the Asher Institute revealed some shocking truths about the 30-year fixed that stunned both consumers and mortgage industry experts alike.

The Asher Institute found that only one of the two reasons consumers like the 30-year fixed mortgage was actually true.

Which one is false?

The part about the interest rate being fixed. Contrary to public opinion, the interest rate on a 30-year fixed rate mortgage is actually an ADJUSTABLE RATE MORTGAGE and the rate consumers are paying on them is much, much higher than they could ever imagine.

The rate is so high, in fact, that it completely blocks the average consumer's path to financial freedom.

In a couple of pages, you'll see an Amortization Schedule for an average American conforming loan, a $150,000 30-year loan at a "fixed" interest rate of just 6.0%. The Amortization Schedule shows how the loan really works.

Here are some of the facts gleamed from the Amortization Schedule:

  • Each year the consumer pays $10,792 but a different portion of that total gets credited to Principal and to Interest.
     
  • It takes 19 years before just half of the payment goes to Principal.
     
  • It takes 24 years before 2/3 of the monthly payment goes to Principal.
     
  • After 10 years, 84% of the starting balance is still owed.
     
  • After 21 years, half of the starting balance is still owed. (At that point, the consumer will have paid $226,800 with only $75,000 of it going to Principal.)

Amortization Schedule
$150,000 30-YEAR FIXED-RATE MORTGAGE AT 6.0%

                  "THE LENDER"           "THE CONSUMER"    PAYMENT = $899.33

           Year                      Interest                       Principal                      Balance

1

$8,949.89

$1,842.02

$148,157.98

3

$8,715.66

$2,076.25

$144,126.11

6

$8,307.30

$2,484.61

$137,096.93

9

$7,818.63

$2,973.28

$128,685.25

12

$7,233.84

$3,558.07

$118,619.16

15

$6,534.04

$4,257.87

$106,573.27

18

$5,696.60

$5,095.31

$92,158.18

21

$4,694.45

$6,097.45

$74,907.92

24

$3,495.20

$7,296.71

$54,264.88

27

$2,060.08

$8,731.83

$29,561.75

30

$342.70

$10,449.21

$0.00

The numbers are heavily skewed in favor of the lender because they are designed to be. It's due to something most consumers are familiar with - front-end load interest.

The result of this system is that the lender collects their interest first, up front. Seems fair, right? But, the Asher Institute also found that the front-end load completely throws off the fixed interest rate schedule.

Look at Year 1. The consumer pays $10,792 ($899.33x12) but only $1842 of it gets credited back to Principal.

What if this house was sold after the first year? Would it seem like 6.0% interest rate was paid? Look at what happens if we were to sell after 9 years. The consumer will have paid $97,128 but less than $21,315 will have gone to Principal. That's not a 6.0% interest rate!

The same holds true for a longer period of time like 21 and 24 years.

So if a 30-year fixed mortgage loan is kept for even 1 month less than 30 years, the rate consumers really wind up paying is higher. How much higher?

The Asher Institute came up with a formula, called the "Effective Rate Formula", that reveals what the real interest rate would be if a front-end load loan was kept for less than the entire 30-year term.

 When they applied this formula to the sample 6.0% 30-year loan, the results were scary:

  • After 25 years, the consumer would have paid almost $270K, with only $104K in loan equity. The actual rate paid would be 9.43%, not 6.0%!
     
  • After 20 years, the effective actual rate paid would be 14.82%
     
  • Holding on to that low 6.0% interest rate for 10 years would result in paying an actual 43.48% interest rate!
     
  • Holding it for 3 years yields an actual 182% rate
     
  • 1 year --> a 580% rate! <--

Hundreds of consumers and mortgage industry experts were informally polled with the following question:

If you held a 6.0% 30-year fixed-rate loan for 7 years, considering that the interest is front-end loaded and you're not waiting the 30 years, what rate do you think you'd really wind up paying?

The responses given by consumers were what spurred the Asher Institute to develop their consumer guide. Without fail, each consumer and expert guessed between 8% and 12% with an occasional high guess of "triple" which would represent 18%.

