I found an interesting article  from the Chicago Tribune about political tolerance, and being respectful of other people's opinions and beliefs, especially when they differ from your own.  It details an experiment done by a 14 year-old girl in a Liberal suburb of Chicago, who shows up for school one day wearing a T-shirt supporting John McCain, and the next day wearing a T-shirt supporting Barack Obama.  Surprisingly, the reactions to her T-shirt from her classmates are not very different than would some of us experience in the adult world or while blogging in the political forums here on ActiveRain.

On the first day of her experiment, wearing a McCain shirt, the student was called among other things "stupid", told she should be "burned with her shirt on" and branded a "filthy rich Republican".  The next day, while donning her Obama shirt, the very same student was told that the students liked her shirt, she was no longer stupid and had "put the right shirt on" that day.   The reporter asks the student's teacher  "whether it was ironic that she would be subject to such intolerance from pro-Obama supporters in a community that prides itself on its liberal outlook."  The teacher agrees that those who are supporting a candidate that promotes equality and inclusion, should not have behaved in such a manner.  Everybody learns a great lesson... I guess until they become adults and start acting the same way

This article deals with children - in middle school - but the funny thing is that the very same intolerance and name calling occur here on a daily basis -in a community of professional adults!  It surprises me how quickly  some people are to call names or insult , when someone  expresses an opinion that is different from their own, (or heaven forbid presents them with pesky facts that seem to contradict the other person's point) .   Now some people are easily offended, and perhaps they should not be discussing sensitive subjects with strangers or potential business partners.  The same can be said for those who result to middle school like name calling as well.  In fact, those who resort to such tactics are really saying more about themselves than the person they are trying to put down. 

Now I know that some people don't think that political discussions have any place on a Real Estate networking site.  They think that you run the risk of alienating 50% of the people who read your blog or comments, since they may have a different political view from your own.  I don't agree.  For every person who doesn't want to shop for a mortgage or refer a customer in need of small business financing to me because they disagree with me politically, there is someone else who will shop for a mortgage or refer a client to me because we do see eye to eye (of course there are some people who don't care either way which political party you support as long as you give them the best deal). But I do think that if you want to discuss topics such as politics and grow your business at the same time that you should leave the name-calling, schoolyard insults, uninformed opinions, and intolerance out of it.  If this 14 year-old girl "get's it" and understands what tolerance is, then surely we should too.

 

 
Post is included in group: ActiveRain Uncensored
Post is included in group: Blatant Politics
Post is included in group: Dissent
Post is included in group: Politics And Real Estate
Post is included in group: Silent Majority

7 Comments on A Lesson in Tolerance - From a 14 year-old girl.

NOV
14
2008
189,497 Points 19 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Michelle, I once commented that I was quite liberal when I was younger. Back then, "liberal" to me meant someone who is tolerant of diversity and embraces change. But when I was thrust in ultra-liberal environments where the meaning of liberal took on a new meaning --- where it meant there is no tolerance for anyone who thinks differently than they --- it soured me.

Since then, I'm more centrist. But I waded into these political discussions when I saw there was unfair bias, starting with how the media treated Hillary Clinton...and then later, and magnified to the nth degree, Sarah Palin. It was shocking to see the vicious name-calling and vitriolic attacks from both sides.

So thanks for the reminder to be professional at all times.

We can all disagree, but not in a disagreeable fashion.

2:43am • #1
2 Featured Posts

Pacita - Thank you for your comments.  It is funny that some adults still insist on acting like children.

11:08am • #2
129,174 Points 5 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Well Michelle, where do you think these children get their ideas? It is from the adults that influence their day to day lives (even if it is from other children). Intolerance - abuse - name calling, all in the name of free speech. What me need is more laughter.

1:12pm • #3
NOV
15
2008
312,328 Points Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

I saw this ittle girl on the news this week . I was impressed with how creative and intelligent she was to come up with her experiment!

9:44am • #4

The same thing happened at my daughter's school. The obama supporters were not kind but it was the Mccain supporters who went to ISS because it was said that they were trrying to incite a riot by wearing clothing against obama. I don't understand that.

So now they say a new rule has been added about wearing political shirts. I can't wait to see the wording.

 

10:59am • #5
NOV
17
2 Featured Posts

Fred - I didn't even think of it that way.  I chalked it up to "kids will be kids", but I guess some people don't outgrow it.

Trey - The article states that her Dad is conservative but her mom is not.  Perhaps he helped her with the experiment.  She was also very brave to participate.

Cheri - it is funny that kids that can't vote have such strong opinions about things.  My daughter who is 10 also got into a political debate with her friends at school.  She said that only her and two other girls were McCain supporters.  I jokingly told her those were the only two girls that she should be friends with. :)  However, there was no name calling or riots or anything like that. 

11:55pm • #6
NOV
18

Okay....I'll play, but I have to ask if you considered that others would respond to your blogging about an article you found "interesting", with news reporting that should have been predictable enough for you not to bother with this obvious finger pointing exercise?

Obama election spurs race crimes around country - Yahoo! News

>..."Cross burnings. Schoolchildren chanting "Assassinate Obama." Black figures hung from nooses. Racial epithets scrawled on homes and cars.

Incidents around the country referring to President-elect Barack Obama are dampening the postelection glow of racial progress and harmony, highlighting the stubborn racism that remains in America.

From California to Maine, police have documented a range of alleged crimes, from vandalism and vague threats to at least one physical attack. Insults and taunts have been delivered by adults, college students and second-graders...."<

So....can we stop posting this kind of stuff now? Or is there some point to what you are trying to do here?

 

 


Ed LeFevre (angry curious Sort)
1:31am • #7

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Michelle Chamberlain - Suburban Philadelphia Mortgage Broker

Secane, PA

More about me…

Above All Financial Services -Pennsylvania Mortgage Broker

Office Phone: (888) 891-7704

Email Me

Get the Mortgage Rate Watch widget and many other great free widgets at Widgetbox!


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find PA real estate agents and Secane real estate on ActiveRain.