The public is tired of hearing that "real estate is local".

Okay, real estate sales conditions are local.  That is pretty obvious.  But, at the same time, NAR uses this cliche phrase over and over in television and radio commercials, in an attempt to reassure the public. 

It almost sounds as if NAR is trying to persuade consumers that there are particular areas where the impact of the national economy goes completely unnoticed, like a sort of Shangri-La, where it never rains and the streets are paved with gold.

The phrase "real estate is local" happens to be one of Lawrence Yun's favorite slogans (Yun is, after all, NAR's chief economist). 

The public isn't buying it.

Here's another NAR cliche.  "All markets are different".  Duh.  Yes, all markets are different, and this one certainly is no exception.  Things are different allright.  They're different enough that the Treasury Department and the Federal Reserve are, at the urging of Congress and the Executive Branch, frantically pouring money into bailout programs for banks, lenders, securities firms and Fortune 500 companies.

And here's another one from NAR's "Economist's Commentary" online: "For many, this is a golden opportunity to buy"

No one is saying there aren't opportunities out there.  But the general public sees pronouncements like this one as self-serving real estate industry cheerleading.

NAR is fond of talking about declining mortgage rates.  Ask the consumer on the street how easy it is for the average person to get one of these wonderful cut-rate mortgages.  Yes, it may be relatively "easy" if you have a top FICO score and lots of cash for a downpayment. 

My point is this.  Let's take advantage of the New Year to level with the public. 2009 gives us all the golden opportunity to start with a clean slate, to consistently provide consumers with a true picture of the real estate marketplace, whether national or local. 

 

 

 

11 Comments on 2009 Offers an Opportunity to Put Aside Real Estate Market Cliches

JAN
01
540,168 Points 13 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Hello Eric, I just stopped by to say hi and I hope that your 2009 is just fantastic!

Happy New Year!


your friend in Charlottesville!

9:34am • #1
1 Featured Post Hit Router

The NAR float in the Rose Parade.  What a waste of money.  

Happy New year to you!!!  Wishing you a Great 2009!

12:25pm • #2
126,028 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Charles, thank you for the New Year's good wishes!

Karen -- I agree, NAR seems to be pursuing the "business as usual" approach to the marketplace.  But it isn't business as usual.  NAR's membership has shrunk considerably, as has the membership of all state and local associations.  It seems ridiculous to be spending money on a Rose Parade float.

12:46pm • #3
JAN
02
161,554 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Eric - Happy New Year to you!  I hope you have a great 2009.  I think it will be a very difficult year for many.  I also think that it is a great time to buy! 

I didn't catch a view of the NAR float.... have seen some discouraging comments about it.  I saw a new ad on TV, it showed fence sitters, I'm not sure the public will get it....

12:22am • #4

Great points about all the cliche and how NAR is acting like cheerleaders...great points to think about.

9:31am • #5
JAN
03
126,028 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

April -- For those with cash or a high credit score and no debt, 2009 may be a great year to buy.  But until Congress, the Executive Branch and regulators induce the banks and the mortgage industry to turn the tap on again, it will be a rough year.

I spoke with a good friend last week who is an exec at one of the largest mortgage companies in the Midwest.  She admitted that lenders are looking for any excuse available to turn down a mortgage application.  She also admitted that most of the public will never be able to take advantage of the "discounted" mortgage rates that are being advertised currently.  And among other things, she says the vast majority of properties that used to appraise satisfactorily will not do so today.  So, all in all, the news isn't that great yet.

 

4:13pm • #6
JAN
04
161,554 Points 6 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Eric, I hope it's not that rough for so many people.  The banks looking for excuses NOT to lend really disheartens me.  ( I also think it's very unfair that banks will be cutting mortgage indebtedness and we the taxpayers will foot the bill. )  But, that's another story! 

4:21pm • #7
JAN
14
217,406 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Happy New Year Eric - your comment is right on point "lenders are looking for any excuse available to turn down a mortgage application."

This is what NAR should be focused on in their commercials

exposing where the real issues lay

Sincerely,

Grace

10:31am • #8
JAN
15
126,028 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Tim, thanks!

April -- Unfortunately, I'm seeing the lender foot-dragging in Wisconsin all too often.  I recently wound up taking a client to six different lenders before he was finally able to obtain a mortgage.  The fellow had a FICO score of over 800 and was essentially debt-free, with no car loan or credit card balances, in a very secure job.  He was treated like garbage by one lender after another.  I thought it was ridiculous.

Grace & Jeff -- In December, a good friend of mine who is in charge of the mortgage department at a large regional bank admitted to me that her bank is "pretty much doing everything they can to challenge new mortgage applications".  In a candid moment, she confessed that her bank (and others) are "looking for any possible excuse to kill a mortgage request".  She went on to tell me that the people on her bank Board of Directors are "scared as hell".

Until something is done to change that situation, all the cheerleading about lower mortgage rates is nothing more than deception.  The public deserves to know what is going on in real estate lending.

9:03am • #9
FEB
07
415,449 Points 59 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Hi Eric!  I'm hearing alot of what you're saying but, I have noticed that with the recent conversation about the potential new Bill, we may just have a breath of life left!  I know my mortgage friends are really pushing for the new $15K credit, that's for sure!

Debe in Charlotte

11:36pm • #10
123,183 Points Outside Blog

Debe, I hope the $15,000 tax credit for buyers accomplishes what it's supposed to.  I'm sure we all hope it will!

11:45pm • #11

This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Rainmaker_large

Eric Kodner, Lake Minnetonka Homes & Madeline Island Real Estate

Minnetonka, MN

More about me…

Wayzata Lakes Realty: Eric Kodner Sells Luxury Homes

Office Phone: (612) 670-2539

Email Me

Currency Converter <!-- Start of StatCounter Code -->
blog counter
<!-- End of StatCounter Code -->
View My Stats <!-- Site Meter --> Locations of visitors to this page Site Meter <!-- Copyright (c)2006 Site Meter -->


Wayzata, MN (55391) Weather Forecast



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find MN real estate agents and Minnetonka real estate on ActiveRain.