The guesses were logical but so far off that it was clear that a major misconception existed!

It was also clear that these numbers had never been disclosed to consumers. No one had ever heard of an "Effective Rate Formula" - it seemed like consumers were aware that mortgage interest is front-end loaded but no one realized exactly how front-end loaded it really is.

Due to the interest rate being front-end loaded, the rate becomes ADJUSTABLE based upon how long the loan is kept. On a 6.0% 30-year fixed, the low "fixed" 6.0% Note Rate is the absolute MINIMUM rate the consumer will pay.

Even though the monthly payment is fixed, the consumer may wind up paying as much as a 580% interest rate, thereby actually making this fixed-rate mortgage an Adjustable Rate Mortgage.

The banks have been relying upon consumers to concentrate on the fact that it will all even out 30 years later. But who keeps the same mortgage, let alone the same house, for 30 years? Nationally, homeowner's keep their mortgages for 5 years on average.

Millions of consumers believe that the 30-year mortgage is a smart home loan with many benefits.

But that belief has been very costly - Americans have been standing in line to sign up for loans that are the equivalent of giant credit cards with APR's well over 100%!

Conclusion

The Asher Institute has identified that the 30-year mortgage does not work exactly as advertised and as a result, consumers end up paying a much higher rate than they believe.

Consumers have accepted these loans partially due to a lack of information, which has misled them into shopping for the wrong product.

A solution has been identified - if consumers want the lowest rate on their home loans, they should be shopping for the shortest possible term they can qualify for, NOT the lowest Note Rate or the lowest fees. The term of the loan has more bearing on the real interest rate than any other factor.

You can overturn the banking industry's profit game by using a short-term "interest cancellation" loan (what we call an ALOC) to expedite equity growth and increase your wealth at a dramatic pace.

Find out how you can retire early - view our MMA video (Step 2) to see exactly how a Money Merge Account can help you live the American dream!   http://www.loanacceleration.net/

 

11 Comments on The Verdict is in: Your 30 Year "Fixed" Mortgage is NOT fixed.....

FEB
10
2007
12 Featured Posts

Judy is correct.  Good post - just in the wrong group.

10:36am • #1
146,716 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog

i am feeling a little deja vu

i think this was posted a while back.

 

10:37am • #2
APR
25
2007
27 Featured Posts

I have a copy of the Asher Institute report and it is a distorted look at the cost of the mortgage.  I will post a blog dealing with it in the coming days when I have time to formulate it professionally and give it credit where credit is due.

But, to say that a 30 Year fixed rate at 6% that is paid off after the first year has an "effective rate" of 580% is very misleading (chart on page 15).  It also does not take into account other issues. 

Amazingly enough, this report had in it a direct link to a MMA seller (not Keith), and a link to the the AsherInstitute.org website (which is still under construction).

Understand that I like the MMA product as it serves a purpose and works well for some people, but let's advertise it correctly.

8:41pm • #3
DEC
07
2007

With a 30 year fixed, it would be benefical to pay off extra principal early.  At what point in the length of the mortgage would it not make finacial sence to do so?  After the half-way point?

12:36am • #4
DEC
09
2007
This is not correct. 
10:09am • #5
218,391 Points 12 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Interesting... I will have to do some further research.  I have always been a fan or ARM products for most people anyway.  People move to frequently in this part of the country for a 30-yr fixed.
10:30am • #6
MAR
20
2008

this post is misleading ppl.  "A Money Merge Account"  is an idea which you will borrow money from bank just like using your credit card.  And the sample these sales providing for ppl to check out are just a misleading math trick.  In their example, you monthly income is $5000, and monthly spend is $4000.  By using that account, every couple month you will need to borrow from your bank to pay a big money towards your home load (to add more money into your principal will reduce a lot of interest), and the way you pay for it, is by using the $1000 difference between monthly income and spend.  In their example, it looks like you are using a very small interest pay for load from the merge account to save big interest for you house loadn.  BUT, is that really true?  NO, and what you really have done, is by spending $1000 more EVERY SINGLE MONTH (up to $12000 every year and plus the interest you will need to pay for your money merge account) to make your principle a big jump to short your loan period.  BUT, think about this, if you have that $12000 /year extra to pay for your house load, you can just direct pay to the loan compay which will do the same job for you. 

