This came up again today during my market update for a real estate company I work with and was surprised how many of the agents did not know the details of this Act that was passed by Congress and signed by President Bush late last year in 2007.

As you many of you were aware, in the past when a homeowner had a devastating financial loss and their home either went into foreclosure or the home was sold on a short sale, the IRS was nice enough to step in and tax them on their loss. Meaning, if you purchased a $400,000 home and you took out 100% financing over a year ago and you were about to lose your home now but were able to find a buyer for $350,000 as a short sale, the $50,000 loss you had would then be reported as income on your tax return.

Talk about adding salt to the wound or insult to injury, the IRS was relentless on this. Can you imagine losing your job, or having a major medical issue where you were going to lose your home and you find out after your home has been taken back and whatever else you lose emotionally and financially, your CPA breaks the news to you that you now have $50,000 of extra reportable income that you had not been taxed on.

Fun stuff,not. Well fortunately the government did something right in my opinion. With the mortgage meltdown with subprime and Alt-A mortgages as well as a drop in real estate values, it became the perfect storm for the new home owner to lose their home if proper planning and strategy were not put into place.

Long story short, now if you lose your home on a short sale or foreclosure the loss, or gain as the IRS sees it, will no longer apply, at least for the remaining calendar year in 2008 and 2009.

A few caveats though, it must be your primary residence and the amount that is "forgiven" is the original accusation indebtedness or the adjusted AI after home upgrades or a remodel.

What is not covered, money used above and beyond the "purchase money" loan/s. So for example, let's say you purchased your home 3 years ago for $400,000 with a 20% down payment and it had appreciated by $50,000 early in 2007, 2 years after the purchase. Your value reached $450,000 with $130,000 of equity trapped in your home so you decided to pull out $100,000 for investments bringing your financed home loans up to $420,000.

Well our little market readjustment occurs and now you are in the summer of 2008, you haven't closed a transaction in 3 months and you have to let your home go on a short sale at $390,000. The simple math that the IRS will calculate is a loss to the bank of $30,000 or a gain or income to you of the same amount.

In case I lost you, even though you purchased your home for $400,000, since you chose to put down 20% or $80,000, your original accusation indebtedness remained at $320,000 and the new $100,000 you pulled out was not used for home improvement or a remodel, which is not "forgivable" debt.

I hope this helps. Of course, the safe thing to do is to always refer your clients to a trusted referral partner from your team in a CPA or LTC as we are not qualified to give tax advice, but we can certainly recommend direction based on our experience and knowledge.

Here is the IRS link for your own research. http://www.irs.gov/individuals/article/0,,id=179414,00.html

Be Blessed!

Travis

 
Post is included in group: Mortgages
Post is included in group: True Mortgage Professionals
Post is included in group: CMPS

7 Comments on Reminder on Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act

Travis, also, even without the debt relief act, if the homeowner is insolvent the CPA can use that to offset the IRS amount owed. But you must speak to your CPA or tax attorney about this. We do get referrals for short sale listings from tax attorneys.Good post.

06/18/2008 02:03 AM by Nestor & Katerina Gasset, Realtors® Wellington Florida Luxury Homes (International Properties and Investments, Inc.)


Nestor & Katerina,

Thank you for the positive and helpful input on this. Good info that you added, I need to research more on the dynamic of when a homeowner is insolvent and how IRS code applies to them. Great to hear you are building relationships with other professionals, it always shocks me to hear when I am coaching or having strategic planning meetings with my Realtors and find out that they do not have relationships built with CPA's, attorney's, financial planners, etc.

Have a great rest of the week.

 

06/18/2008 02:14 AM by Travis Neliton (Mortgage Express)


Travis, I think you are right that congress has finally done something right!  Great info.  I knew about this, but didn't understand all the details about who would qualify.  Thanks

06/18/2008 03:42 AM by Meridian Idaho Real Estate ~ Pam Pugmire (All Pro Realty)


Hello Travis,

I had posted a blog a couple of months ago regarding the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act and was swamped with calls from agents as well as some homeowners who had no idea what I was talking about.  At a couple of conferences I went to agents admitted to have never read the law and really had no idea what it entailed.   

