My apologies to the Wizard of Oz for stealing one of the Munchins' famous lines as they ask Dorothy, "Are you a good witch, or a bad witch?"

So...  Which of these shingles is good? That is, which is installed properly?

Good Shingle?

Good Shingle?

Look closely. Notice the nail head in the second picture. See how the head is slanted... the nail was not driven in straight and has cut the shingle slightly. Believe it or not, this slanted nail has voided the warranty on the shingle from the shingle manufacturer. Wow! A cut shingle is more susceptible to blow off.

But...

The shingle in the first picture is not right either. See the shiny back stripe that runs from left to right on the shingle just below the nail head. That stripe is called the "tar strip" and it actually bonds itself to the overlapping shingle to prevent blow off in high winds. AND, the nail is supposed to right in the middle of the tar strip. No nail in tar strip, no correct installation!

Not sure about your roof? Call me!

Tom Sinclair

About the House - Home Inspections

Fairhope, Alabama

(251) 990-3169

www.InspectTestAnalyze.com

 

 

2 Comments on Are You a Good Shingle, or a Bad Shingle?

APR
24
2007
221,329 Points 9 Featured Posts Outside Blog
Trick question, but a good one.  Thanks for posting.
9:15pm • #1
188,117 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog

What brand shingle is it, that calls for the nail in the tar strip?

The nail goes below the tar strip on the white line doesn't it?

I agree that both are wrong.  Both are too high on the shingle.

9:45pm • #2

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Tom Sinclair : About the House - Home Inspections

Mobile, AL

More about me…

About the House - Home Inspections

Address: 19940 State Highway 181, C4, Fairhope, AL, 36532

Office Phone: (251) 990-3169

Cell Phone: (251) 422-3169

Email Me

We all live in one, but just how much do we know about the house we live in? The articles posted here may help you understand your house better. As always, feel free to add a comment or ask a question. I will answer your email.


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find AL real estate agents and Mobile real estate on ActiveRain.