I often hear the argument that if a component in the home is "serviceable" inspectors have no business reporting on it.  It is as if a label of "serviceable" covers the item with a shroud of "OK-ness," and we don't need to talk about the fact that it is 20 years past its life expectancy.toilet

     Let's discuss "serviceable" for a moment.  That is one of those words that have almost no meaning whatsoever in the context of a description about a component in a home----in my opinion.

     It sounds too much like something waiting for a grease gun, an HVAC technician, or an airplane at the arrival gate.

     I know what it is "intended" to mean, and I think there are better ways to say it. 

     For example, is it more accurate to say that the faucet is serviceable or that water came out?  You might want to then qualify the description with the amount that actually flowed or that the amount would not "typically" be sufficient or any other "qualifier" that fits what is actually going on.

     As inspectors, I think we have to be careful about trying to find one word that covers all kinds of scenarios.

     I am sure we have all seen those reports that read like a tombstone:

         Foundation----serviceable

         Roof-----serviceable

         Siding-----serviceable

         Furnace-----dead

         Doors & Windows-----serviceable

         Etc.-------serviceable. 

     No wonder they can crank the report out on site!

 

     First of all, what is "expected" of a faucet?

#1. For water to come out,  (pretty basic, but really isn't that about it?)

Then there is the long list of things that would modify that "basic" expectation.  Nothing else really needs to be said about the faucet unless there is something about the "coming out" that departs from the basic expectation, like:

1.   Not enough water

2.   No water

3.   Not hot enough

4.   Too hot

5.   Sprays all over the place

6.   Runs rusty

7.   Runs blue

8.   Etc.

     So, we might say something like, "Water flowed, and sprayed all over the countertop making the room blue.  I recommend repairs by qualified repair person to prevent spraying of water all over the bathroom."  It takes more words, but accurately describes what is going on.  To say that the faucet is serviceable actually tells the listener that the thing is either "ready to be serviced" or that it is "able" or "in a position" to be serviced.

     I think some inspectors are lazy and/or are scared to death of words.  Some of the "canned" language of the commercially available report software takes inspectors down this path as well.  Either way, it is the consumer that ends up with useless and/or unintelligible reports, which are passed off as "information."

     Remember though, it is the nature of language to not always convey "exactly" the same thing to every person no matter how vigilant we are, but if we just tell the story----as opposed to attempt to write in "shorthand"----the risk of miscommunication or no communication goes way down.  Especially if we stay away from "useless" words all together.

     Does your inspector use the word "serviceable?"

 

Charles Buell  

PS, for those of you that are new to my blog (or for some other "unexplained" reason have never noticed)sunsmileall  pictures and smiley-face inserts (emoticons) (when I use them) have messages that show up when you point at them with your cursor.

 MEMBERS OF ACTIVE RAIN CAN EASILY SUBSCRIBE

 TO MY BLOG BY CLICKING ON THE NUMBER PLATE!

sign me up

 

 

 

 

picture logo

 
Post is included in group: AR My Name is Cheryl
Post is included in group: Home Inspector's Corner
Post is included in group: Independent Thinking Inspectors
Post is included in group: Puget Sound - WA Real Estate
Post is included in group: The Ninety-ninth Percentile

30 Comments on How would you like to be called "serviceable?"

NOV
06
2008
119,377 Points

Charles, tell me that you are kidding, right. Just the word serviceable with no other explanations. I have not seen that type of reporting method around here. Close to it.

 

                          ~ All the Best         

9:41am • #1
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Roy, well I was "liberal" with the hyperbole----but not that far off:)

9:50am • #2

Charles - I have seen the word"serviceable" but there is generally an explanation of how the item was viewed and tested.  I would say to explain how you tested and viewed everything but there is no need to write up anything that is not a defect.

If the buyer is doing their job and actually attending the inspection, they will know what their inspector means by serviceable. Most buyers do not attend home inspections.

10:45am • #3

Hmm, I think my wife calls me that. Does that mean I'm useless, or just in need of being serviced?

Seriously, a lot of inspectors and inspection reports do use the word "serviceable", and quite honestly, I didn't see anything wrong with it, as long as if there IS something remarkable about the item, that it be further explained. Whether you use the word serviceable, or satisfactory, or good, or functioning as intended, or no defects noted, the basic idea is to get across that there is nothing remarkably wrong with the item, and that it will be of 'Service" to the user for it's intended purpose. Why go into a dissertation about it?

10:58am • #4
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Steve, I think the rub comes when we try to define what is defective.  To me there can often be lots that needs to be said about items that are functioning as intended.  I know the toilet is a "gross" example of that but it conveys my point.  As to the word "serviceable," Webster's definition of "serviceable" defines the word as:  1. helpful, 2, wearing well in use.  I don't think that either of these really describes what is going on or its "actual" condition.  Did you mean that most buyers "do not" attend the inspection?  Around here it is pretty rare for the buyer to not be present.

11:04am • #5
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Kevin, I don't in general have a lot of heartburn with what you are saying----just for me---the word serviceable has an element about it that says it is "able to be serviced."

11:08am • #6

I too, have done very FEW inspections where the buyer is NOT present. Occasionally, I get the out of town buyer or investor who is not present, but that is really the exception.

