Special offer

Short Sale or Foreclosure?

By
Real Estate Agent with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty
Everyone likes getting a great deal buying real estate

Everyone likes getting a great deal buying real estate. While looking around, you have heard about a short sale and a foreclosure. What's the difference? A big one and it's important to know before moving forward.

 

A short sale means that the seller will not net enough from the sale to pay off the mortgage. There could be a difference of $20,000 or more and the seller must work this out with the lender. If you put an offer on a short sale, the lender makes the decision to either accept or reject the offer and they are slow to respond.

 

Buyers who have made offers on a short sale have waited 60 or more days without hearing that their offer is either accepted or rejected. Why are the lenders slow to respond? They are waiting for a better offer to come in. Why hurry when the homeowner is maintaining the property? As a matter of fact, offers above list price have been rejected. Meanwhile, the buyer looses out on another opportunity because they are waiting for an answer. Unless you have lots and lots of time, don't bother with a short sale.

 

The lender owns a foreclosure. These are often referred to as bank owned or REO's. They are similar to a normal transaction allowing you to close in 60 days or maybe less, which is a big advantage over a short sale. Why are the banks so eager to close? The bank is paying to maintain the home. They also know their bottom line.

 

You can expect the procedure to purchase a foreclosure to be different than a conventional purchase. In a conventional sale, the buyer usually gets pre-qualified for a mortgage if that applies. A deposit (earnest money) is submitted with the offer. When the terms of the sale are worked out between the buyer and seller, the buyer proceeds to get a mortgage if that applies. The deadline for the mortgage application and approval is defined in the purchase agreement. If the buyer is not able to get the mortgage, the earnest money is returned to the buyer.

 

When you purchase a foreclosure, you must be pre-approved for your mortgage, if that applies, before submitting the offer. The approval does not have to be through the lender that owns the home. You can submit the approval letter from the lender you are using. If you are paying cash, there is a very good chance that you will have to show proof of funds. Keep in mind that the lender wants to make sure that they have a solid deal and you'll still need to submit earnest money with the offer.

 

In a conventional sale, the seller may fill out a “Sellers Disclosure” to disclose any defects that they are aware of. The buyer has the option to have an inspection. If any deficiencies are found, the buyer can request that the seller either makes the necessary repairs or request a credit at closing for the repairs. If the seller does not honor the buyer's request, the purchase agreement is dead and the buyer gets their earnest money back.

 

The lenders do not fill out a “Sellers Disclosure” on a foreclosure and the home is sold “as is”. You can pay for an inspection to make an informed buying decision, but the lender will not make any repairs or give credit at closing for the repairs.

 

Lastly, some banks may not disclose if the home presently has any offers or if any offers have been made at all.

 

Before you consider owning a foreclosure, firm up the financing or obtain proof of funds, do an inspection to make an informed buying decision and allow up to 60 days for closing. There are a lot of great deals out there and they won't last forever.

 

You can see the foreclosures on our web site, www.cnaples.com. You can also click here for details.

 

I welcome your questions or comments. I would love to hear from you.

 

- Michael

Whittier, CA

Not true about the bank owned being better. I think shortsales are better. Out here in california the bank owns are a shell. They have no kitchens no cabinets just a shell of a home. No fixtures. People pull everything out. Owners that lost there home are mad and frustrated because they lost there home. I know its not right, however that is what is going on out here. So out here bank owned are not good deals. Shortsales still have people living in them. These people leave them clean and worry about there credit. That is the reason for a shortsale. Leaving them to the bank is just plain ignorant.

Sep 09, 2008 12:53 PM
Michael & Joani Kikkert
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty - Naples, FL

Rose,

Thanks for sharing your experience with short sales in California.  I’m hoping that more agents will share their experience, too.

 

We don’t see too many foreclosures in Naples that are shells.  Even if they are, they’re priced below market value to move and they attract those who want an exceptional deal (who doesn’t).  I agree with you that it’s not right to strip the home out of frustration.

 

When there is a short sale, everyone with a financial interest has to agree to a settlement.  Anyone that holds a second mortgage takes a back seat to the primary lender.  The buyer is waiting for an answer and the bank gets tired of waiting for everyone with a financial interest to agree, so they foreclose.  That is why only 5% of short sales end up closing.

 

Would you drive to Los Angeles if there were only a 5% chance of getting there?  Why bother selling a short sale when there is only a 5% chance that the buyer will own it?

 

One of the agents I work with has a buyer who showed a lot of interest in a home that was a short sale.  He wants this home and he is willing to wait, so he wrote a contract that was accepted by the seller.  When a seller accepts a contract in a short sale, it doesn’t mean anything.  The contract is subject to the lender’s approval.  After eight months later, the buyer is still waiting for a response.  The bank foreclosed on the home, which made the buyer’s offer null and void.  The buyer was not happy that he lost the deal.

 

The agent who is working with the buyer happens to work with the lender that foreclosed on the home.  The lender ended up listing the house for $35,000 less than what the buyer offered when it was a short sale.  The buyer was lucky and ended up getting the home before anyone else made an offer.  The odds of this happening again are pretty slim.

 

When the chance of a short sale closing is greater than 50% and the lenders are quick to respond to offers, I will get involved.  In the mean time, I will stick to foreclosures.

 

I would like to hear your experience with short sales.

 

- Michael

 

Sep 12, 2008 08:09 AM
Whittier, CA

As far as shortsales I have closed 100%. I work on these listings as if they were my own home. It takes the alot of negotiating and an agressive agent. I have heard the stories about the 8 month wait. 

My longest closing was 2 months. First one was because the second wrote off the loan so then I had to deal with a collection agency. My second one that took a long time was because I had to wait for the buyer to be qualified again because he was qualified thru indy mac the time that indy mac closed down. The trick is to price it right and you will get lots of offers. I would never work on a shortsale if it took 8 months. I have had loans on a second as high as 135,000 and they accepted 7,000. The second was a different bank than the first.

Sep 13, 2008 09:16 AM