Special offer

DPA (Down Payment Assistance) is gone, 100% is gone....so why am I smiling?

By
Mortgage and Lending with WFS Mortgage, An Affiliate of Wells Fargo Home Mortgage

Over the past couple of weeks we successfully closed our last remaining DPA (Down Payment Assistance) transactions and thus the last 100% financing loans....   Possibly for ever?  My last two DPA transactions were first-time home buyers, who "needed" the program.  They didn't have enough money for a down payment, and these programs allowed them to get into their first home. 

After closing these loans I have actually felt a slight sigh of relief....actually feeling quite well knowing that for now, and possibly for a long time to come, my customers will need to put some money down when they buy a home.  This is in great contrast to the way I felt when I heard FHA was stamping out all DPA programs (for good).  I was angry.  I sent emails. I signed petitions. I may have even emailed my congressman, in hopes that he would actually read my message.   I "rallied the troops" in the office to do the same. 

However, that feeling of relief was still there, and I couldn't ignore it.  After my last DPA transaction, I left the closing feeling like I had not done anyone any favors.  Sure, my clients were happy....ecstatic even.  My Realtor was happy....a nice smooth closing without any issues.  But I still felt as though something was amiss.  After I pondered things for a while, the reason behind my uneasy-ness became apparent....  I realized that I felt the customers had no "stake" in the game whatsoever.  And I didn't like it.  I felt very confident they will have no issues making their payments for many, many years to come.  But, what if something happens?  What if there's trouble in paradise and this young couple decide to go their separate ways?  Besides a knock on their credit, what would keep them from mailing the keys to the lender and saying "c'est la vie?"

I have closed several, maybe even hundreds of 100% financing transactions.  I am young, having only been in the business for 7 years.  I haven't really known any different, or even had a chance to think about what the consequences are of "investment-less" homes.  I feel good about the future.  I feel good knowing that from now on, when the clients come to closing they will have a check in hand.  A check that they worked hard for, a check that they aren't going to just give up on, should things get tough down the road.  Before I went to college I worked for two years to purchase a farily decent, reliable set of wheels that would last through those next four years and not give me too many problems.  It was a small Mazda with a stick shift, with absolutely power nothing.  But it was mine, and I worked hard for the money to buy it.  A friend commented it was the "cleanest, newest looking 12 year old car he'd ever seen."  Why did I take such good care of it?  Because I worked hard for the money to buy it.  I acquired it through no other means than via blood, sweat and tears (a lot of long, hot days performing manual labor). 

I'm fairly confident now that people have to put forth that type of effort to aquire their first home, we'll see them want to keep them.  Even if there's trouble in paradise, and it's a 12 year old home....    

DEBORAH STONE
Balboa Real Estate San Diego, CA - San Diego, CA

Ryan

100% financing is really only the "tip of the iceberg"  Many, many more are the ARM's, and negative ams.which blew everyone away when the economy threw us a "curve ball" and our incomes dropped. Homeowners with excellent credit and 10%-20% downpayments had no choice but to hand back their keys to the Lender, losing their downpayment.

I would be curious to know the percentage of defaulted loans that in fact were 100% financing. For the most part good, solid Buyers with truthful info. on their applications won't walk away from a home, money down or not.

Oct 02, 2008 08:54 AM
Ryan Young
WFS Mortgage, An Affiliate of Wells Fargo Home Mortgage - Flowery Branch, GA

Thanks for your reply.  Yes...I would agree that most of the foreclosures out there are tied to some type of jump in payment or adjustment.  However, that being said, over 60% of FHA loans currently in foreclosure utilized Down Payment Assistance (per HUD). 

Also, Fannie Mae compiled lots of data and the figures were staggering.  Loans with down payments of less than 3% were three times more likely to go into foreclosure.  So yes.....I completely agree with your comments.  I am just suggesting that if someone has a "vested interest" in their property (besides their credit score) they are more likely to keep it.  That's all. 

Have a good one and thanks again for your reply!

Oct 02, 2008 09:11 AM
DEBORAH STONE
Balboa Real Estate San Diego, CA - San Diego, CA

Ryan

Those are staggering statistics. I only hope that in the forthcoming years, more stringent guidleines will be used to lend people mortgage money. Honestly, being self-employed and with a few lean years, I think it may be a long time before I can get another home loan. I am curious to see how this all plays out, but I have my **fingers crossed** for a good solution.

Oct 02, 2008 09:21 AM
Anonymous
Anonymous

It doesn't matter how much you put down. You could have put 10-20 percent down or nothing and still have the same amount of people giving up on their loans for divorce, etc. It all depends on the person. And right now the ones who were buying all these distressed properties were people who were using the program. And from what I have heard the program doesn't cost tax payers a cent. The mortgage companies are the idiots who gave out some really bad loans.

Oct 03, 2008 07:11 AM
#5
Ryan Young
WFS Mortgage, An Affiliate of Wells Fargo Home Mortgage - Flowery Branch, GA

Thank you for your reply, although I am a little confused by it and feel it may have been poignant in nature.  If someone puts down tens of thousands of dollars when purchasing a home, they are more likely to keep it, bar none.  The facts and numbers don't lie. 

Also, I am a bit mystified by your comment "...from what I have heard the program doesn't cost tax payers a cent.."  Well, the majority of current FHA loans in default were originated using Down Payment Assistance, which was used almost exclusively in conjunction with FHA loans.  The Federal Housing Authority (FHA) is a government entity that backs and insures these loans.  They take most of the hit when these loans go bad.  If FHA is a government entity, how does it not cost taxpayers anything when these loans go bad?  Maybe I am misunderstanding your comments. 

 

Oct 03, 2008 07:37 AM
DEBORAH STONE
Balboa Real Estate San Diego, CA - San Diego, CA

In other markets i.e. San Diego between 1997 and 2003.... a down-payment of perhaps 10%-20% would be a huge deterrent to foreclosure. Unfortunatley, I don't see that being the case in this current economical mess we are in right now in 2008. Of course statistics don't lie, but the loss of a job would force anyone into foreclosure if they have no equity in their home. If one bought in certain markets between 2003 and the present, that is the situation these folks are in. I have been in this business for 25+ years, and I really think that 100% financing, although slightly more risky in an average market, is not the culprit.

 

 

Oct 03, 2008 09:45 AM