I read an article here on AR this morning that was posted yesterday. I have no idea if the article is ficticious or not. It really doesn't matter. The subject is important and similar real stories are happening all around us. The Codgers describe a foreclosure and the clients who lost their house. The story is saddening, but it's the comments that I have to challenge. Well, I don't have to challenge them but I will anyway. My opinion is different from most of those posted in the comments. All I ask is that you take a moment and consider the view I propose...
There is plenty of blame to go around in situations like the one described in this story. Some people want to place all the blame in one place. They want to blame the Realtor or the Loan Officer or the Client. All the blame in one tidy little package. I don't think life works that way. Some of the blame needs to be shared by each of the players in the story.
We are real estate professionals and we must take some responsibility. Our clients come to us with their trust in their hands. That trust is often based on something as thin as the recommendation of a friend. They ask us questions like "What do you think I should do Mark" and "Do you think this is a good idea?" and they make comments like "Well, John said I could trust you, so if you think this is what's best...". They often place what amounts to Blind Trust in our education, our abilities and our ethics. They don't know us from Adam.
The clients in the story have to take the blame for a bad decision. They let their emotions and desires overwhelm their good sense. But do you really think the Loan Officer and the Realtor didn't know that was happening? C'mon folks, it happens in every deal we handle! Of course they were emotional and of course it clouded their judgement. That is the reason they needed to be able to trust the professionals involved! Did anybody stand up and simply say "I don't think this is a good idea for you" ? Why not? Should the clients take the blame for that? Where was the "voice of reason"? Isn't that what we are supposed to be?
The final chapter of a scenario like the one presented is the most telling chapter of all. The clients couldn't handle the payment and started down the path to a foreclosure. Where was the Loan Officer? Where was the Realtor? I have no doubt that a phone call from the Loan Officer to the Lender would have bought some time for the clients. I have no doubt that time is the thing a Realtor needs plenty of to help someone under this kind of pressure, get the property sold. Taking the paycheck without taking some resposibility just doesn't work for me. Call me a rock head. I think it's wrong.
There is plenty of Mortgage Broker bashing and Realtor bashing that goes on on the internet and other medias. You can read plenty of commentarty by Loan Officers and Realtors using that latest fad words like "Transparency". Most of the commentarty attempts to give the impression that this is something new or unique. What is so unique about common decency? And why would anybody use something that should be as natural as breathing, as advertising. I just don't get it.
These situations are rarely ALL anybody's fault. They are the fault of ALL. We should (in my opinion) take our share of the blame.
I don't visit the Codger's Front Porch because I find articles that make me think deep thoughts. I visit their front porch for a cup of coffee and a grin. It's a unique blog on this network and typically light-hearted. You can say anything you want there. This morning I got more than my normal cup of Joe.