11:09am • #7

Charles - It has been my experience that more than 50% of buyers do not attend.  I make it very clear to my clients that they must attend the home inspection.

11:22am • #8
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Steve, I guess I could deal with that if I had to but it sure seems that everyone's liability goes way up if the buyer isn't actually there.  I go out of my way to make sure they are going to be there.  It is much easier to communicate how much "weight" to attach to what is discovered during the inspection-----makes the actual written report much less intimidating.

11:29am • #9
119,377 Points

Well gentlemen believe it or not, I have a 75% absentee on my inspections. ~ Roy

11:46am • #11

Wow Roy, that is amazing. It's really funny to see how different parts of the country are.

11:51am • #12
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Roy, ditto what Kevin said----amazing

11:57am • #13
368,760 Points 16 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Charles -Yikes, the photo gave me goose bumps and chills! Not in a good way! ~Rita

3:34pm • #14
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Rita, I will be looking into how to give you goosebumbs and chills in a good way then.  409 and a little elbow grease and it will be good as new----don't you think?

5:49pm • #15
382,808 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Charles .... How did you classify that beautiful toilet? Looks like a little toilet cleaner and it will be good-to-go.

Sean Allen

5:59pm • #16
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Sean, why?----what is wrong with the toilet? :)

7:28pm • #17
357,182 Points 11 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

 I see the term satisfactory a lot.  Is that a similar term?  Very nice blog and lovely toilet illustration!!

8:19pm • #18
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Barbara, I think that whatever terms like this that get used "can" be OK as long as all parties are ont the same page as to what they mean.  For example what is "satisfactory" for a component that is 100 years old has a different meaning than when used on something 1 year old.  What is satisfactory to one person might not be satisfactory to another.  A lot of people would have a problem with the toilet above being called "satisfactory"----but there might be someone somewhere on the planet that would be greatful to find such a device:)  Raven DeCroe

8:58pm • #19
NOV
07
2008
566,392 Points 10 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Before I ever started my home inspection company back in October 2001, my attorneys were able to show me lawsuits telling me that "serviceable" was not an acceptable term in my job. So be it. The lawsuit in question had a home inspection report where the water heater was not accessible, but what could be seen from 20 feet away looked okay, so it was passed off as serviceable. The only thing serviceable about it was that when all the furnishings and storage in the garage were removed, one could get to the water heater to service it, ergo "serviceable." Unfortunately, the only thing that was "serviceable" on it was disconnecting it and replacing it, ergo the lawsuit.

Courts here time and time again are telling home inspectors that they have knowledge that needs to be conveyed to their Clients. Such knowledge can include asbestos insulation on the water heater exhaust flue, lack of seismic straps, lack of a raised platform in the garage, etc.

2:23am • #20
199,943 Points 2 Featured Posts Outside Blog

A definite 'broad' term that shouldn't be used. 

11:53am • #21
261,225 Points 24 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

That's one nasty toilet! I wonder who was supposed to clean it last? I always hate to see the lid left in the up position! LOL

12:44pm • #22
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Russel----right on

Lyn, that is my thinking

Lizette, you have perhaps caught on to the only significant defect:)

12:55pm • #23

I honestly never thought of using the word in relation to inspections.  I guess the same goes for operable.  I suppose on that faucet that would mean that the handles turned, now water that is another subject altogether.

11:17pm • #24
NOV
10
2008
200,598 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Toilet is gross - and ................  PS you are out of T.P.

2:48pm • #25
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Jack----good one.  It "turned on---and you wanted water too?"

Kathleen, I called out to have the toilet paper roll replaced:)

4:02pm • #26
130,617 Points 2 Featured Posts

Charlie,

I have a distaste for the word serviceable as well. I have never used it. I think you're right on with how some guys bang em out.

The problem is many inspectors are deliberately vague or oblique in a misguided assumption that it somehow covers their a**.  The best way to cover your fanny is to do the absolute best job you can and continue to learn. No big secret.

You hit on another pet peeve of mine, reports. I can not tell you how it irks me when some inspector touts how good they are because they use this report or that report.  If you can't write an intelligent sentence or know the difference between a rafter and a rain gutter, the report you generate isn't going mean a whole lot.

Wow, you got me going.

4:05pm • #27
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

James, it sounds like we have a lot of the same pet peeves.  If you wander around the Internet and check out the sample reports of "most" home inspectors it is frankly----embarrassing.  I went to one once and it was all check-list with no narrative and it repeated itself three times.  I assume the repeats was some sort of "glitch"----but come on guys can you say "PROOF-READ"?  The foot you stick out on the Internet should not be in your mouth:)

4:13pm • #28
130,617 Points 2 Featured Posts

Charlie, You know what they say about great minds:)  The same can be said for some of those web sites.

4:27pm • #29
382,052 Points 23 Featured Posts Outside Blog

James, I think all professions have people that are "going through the motions" I guess.

6:02pm • #30

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
My blog is intended to provide information related to home inspections in Seattle, surrounding communities and anyone else interested. Sometimes I will provide information that has nothing to do with home inspections. Enjoy! Subscribe to feed

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find WA real estate agents and Seattle real estate on ActiveRain.