User55921_1_t Amanda Hall * Texas Real Estate Broker *
Find real estate listings in your city:
Members: 122,705 - 848 Online Now  Login
 

It's not just a CMA, It's a TMA.

CMA stands for Comparable Market Analysis.  A CMA is a compilation of data that is gathered from the Multiple Listing Service (MLS). The MLS is used by Realtors® as well as licensed appraisers and it provides information regarding properties that have been or are currently being sold on the market.  The data is used to assist in determining marketable value for a subject property by comparing the subject to similar properties for sale now and those that have sold in the recent past.  Sold data is often referred to as a "comp".

Layman's terms:  A CMA is a report that Realtors® run that gives us an idea of what homes have recently sold for that are similar to the one you are trying to sell.  Realtors® compare square footage, # of bedrooms and baths, features, schools, etc. and use the information to make pricing recommendations to sellers.  A quick search of the internet will reveal that most Realtors® offer to perform a Free CMA upon request. 

TMA stands for Thorough Market Analysis.  A TMA is not widely heard of by consumers and is most often performed by the consummate professional who believes that a CMA involves more than just the gathering of data.  For data to exist, someone has to input it and that input is subject to human error and/or creative liberties.  Performing a TMA requires that a physical inspection of the competition (Active listings) take place to verify the accuracy of the data and properly price the property. 

LAYMAN'S TERMS:  The MLS is full of errors because a listing in the MLS is only as good as the agent making the entry. Within minutes, it is easy to find at least 5 listings that include errors with regards to # of bedrooms, baths, dining rooms, living areas, garage spaces, schools, directions, status and so on.  I have yet to find a listing in the MLS state that a home was a cramped space filled with trash, yet I have toured plenty of cramped spaces with trash all over the place.   I've also encountered homes that show like a builder's model and the description didn't do the listing or the seller's exquisite taste any justice. 

Don't leave the pricing of your home to chance that the CMA data is inaccurate.  At Hall Team Homes, we tour the competition prior to offering a price recommendation so that apples will truly be compared to apples.  A listing that is priced right ALWAYS results in a faster sale regardless of the condition of the property, its location or local market conditions. 

CMA Versus TMA - A TMA reveals the difference.

Clients of Hall Team Homes know the difference.

*********************************************************

Hall Team Homes is proud to serve the real estate needs of the Greater Fort Worth Area including Arlington, Grapevine, Southlake, Colleyville, Mansfield, Hurst, Euless and Bedford.

Hall Team Homes

www.hallteamhomes.com

Contact Amanda Hall, Broker, Realtor and Owner of Hall Team Homes

817-239-9387 direct

 

 

 

11 Comments on Beyond The Marketing Plan -- Beating The Market

Excellent point and great post.  I am of the opinion agents need more training before placing a home on the market.  It would make a big difference in the lives of both buyers and sellers.

05/22/2008 08:21 AM by Melody Botting Real Estate Network


Excellent information for your sellers, Amanda, and kudos to you for setting the bar high.  You would definitely be my pick for DFW real estate.

05/22/2008 09:34 AM by Lisa Heindel, New Orleans West Bank Real Estate (Latter & Blum Inc. Realtors)


AMANDA - If I were moving to the Fort Worth area, or if I knew anyone that was, the first call would be to you and the Hall Team.  I feel the same way as you.  One of the reasons that my market reports take so long to create is because I manually pull out errors instead of relying on MLS to be 100% accurate.  I belive the term is "garbage in, garbage out."  The MLS has no filter, and has no ability to remove misinformation (intentional or not).  Great post, Amanda!

05/22/2008 11:18 AM by Adam Waldman - Long Island REALTORĀ® (RE/MAX Best)


Melody, I couldn't agree with you more regarding the issue of agent training.  I also have to add that a lot of the errors I find are by agents who have been around a while.  The rookies appear to be too scared to make such careless errors in most cases and their Brokers are still keeping an eye on things.  Go figure!