We really have to educate ourselves and then our clients in this area, yet I suppose with caution.  There is apparently no plan by congress to revisit this to make any extensions After December 2009.

Those who are struggling to keep their homes and fall into foreclosure thinking they are still safe will be unpleasantly surprised.   With our economy the way it is, and more layoff's coming, it is concerning how long some of these borrowers can hold on to those homes they put zero down on, and are now upside down.  Relationships with tax attorneys is very good advice, I utilize that as well as referring clients to a non-profit debt counseling agency to get their finances straight for the long haul recession. 

Note:  I have a friend who is struggling with a $90K tax consequence due to the loss on her million dollar home that went to foreclosure prior to this debt relief act.   We have to really pay attention.  Thanks!

 

06/18/2008 04:11 AM by LeAndra Shepherd (Independence Realty)


Good reminder. Sad we have a law like this, but a good reminder. Leave it up to the IRS to kick someone when they are down. After all, don't you still have to pay income tax on unemployment still?

06/18/2008 05:04 AM by Dennis Swartz (Buyers & Sellers Realty GMAC)


With all the talk in congress about tax fairness, fairness is not part of the tax code. As far as this paper income from losing the home and negotiating a short sale that cuts the loss for a lender.

Everyone is in a lose less/lose less situation, making the best result for all concerned. Dropped market, cannot pay, no alternatives.

There is no income here. There really was no income. there was a home that lost value in a market adjustment.

An equity withdrawal however did involvethe receipt of cash. I can understand the equity debt being treated differently.

On the tax code, it is sad also to see the number of right offs allowed by the IRS and performed by accountants and their clients to the point that the filing actually shows no taxable income.

Most self employed people actually pay taxes on an income that is commiserate with their life style and debt load, but some do not. I do not understand how that can get through even a cursory reasonableness test?

Maybe with the stated programs becoming restricted, such tax abuse will be encouraged to be reduced.

I already told one client last week who said their account did the return, that maybe their accountant will lend them the money to buy their new home.

Richard

06/18/2008 06:07 AM by Richard Smith Mortgages Home Loans FHA TN GA AL (American Acceptance Mortgage, Inc)


LeAndra, thank you for sharing your personal experience with your friend, it tends to hit home when someone actually knows someone that has experienced this.

Richard, great comments as well! And you are right, I am having a heck of a time getting clients qualified that are self employed that "make" $150k" but their adjusted gross income is $72,000! How do you politely tell a client that they can't have it both ways avoiding income taxes but convince the underwriter that they really don't have those expenses. It's a weekly conversation I am having now.

So again, preparing your clients for the worst or lowering their expectations from the beginning if they are used to the home buying process of the past 5 to 6 years, you will save yourself a lot of grief.

06/18/2008 10:07 AM by Travis Neliton (Mortgage Express)


Leave a response…

Name:
Notify me of new comments:
Comment:
What does the graphic say?
 
Loan Officer: Travis Neliton (Mortgage Express)
Travis Neliton
Beaverton, OR
More about me…
Mortgage Express

Office Phone: (503) 517-8758
Cell Phone: (503) 515-6898
Email Me

Links

Tags (Tag Cloud)

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog
ATOM 1.0 Feed for this blog

Find OR real estate agents and Beaverton real estate here on ActiveRain.
Disclaimer: ActiveRain Corp. does not necessarily endorse the real estate agents, loan officers and brokers listed on this site. These real estate profiles, blogs and blog entries are provided here as a courtesy to our visitors to help them make an informed decision when buying or selling a house. ActiveRain Corp. takes no responsibility for the content in these profiles, that are written by the members of this community.
© 2007 ActiveRain Corp. All Rights Reserved