Special offer

60 Minutes: A Second Mortgage Disaster?

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner

First of all I need to thank Marc Rasmussen for bringing this segment to my attention on his blog because I was not aware of it.

I am also glad that 60 minutes had the foresight and courage to run a piece like this, even though it does instill concern about the direction of the housing market and ultimately the economy; there is simply too much at stake for this country, our government, and the REALTOR community to pretend that this type of threat to our housing market does not exist.  Or to simply hope that the problem will go away or take care of itself.  It's not going away, and it's not going to take care of itself without an awful lot of pain for an extended period of time - and quite frankly I'm not sure if most Americans are prepared to weather this type of correction.  As we are seeing, a housing correction will indeed spillover into every corner of our economy, the financial markets, and the credit markets.

The point that the 60 minute segment brings up, the fact that there are still millions of loans acting as ticking time bombs, is the fundamental issue as to the reason I wrote the, "It's The Housing Market, Stupid!" book.

This housing and home-ownership bubble that is the result of easy and cheap money and aggressive leverage, has not yet run it's course.  In fact, I would argue that we are only one third of the way through a correction.  And there are two reasons for this.  First, we are going to continue to see millions of foreclosures over the next four years.  Credit Suisse recently increased their estimates to 8.1 million foreclosures.  Asa result of the first wave of foreclosures, the supply of homes has surged 48% over the past three years (source: NAR).  The second concern is that there is not a buyer for these homes that will ultimately end up in foreclosure.  With the mortgage market as tight as it is, the demand for real estate has plummeted nearly 30% over the past three years (source: NAR).  It is a perfect storm, demand has plunged, and supply has surged.  And there is no indication or data that either of these trends is changing course, especially considering the broader economic concerns.    

Ordinarily, if this was just simply an isolated case of home prices declining further, it may not be so worrisome.  But the truth is that declines in home values, the leading cause of foreclosures, are anything but isolated. They have a significant spillover effect to the financial markets (including the stock market), the credit markets, and the broader economy (jobs).

While an unpopular position, I will admit that it is my belief that the economy will not be able recover from this current recession until the housing market, the foundation and engine for our economy, can get some price stability.  And what this means is that the excess supply of homes (approximately 1.5 million) needs to be absorbed, preferably sooner rather than later as the longer it takes for this to be accomplished, the more homeowners will be at risk and the more damage will be done to the economy.

The government needs to get ahead of this crisis rather than reacting to it.  Loan modifications and lower mortgage rates are not the answer, this is going to require aggressive fiscal policy to get Americans to invest in the real estate market in order to prevent a cascading effect on the overall economic health of this country.

www.ItsTheHousingMarketStupid.com

 

  

 

Comments(5)

Bridget Fredericks
Home After Home - Baton Rouge, LA

This 60 Minutes story is another example of the media run amuck.  I do understand that there are financial crises going on in various markets around the country that pertain to housing.  And I do understand that our goverment probably needs to take some action (what action I don't know).  But I'm wary of anyone who talks about the housing market on a national scale.  It's neither fair nor reasonable to compare a crash in one market to a healthy market in another locale.  In fact, all this negative news slows sales in otherwise healthy markets by impacting public perceptions.  I believe that we have a responsibility to talk about the real estate market within the confines of our local scope.

Dec 15, 2008 03:16 AM
Mark MacKenzie
Phoenix, AZ

Hi Bridget:

Thanks for your comment.

Yes there are markets that are not as affected as those markets in CA, AZ, NV, and FL, but with all due respect, sales and prices are down in every region in the country - per the NAR data.  Every region has shown home value declines by at least 10% from 2006.

Are there a handful of markets that have shown appreciation, sure, but the point of the article is not to identify which markets are doing well, but rather to identify that this foreclosure crisis is not over yet and that it is indeed going to have a spillover affect into the broader economy and as a result of this everybody will be affected.

What began as simply a sub prime fiasco, has snow balled into a global recession and the fact that there are still millions of foreclosures coming down the pipe is something that should not be ignored.

 

Dec 15, 2008 03:28 AM
Amanda Evans
DFW Living - Fort Worth, TX
Real Estate Broker - Fort Worth Texas

While it is fair and accurate to say that real estate is local, it is a reality that the credit crunch is not.  The fed can't lower the funds rate to the point that they pay to loan money so any idea of preventing the $1.5 TRILLION (with a T) wave of bad mortgages just from ALT-A and Option loans that is coming over the next 3 years is a fantasy.  $1.5 TRILLION (with a T) doesn't figure in a normal rate of default that is likely to occur in just your old fashioned bad economy.  Let's not forget that 2006 and 2007 "workouts" are starting to fail as well.  Every attempt to avert disaster so far has delayed the inevitable.

Wouldn't it be great if we could just change the channel?  I'd rather deal with reality and be as prepared as possible for what is to come.

Dec 15, 2008 04:47 AM
Mark MacKenzie
Phoenix, AZ

Thanks Amanda - great comment.

"I'd rather deal with reality and be as prepared as possible for what is to come."

By dismissing the truth about this economic and housing crisis we are at the same time eroding our credibility.

Dec 16, 2008 11:55 PM
Amanda Evans
DFW Living - Fort Worth, TX
Real Estate Broker - Fort Worth Texas

I just flagged this one for a feature.  It should have been featured back then but it was just too dang easy for people to stick their heads in the sand and say it isn't so.

Hope you are doing well.

 

Jun 02, 2010 12:17 PM