Special offer

If You Bid Up, Should You Pay Up?

By
Real Estate Agent with Juice RE Group at Compass Lic# 491811

Ever had this conversation:

Buyer Agent: Hi Listing Agent John, hope you are having a great day.  

Listing Agent John: It's going great, hope you are well.  Is this a happy call?  Is everything on track with your buyer's loan?

Buyer Agent: Well, the lender just received the appraisal back, and the property missed value by $5,000 (appraised value is lower than agreed upon sales price). I know there were multiple offers, all over list price, and we agreed to pay X price, but the seller needs to lower the price so we can move forward.  If the seller doesn't lower the price in-order for the buyer to obtain financing we will have to terminate.

___________________

There are a lot of different directions this conversation could turn, and Listing Agent John could respond, however much depends on the discussions you have 2 or 3 weeks prior.  Austin has a unique, hyperactive market, where this is a concern for many transactions.  With our anemic inventory, we are watching some buyers get overly aggressive to lock down a home after loosing out on several properties or under pressure to lock down living quarters!

If both agents don't have a conversation upfront, and there is a shortage, the debate later down the road  might not end well for either side.  Buyers have to jump back in a competitive market and seller starts over again with a new buyer.  We are initiating this conversation as listing agents, especially on unique homes or highly competitive situations where offer prices head into uncharted values for a particular neighborhood.  

What are buyers doing?  Some are opting to throw all finance contingencies out the window (Please make sure buyers understand what it means to not include the TREC Third Party Finance Addendum here in Texas and what's on the line).  Others are writing in language to their offer that says they will make up any difference between appraised value and contract sales price.  Careful here, keep it to facts and always put a cap on the amount if representing buyers.  You never know when some appraiser might miss the mark by some obscene amount!

Have the conversation upfront and avoid issues down the road.

Comments (3)

Joe Jackson
Keller Williams Capital Partners Realty - Columbus, OH
Clintonville and Central Ohio Real Estate Expert

Excellent tips John. The appraisal process is an important topic for not only buyers but sellers too when going over (hopefully) multiple offers.

Jun 20, 2016 06:29 AM
Dorie Dillard Austin TX
Coldwell Banker Realty ~ 512.750.6899 - Austin, TX
NW Austin ~ Canyon Creek and Spicewood/Balcones

Good morning John Dunham ,

Excellent topic. You are so right if language is not inserted in the contract addressing this issue a conversation is needed up front between agents. Appraisers are all over the board with their reports. Some are coming in at value when you didn't think there was a ghost of a chance! Other homes that should appraise are not coming in at value..a real mixed bag! Appraisers are backed up and some getting out of the business because of the stress. Their compensation is less due to the new regulations forcing many of them to bid on the work. A problem all over the country!! Another reason cash is king!

Jun 28, 2016 09:55 PM
Michael Jacobs
Pasadena, CA
Pasadena And Southern California 818.516.4393

Hi John -- in a fast-changing and quickly appreciating market, this issue needs to be addressed sooner than later and in writing.   With the current trends in the Austin area, I'm sure this is a big issue.   Good job explaining it to prospective buyers(and sellers too).   

Jun 29, 2016 03:35 AM
John Dunham

It has helped a number of situations this year alone being proactive vs reactive.

Jun 29, 2016 03:48 AM