Points...
What are they good for?
Absolutely...nothing
Uhuh..Uhuh
Say it again...
OK I am stealing the tune and many of the words of Edwin Starr's 1970's hit protest song...War ... forgive me...
Should RealTown (Internet Crusade) introduce points in their communities?
RealTalk
Back a few years ago on RealTalk if you tried to get lurkers to communicate on RealTalk (the Grand Daddy of national real estate communities) lurkers would dig in their heals and say that someone else had already said what they would say, so rather than say "ditto" they were remaining silent. The same 100 or so people out of 10,000 (back then a couple of years ago...) would carry on conversations. Lenn Harley a long time was never shy. Terry Cook would contribute. I would converse. The EBAs would hold forth... and Mark Jay would carry on with the EBAs, kind of a pointless (excuse me...) back and forth since both sides were so intractable.
According to the RealTown site RealTalk has increased to 33,000 members. I don't participate on RealTalk anymore. Who does? Is RealTalk growing in participation proportionately? Are there now 300 people carrying on the conversation out of 33,000 members? Or has participation on RealTalk naturally increased without something like points?
If RealTalk gave points for participation would participation increase? Would people be motivated by the points to participate? Not that anyone at RealTown wants to introduce points. Frances Flynn Thorsen (who has a title at Real Town which I can never remember and certainly would not want to get wrong .... ) does not like the points or the pointless comments on ActiveRain so I hardly think anyone has to worry about RealTown communities adopting points.
RealTownTalk
oooooh something new RealTown Talk is new.... that is a community to talk about ... well here's their description of that community:
"• RealTownTalk (Beta) -- RealTownTalk is our newest community, created for RealTown members to discuss the features of RealTown.com and its many components."
BlogTalk
The RealTown site says of BlogTalk:
"• BlogTalk (Beta) -- 6,000+ members of the RealTownBlogs community sharing information about their blogging experiences. Go to http://www.RealTown.com/blogs to create a blog."
I have a RealTown blog, my oldest...
Again FFT dislikes points and idle comments but if you look at BlogTalk, Frances starts a topic or thread and no one responds. Look at the 0's on BlogTalk. Frances talks... I am sure there are people in the community of 6000 that are reading it but no one is talking on BlogTalk except Frances Flynn Thorsen.
psst hint for the social media gurus at RealTown... why not build polling into your communities?... you are hosting "Talk" communities for the silent majority.... very few talk but maybe give them some choices, a few buttons to push to participate.
ActiveRain is doing away with points Of course ActiveRain announced on April First that they are going to do away with points. ActiveRain Point Scoring System Update The community response? Comments (280) in just two days... it was a joke so maybe it's OK for people to comment pointlessly... maybe it is all you can expect with a joke and hey you get 25 points anyway for just typing in 12 words....? I believe it is 12 words. Was ActiveRain's muse for this April Fool's joke Jonathan Dalton? Jonathan's Jumped The Shark? [Active Rain] says:
"As AR broached the 40,000-member mark, I came to believe it had jumped the shark"
ActiveRain today at Members: 81,344... a lot of members participating via comments... I wonder how the percentage of participatiion on ActiveRain compares to other real estate social media...
"Peace love and understanding tell me
Is there a place for these today
But Lord knows theres got to be a better way"
Again forgive me for thinking about the 1970's protest song... Were points on ActiveRain "genius"? Or stupid? Or do you spell that "stoopid" in real estate blogging?
Maureen, sure points can be motivating for a while and get people started, but it's the community, the learning and the business that's created that keeps one motivated once the points grab loses its luster.