On the other hand, by using the Money Merge Account way, you will lose the $12000 tax deduction part for sure( because only the interest you paid every year will deduct your income tax, principle not included), you will also need to pay the high interest for the money you borrow from that Money Merge Account (up to $1000 sometimes) and also other disadvantage. 

 So far, it seems like only one advantage for this kind of account, which you can always borrow money from them just like using your credit card.  Is that really worth it?  (by the way, if accident happened, such as layoff, sick, and you can not pay for it, you will need to pay a big interest for it, lower your personal credit, loose your house, maybe broke)

 The question is do you think it worth to take such a risk and pay more that what you need to (the interest for your money merge account is an extra), loose your tax deduction benifits, no back up money for emergency?  You tell me the answer. 

 p.s. please check with your friends who is holding at least a BS degree in math to double check it.  There is no such thing money will come down from sky.

calvin
8:58am • #7
3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor
A fixed rate loan is paid at a fixed rate, every year, on the remaining balance.  This report is an attempt to juggle some numbers in a very creative way.  Did any of the authors work for Enron?        
9:19am • #8
OCT
05
2008

Well,

Can anybody tell me the actual interest rate I paid on my home if I sell it at the end of 12 months?

It certainly is not the 5.75% intrest rate I signed up for 30 years?

What if the ASHER REPORT is closer to fact?

What if the MMA is the way to go becuase it uses a lower daily balance intrest rate bank product?

What if the one's who know actually use the MMA and the ones who think they know don't own it?

Who would really be the person who knows?

Do you really want to pay $10 in interest just to have a $3 deduction?

 

 

 

 

TomyG
10:43am • #9
MAY
21

 

Hi,

 

We have just added your latest post "Real Estate Blog - The Verdict is in: Your 30 Year" to our <a href="http://www.creditca-rd.info"> Directory of Credit Cards</a>. You can check the inclusion of the post <a href="http://www.creditca-rd.info/story.php?title=real-estate-blog---the-verdict-is-in-your-30-year"> here </a> . We are delighted to invite you to submit all your future posts to the <a href="http://www.creditca-rd.info"> directory </a> for getting a huge base of visitors to your website and gaining a valuable backlink to your site.

 

 

Warm Regards

 

Credit car-d Team

 

http://www.creditca-rd.info

Harrys
9:24pm • #10
JUL
03

The Asher site seems to be gone.

A fixed rate is just that, fixed. You pay interest on what you owe. No more complex than that. Pay more to bring down the principal, but the rate won't change, not if you pay in 1 year, 10, or 30.

I am a self-admitted MMA naysayer, but right now, I feel sorry for the honest agents. You see, instead of just selling a product and pushing its benefits, the discipline they suggest can't be done alone, they also have to defend these crazy claims and disassociate themselves from this innumeracy.

In the first month of a 6% 30yr mort, $200K, the first payment of $1199.10 is exactly $1000 in interest and $199.10 principal. Are they charging you (1000/199 = 502%) over 500% interest?? Hardly. No more than in month 360 when the interest is $5.97 and principal $1193.14, they are not charging (5.97/1193 = .5%)  less than 1/2% interest. This is all nonsense. The interest divided by the prior month's balance is 6%. Month after month. There is no conspiracy. If you reallt think the bank charges 100%, well, I am willing to charge you only 20%, that's fair, no?

I've wriiten about MMA for over a year, and compiled into one PDF all my posts.

http://www.joetaxpayer.com/MMACompR32.pdf

 

 

JoeTaxpayer
9:55am • #11

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Keith Gill

Tucson, AZ

More about me…

Mortgage Equity Acceleration

Office Phone: (520) 979-0545

Email Me

Everything You ever wanted to know from a Real Expert in the Arizona Mortgage loan Market


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find AZ real estate agents and Tucson real estate on ActiveRain.