Well, as a technical person and a natural skeptic, I was very skeptical when I heard about this new product that would give you what amounts to free telephone service using your PC and high-speed Internet connection.

Unlike services such as Vonage, Magicjack is a small USB device that plugs into your PC. Plug in a phone, sign up for a number and hey-presto, you have phone service. The cost of the device is about $40 which includes the first year's service. After that it's $20 a year.

Sound too good to be true?

We thought we'd give it a try. A neighbor actually recommended it when it came up in conversation. Turns out she'd been using it for a while and we'd not noticed any call quality issues when speaking to her. So, in these trying economic times we thought "what the heck..."

The reviews online are mixed. Some good, some bad. Some call it a great invention. Some call it a scam.

Our Magicjack arrived and we plugged it in. The software was all on the device already. After a reboot, the registration screen came up, we picked a local telephone number, hooked up one of our existing handsets...and got a dial tone. So far so good.

We called several people, both locally and long-distance and have been experimenting for the past week. So far, the product seems to work as promised. We're getting local and long-distance phone service for less than $2 a month. Our Magicjack is hooked up to a PC that is connected to our high-speed router by a wireless connection so we figured we'd suffer a little for, but on the whole, it's been surprisingly good.

There have been a couple of "crackles" on the line and a fad in and out once or twice. It's certainly not the 100% clear, crisp sound you expect from a phone service, but you can hear and be heard clearly and you don't have to strain your hearing or guess who you're talking to.

The setup program registered our address for 911 calls and that was it. We tried the free voicemail and gave up. At least from our perspective, the Voice-over-IP (VOIP) quality just wasn't up to it, so we'll stick with an ansering machine for now.

But it's pretty cool. You can take it with you when you move about - quite handy. The only thing is that your PC has to be on when you use the device.

But, for $20 a year, so far it's living up to its promise. I'll update this review in a few weeks as we progress with our testing. We've still got our main home number active. I suppose the true test would be to have that disconnected...Anyway for this price, it's a good cheap second number for now.

www.MagicJack.com

Have a good one!

 

12 Comments on MagicJack...does it work?

JUL
16
2008
162,130 Points 1 Featured Post

Wow, interesting. Never heard of it before now. Is there some catch to it that you have not realized yet?

12:53pm • #1
4 Featured Posts

Hi Angelia

I sincerely hope not. I'll keep this post updated as time goes by, just in case. The person who referred us swears by it and there are some excellent reviews out there.

It does seem to good to be true I admit but so far...

Dave

12:57pm • #2

I have a friend who just told me about it and he has had his for 6 months and loves it.

Ron Lambright
HOPE USA
www.hope4usa.com
ron@hope4usa.com

1:04pm • #3

Dave,

I just saw the Infomercial this past weekend. Like you, I am a skeptic of the "But Wait...There's More" ads and always believe that if it is too good to be true, then it isn't.

I would like to read your follow-up to your testing and see if six weeks and six months from now something hasn't popped up or changed the claims and terms.

It would be nice, for once, to see something actually perform as promised.

Tracy L. Williams

www.LaPorteHomeSearch.com

Tracy
1:26pm • #4
133,525 Points 5 Featured Posts Outside Blog

I have seen this advertised for some time now and figured there must be some catch. Apparently, so far there isn't one. I am waiting for the government to start taxing it tho.

2:37pm • #5
246,791 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Dave, I am still on the fence. Your response puts one more point on the plus side. Thanks for sharing your experience with MagicJack and am looking forward to your future comments.

2:41pm • #6
SEP
06
2008

In the pros and cons from various comments on various other sites I came across one that states it will definitely NOT work if you have any CD/DVD programs (such as Nero) on your computer due to some conflict. Do you have any insight as to whether this is true or not?

Lee Godwin
3:37pm • #7

CLARIFICATION:

-----as in CD/DVD "duplicating" programs.

Lee Godwin
3:40pm • #8
4 Featured Posts

Hi Lee

I have Roxio on the same PC and use it to watch TV and it seems fine. It could be a particular combination of a,b and c that causes it or a given version.

The biggest "issue" we've had is if the network card is being heavily used while talking you can get a slight delay or "chop".

Dave

3:46pm • #9
NOV
12
2008
175,652 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog Hit Router

Thanks for the info, we just saw the commercial for it and were researching it. Sounds like there are pros and cons.

9:47pm • #10

majicjack is a real deal, I have a lot friends saving money with magicjack especially on their interntional calls.  There are pros and cons, but the for $20 a year. I personally feel it is worth to use. 

9:58pm • #11
JUL
20

 

THANKS DAVE:

 for the info: on majicjack, I'll be going to get me one majicjack next week, like you i feel, how can I loose, trying it $ 40.00 for the first year, is, comes out to about 5 to 6 months, just on taxas, and other charges, added, to my phone bill, by AT&T, and doe I been waiting, for this corrupt, company to wake up and smell the coffee,it does not appear it will happen soon enough,for it has kept a monopoly, for a very long time, so the way I see it, AT&T will never change unless it sees competition, for it has grown, like unattended parasites, I just hope millions of people drop, their AT&T services in order for majicjack to grow enough,as to be a real competitor, other wise AT&T will end up buying the competition like all monopoly company do and we as consumers are the only losers, $ 20.00 per year it amounts to a case of imported beer per year, I'm willing to give away, that case of beer for one year of phone service even if is imperfect, with time and more costumers I'm sure majicjack will improve its service to continue growing.

 

 

 

 

 

dave

6:49pm • #13

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
August_09_hr Rainmaker_large

Dave Segrove

Phoenix, AZ

More about me…

JDE LTD

Address: Phoenix, AZ, 85086

Office Phone: (480) 353-0504

Email Me

Marketing and small business development consultant, web and graphic designer. What this means for you is that my company can be a central resource for both your online and offline marketing needs. With a focus on small business, and being one, I know that every penny counts. Affordable, high-impact marketing solutions are essential in the quest to succeed, no matter what the marketplace. My services include:
  • Web Design, Redesign (Updating);
  • Marketing Materials (flyers, business cards, postcards, brochures and more);
  • Marketing Image "Makeovers"
  • Traditional and non-Traditional Marketing Campaigns;
  • Small Business Development;
  • Logos and Branding;
  • Education & Training;

You can view some of my portfolio at www.JDELtd.com.

My Small Business Genetics (SBGEN) Program is designed to help small business owners to develop a strategic plan from the ground up. Many small companies do not have access to "corporate" training, motivational or consulting services. The SBGEN program, available as a series on 1:1 consultations or as one-off sessions, brings new ideas that can help a small business develop and grow. You can learn more about the SBGEN program at www.sbgenetics.com.

I have over 20 years experience in the technology, web and marketing industries. At first glance these may appear mutually exclusive but, as we've seen over the past few years, a solid foundation is all these elements is critical if you're going to be providing comprehensive marketing solutions.

My approach to my work is collaborative. There are many web design companies out there that sell you a template, take your deposit and get back to you with a finished site. At JDE, we don't do things that way. I firmly believe that in order to get the best results, you have to work with and not just for the client.

Please take a moment to read some of the testimonials on our website. Take a look at our portfolio. Our reputation for excellence and value is growing in leaps and bounds.

Please feel free to send me an email if you have any questions. I look forward to working with you.

Scottsdale and Phoenix web design and marketing services by JDE LTD

Web design, technology and marketing news by Dave Segrove : webbys updates

Web and graphic design solutions for small business by Dave Segrove : profile on LinkedIn



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find AZ real estate agents and Phoenix real estate on ActiveRain.