Lisa, You know where I will turn when I encounter buyers looking to move to the New Orleans area, too!  I've read enough of your blogs and spent enough time getting to know you that I am confident of your high professional standards as well! 

Adam, come on down to Texas!  What internet consumers may not realize is that the MLS is feeding all of those websites the same misinformation that we are used to scrutinizing for accuracy.  Hiring a professional that realizes not everyone understands truth in adverising helps the consumer a great deal!  Imagine pricing a home to the low side and finding out later that the comps were skewed!  What an expensive error and most sellers don't realize that it happens every day.

05/22/2008 11:46 AM by Amanda Hall * Texas Real Estate Broker * (Hall Team Homes )


What can I say.... when you're good, you're good.

The amount of inaccuracies in the MLS data is staggering... I am constantly teling agents and clients alike that it's no wonder some agents can't price homes.  Using the "on the surface" MLS data would make the price wrong 85% of the time.  It takes a pro to get to the real scoop.

Excellent blog, Amanda. 

05/22/2008 02:26 PM by Fairbanks Ak Real Estate Broker Jesse Clifton (Jesse & Kathy Clifton, REALTORS 907-699-6024)


Amanda,

You came out of the "Broker shoot" with a bang. Great post. Does anyone no why the listing checker is not working at this time with NTREIS?? It sure seems to be missing more mistakes by realtors.

05/22/2008 04:42 PM by Becky Respess, ABR, CRB, CRS (Broker/Associate North Texas GMAC)


Seeing each home in the market analysis is the key to the most accurate report.  It's the height of professionalism to be familiar with the inventory of homes on the market and the features and drawbacks of each one.  Your professionalism and knowledge of your market lets you provide your consumers with a more accurate analysis.

05/22/2008 11:23 PM by Elaine Hanson, REALTORĀ® ~ Topanga, CA Real Estate Specialist (Pritchett-Rapf & Assoc. Realtors, Topanga)


Amanda, this is a great post. I too am a believer or doing a thorough job.

05/23/2008 03:50 PM by Danny Thornton (Home America Mortgage, INC.)


Amanda- This is why you and The Hall Team are serious winners! Customer service like this should make any buyer interested in the Fort Worh area call you!

05/24/2008 09:01 AM by Brentwood TN Real Estate/Homes - Vanessa Stalets REALTORĀ® (RE/MAX Elite)


Amanda, this is a great post.  In fact, I might steal this one and put on my web site!  I'll even give you credit..."The Red Head"!

05/24/2008 06:13 PM by Sharon Yeary (Sharcom Realty)


Jesse, if you aren't right about the 85%, I am sure you are close.  Pricing too low or high is avoidable when you take the time to get to know the market.

Becky, I wasn't aware that listing checker isn't working, but even when it's up and running smoothly, it is only designed to catch the obvious.  The MLS relies heavily upon humans to catch human error.  What shocks me is when I send a courtesy email to agents to let them know of an error and they still fail to make the correction.  Some of them even acknowledge the email.  Go figure!

Elaine, I think it goes even further than taking care of the needs of the client.  When I take a buyer call, if my listing doesn't work for the caller, I have knowledge of what is available in the area that works for them.  (This going the distance thing is profitable!)

Danny, thanks for stopping by! Hope all is well with you.

Vanessa, I am counting on it.  My brokerage is just a small fish in a big pond here in DFW.  It is our service level that keeps the referrals and repeat business coming in.

Sharon, don't steal it for your website, borrow it for your training manual! 

05/25/2008 10:37 AM by Amanda Hall * Texas Real Estate Broker * (Hall Team Homes )


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Real Estate Agent: Amanda Hall * Texas Real Estate Broker * (Hall Team Homes )
Amanda Hall * Texas Real Estate Broker *
Fort Worth, TX
More about me…
Hall Team Homes

Office Phone: (817) 239-9387
Cell Phone: (817) 239-9387
Email Me


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find TX real estate agents and Fort Worth real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved