I got my real estate license in May of 2001. It took a lot of time to study for it, a lot of work. I spent months agonizing about the license exam, particularly the math part of the test.

This turned out to be unnecessary for the test. And it has turned out to be much more than necessary for the real-life job of being a real estate agent.

Consider this math problem, which was one of dozens I tackled prior to taking the test:

Dave and Sandy buy a four-plex apartment building as an investment. The purchase price is $385,000, of which $78,000 is attributable to the land. For tax purposes, they take a straight-line depreciation on the building over 27-1/2 years. Of course, the property actually appreciates in value by four percent a year. Assuming they make no property-improvements, when they sell the property seven years later, what are the tax consequences?

I can do that problem. It's just straight plug-and-chug calculator math. To actually come up with an answer would take a while, and I'd want to check my numbers three times -- at least. But this is a doable problem, and people have to solve this kind of problem every day.

What's ironic is this: After doing dozens of math problems this complex, this is the math problem I got on the Arizona State real estate license examination:

Starting at the northwest corner of Section 3, proceed in a southwesterly direction to the northeast corner of Section 8. From there proceed east 2 miles to the northeast corner of Section 10. Procced from there in a northwesterly direction to the point of origin. What is the total acreage of the parcel described?

That sounds complicated, but it's actully very simple. What we have is half of Section 4 plus half of Section 3. There are 640 acres in a section, so the pink half of Section 4 is 320 acres. The blue half of Section 3 is also 320 acres. Add them both together and we get 640 acres.

People fail this test. Lots and lots of people fail this test. I don't want to speak ill of my fellow real estate agents, but my advice to anyone buying or selling a house is this: Double-check the math.

But there is an area of mathematics where real estate salespeople are and must be math wizards. What is that area? Figuring out their commissions...

It's a simple enough problem, right? The commission on the sale of a house is usually six percent. Everybody knows that.

But wait. There's more. If the house was sold by someone other than the person who listed it for sale, the commission is split 50-50. So the salesperson gets three percent, right?

Not quite. To be a real estate salesperson in Arizona, you are obliged to align yourself with a real estate broker, a designation taking a different license. Theonly people who can receive commisions for real estate sales or leasing are the brokers. The brokers pay the salespeople, and if a salesperson so much as touches a dollar that did not emerge from his broker's pocket, he could lose his license.

So what do you suppose the broker does between the time he receives the commission from the sale of the house and the time he passes it along to the salesperson? That's right, he keeps some of it.

There are office fees, of course; gotta keep the rain out. And desk fees, unless you want to stand around like a flamingo. There are franchise fees so you can use that nifty logo. Fees for copies, faxes, phone calls. Fees for business cards and signage. Fees to tap into that pool of unassigned leads. Then there are transaction fees, errors and omissions insurance fees, recordation fees.

And it's not just the broker. MLS wants their cut, too, along with the Board of Realtors in every town you set foot in.

And don't forget the money spent out-of-pocket to sell the house: gas, entertainment costs, advertising.

The real estate agent is the last person in a long line of people getting fed on the sale of a house. The math involved in figuring his ultimate commission is half mystery, half myth. If he's lucky, he'll get as much as fifty percent of fifty percent of six percent of the sales price of the house. That comes down to one-and-one-half percent. That's $1,500 on a hundred-thousand dollar house. It's $600 on a forty-thousand dollar condominium.

Find the prospects. Establish rapport. Investigate their needs. Take them around to see six or sixteen properties. Finally settle on one and close. Spend three hours writing a nine page purchase contract. Submit the offer. Go over the counter-offer. Submit the counter-counter-offer. Hammer away until you make a deal. Hand-hold, hector and hustle documents around for six weeks. And when it's all over, pick up a pay-check for $1,500. Or $600. Or nothing, if the deal falls through.

Now here is a math problem: How does anyone make a living at this?

Volume.

It's true. What starts as fifty percent of fifty percent of six percent can turn into one hundred percent of ninety percent of six percent -- if you sell your own listings and keep those fees and costs down. And the houses can sell for a lot more.

This is a true mathematical fact: Of every 100 new real estate licensees, 85 will be out of the business within a year.

But for every thousand real estates agents sweating over a $1,500 commission, there are one or two who live on the top of a mountain.

And this is the final math problem: How many mountaintop homes do you have to own to live on top of a mountain?

The answer: One.

I can count that high...

 

8 Comments on The Math of Real Estate Sales...

FEB
25
2007
258,744 Points 102 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Nice, Greg.  I like how you take the reader down the "real" costs of a real estate transaction and remind the reader about the need for volume.
10:00pm • #1
MAR
01
2007
258,744 Points 102 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Thanks for the entry in The "Carnival of the Economics of Real Estate".  I'll be posting the entries and winners by Friday and will be sure to notify the winner about his/her new Forbes subscription.  We had fifteen entries; two from new Active Rain members.  You can see all the entries here with a star next to them.

Each entry was masterful.  One person will win the Forbes subscription but all of you won something from your well thought out posts; increased knowledge.  Be sure to comment on each other's posts.  There is a lot to learn from each other.
12:29am • #2
534,504 Points 45 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Good outline, Gregg. Amazing how many agents can't do this math.  One big expense omission - education! It's hard to get to the mountain, much less stay there,  if you aren't continually educating yourself. And then there are the technology costs....

Ever wondered why this industry touts gross sales or gross commissions rather than net? Very few are taught to analyze and plan so that their net is larger.

Actually, your final answer isn't necessarily one - it could be two, as in one or two in your comments. It could be zero, if the person living there is renting. It could be fifteen, if the house was sold as fractional interests ... well, you get my point. 

6:13am • #3
27 Featured Posts

Greg,

I like the post, helps put things in perspective.  BTW, you can't get on top of a mountain in South Florida (unless you climb the garbage dump). 

Joking aside, you can rise to the top of the industry down here.  I did want to mention one peculiar thing, and I may be wrong with this, but since a four-plex is considered residential property, shouldn't the deprediation be taken out over 39 years, not the 27 1/2 allowed by commerical properties?  (I state I may be wrong because I do not remember off the top of my head right now.)

Hopefully readers, whether real estate agents or mortgage brokers, will be focused on the ultimate goal and develop a path to their "mountain top".

8:38am • #4
126,395 Points 12 Featured Posts Outside Blog
My first Real Estate office took a 6.75% surcharge for the franchise before their 50% split... so ONE was not possible!
9:21am • #5
JUN
01
2007

Robert:

     Residential property is depreciated over 27 and 1/2 years.

     Commercial property is depreciated over 39 years.

     Your residential homestead cannot be depreciated at all

steve
2:31pm • #6
JUN
02
2007
I am always amazed how few agents (or even loan officers) can use a financial calculator to figure out something as simple as the monthly P&I on a 30 yr note.
12:57am • #7
AUG
28
2008
119,680 Points

Greg ....  Good article about THE MATH OF REAL ESTATE SALES.  I see that it's from last year and know that the MATH still applies. Keep up the good work.

Harrison K. Long, Explore Properties group, Irvine, CA

10:10am • #8

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Greg Swann

Phoenix, AZ

More about me…

BloodhoundBlog.com

Address: 314 E El Caminito Dr, Phoenix, AZ, 85020

Office Phone: (602) 504-1256

Cell Phone: (602) 740-7531

Email Me

Find AZ real estate agents and Phoenix real estate on ActiveRain.