Special offer

Trying to buy a short sale? Why is it an AUCTION???

By
Real Estate Agent with Realty Executives

There are so many pitfalls and things to consider when you are looking at a short sale.  Unfortunately many agents are making the process harder for themselves and our clients which in turn continues to give short sales a bad rap.

Recently my clients had an offer in on a property that was exactly what they wanted.  It had a view, open floor plan, in a great neighborhood, and had three bedrooms and a loft.  There was some work that needed to be done on the property including fixing the garage door where the listing agent had tried to adhere his sign to the vinyl door and left marks that would render the door useless unless replaced.  All in all the pros outweighed the cons and my clients were in for the long haul which turned out to be about two months of their time. 

The listing agent was from out of the area so I'm sure that he had not seen the property since he had listed it.  He actually told us what other offers were in on the property.  In my offer I specifically asked the seller and agent to take the property off as an active listing and put it in back up.  There were already five or six offers on the property.

I called the agent to inquire why the listing was still active on the MLS after a week or so.  He said because he was an out of area agent that it was difficult to get the outside board to make the changes. This went on for some time.  After being the responsible agent and staying in touch about our offer, the listing agent told me that the bank was getting close to getting an approval and my client's offer had the highest net submitted. 

A week later I called to see how the approval was coming. The listing agent then told me that another cash offer had been submitted and was in the process of being approved.  In the mean time, the listing was still active on the MLS. 

I totally disagree with keeping a listing active on the MLS when an offer or offers have been submitted.  Who are we as short sale listing agents working for? Our clients or the bank? In case you answered the bank, I say, WRONG! We are working for the client.  So why do agents treat short listings like auctions and essentially are working for the bank?

I don't understand how an agent can think keeping a short sale listing open is a good thing.  I understand that buyers may walk from a transaction.  Guess what, they used to do that in regular transactions too.  And what did we do? We started over and got a new buyer.  If a short sale listing isn't selling, reduce the price!!  We all know that price is what sells a property. 

The thing that really upsets me the most is the lack of follow up that these agents are doing, and I'm seeing it rampant in both REO's and short sales.  If you have a list of people who have offers in on a listing, why don't you call the agents back? As a courtesy for one thing, but as a good business practice as another.  You never know if your current deal is going to fall out!  And when it does, wouldn't the previous offers be the first people that you call? I just don't get it. 

Are there any other agents out there that feel the best offer and only the best offer from a committed buyer who understands his offer is legitimately being considered is the one that should be submitted to the bank for a short sale?

Posted by

Susan Manning

Comments (6)

Tom Wood
Ad Maker Tool & Real Estate Auction Systems - Ballwin, MO

I agree, if the listing agents are submitting multiple offers to lenders on short sales, how do they ever expect the bank to respond. It's bad enough it takes as long as it does when you submit just one offer. Get the highest offer and submit that one only.

Nov 11, 2008 12:19 PM
Susan Manning
Realty Executives - Temecula, CA

Tom, why is that sometimes I think I'm going crazy because no one else understands my logic here???

Nov 11, 2008 12:20 PM
Gene Allen
Fathom Realty - Cary, NC
Realty Consultant for Cary Real Estate

I have seen many posts on the subject and part of the problem is that the first buyer goes away before the bank responds and the marketing starts all over again.  With multiple offers the bank has back up offers.  Not saying I agree with the practice but it is what I have seen and read.

Nov 13, 2008 08:47 AM
Susan Manning
Realty Executives - Temecula, CA

Gene, so you assume the first buyer really is no good?  Why even accept the offer? Isn't there something called good faith? 

Of course I do ask that the buyer expresses their committment to the transaction.  If by chance they start looking at other properties I ask the buyer's agent communicate that with me as well. 

So many agents are just too lazy to keep up with the regular communication.  That's another problem too. 

Nov 13, 2008 08:56 AM
Nelene Gibbs
NELENE GIBBS REAL ESTATE - Chesapeake, VA
e-Pro, Realtor - Chesapeake & Virginia Beach, Virg

Susan:

I so agree with you that  the best offer and only the best offer from a committed buyer who should be submitted to the bank for a short sale.  I recently represented a seller on a short sell and within two days of listing received an offer which I promptly submitted to the bank.  While we were waiting for the bank's decision, which took several weeks, we had several other agents that wanted to submit a bid on the property.  I informed them that until the bank either accepted or rejected the current  buyer's offer that they would have to wait.  It turned out the bank accepted the offer and my sellers were able to get out from under a house they could not afford and the buyer, who was willing to wait for the bank to respond, got a great deal on a  house.  I had given my word to the buyer's agent that I would not submit any other offers until we had an answer from the bank as to whether they accepted or rejected the original offer.  To me that is what we, as Realtor's, have an obligation to do for our clients as well as our fellow Realtors. 

Nov 13, 2008 03:10 PM
Gene Allen
Fathom Realty - Cary, NC
Realty Consultant for Cary Real Estate

What I am saying that a lot can happen in 60-90 days waiting.  I don't think buyers have the mindset to wait that long.  If the buyer walks the house goes into foreclosure.

Nov 14, 2008 12:26 PM