I know I'm preaching to the choir with most of you on Active Rain, but this is for the benefit of the Realtors on my team - most of whom have never blogged, so bear with me.

I was positively esctatic last night…

I talked a couple of the agents on my team into doing some hyper-local blogging, and they each started a blog 6 days ago. Yesterday evening, I got a Google alert about one of those agents’ posts, and when I searched Google, I found that his very first post is in the #1 position on Google for several phrases revolving around that neighborhood!

Even though it isn’t a highly competitive phrase, I was just happy that he could achieve a #1 ranking right out of the gate on a brand-new blog - with only one post!!!  He hadn’t even finished his “about me” page!  (It took me YEARS to learn how to even make it to the first page of Google without buying advertising or PPC campaigns, let alone make it to #1 for any given phrase.)  I shared my elation with my online Twitter friends, and got a sarcastic response from a skeptic: “Good for you! Now you can rake in leads from a phrase that is searched all of a dozen times a week.”  I responded with one of my favorite lines: “You may be right.

For those of you thinking low-volume search phrases aren’t worth the trouble, here is a little story for you. It is inspired by an old favorite show of mine - “Newhart”.

Meet Darryl and his brother Darryl.

Both are Realtors, and both work separately in the same market (which we’ll call “BIG CITY”).  They both started a blog at the same time, and both learned the same SEO strategies about search engine marketing.

Darryl 1 decided that since “Big City real estate” got 250,000 searches a month, he was going to roll up his sleeves, and get to the first page of Google to get some of that action.  He made his blog all about “Big City”, and all of his optimization efforts focused on phrases like “Big City real estate”, and “Homes in Big City”.  Darryl 2 happened to read The Long Tail - by Chris Anderson, and decided to optimize for much lower volume phrases by writing a post about “Small Neighborhood Big City real estate”. “Small Neighborhood Big City real estate” only gets about 400 searches a month, but hey, at least Darryl 2 can be a big fish in a little pond if he ranks well for that phrase.

 

 

Fast Forward 1 month:

Darryl 1 has written a post and gathered about a dozen links with anchor-text of “Big City real estate”. He does a search, and he’s ranking #250 on Google for that phrase.

Since no one looks beyond result #10 or #20, Darryl 1 isn’t getting any traffic yet.

Darryl 2 writes a post about “Small Neighborhood Big City real estate”, and gathers a few links pointing at that post. He does a search, and finds that he is #1 on Google for “Big City Small neighborhood real estate”, #3 for “Small neighborhood real estate.” and #6 for “Small neighborhood Big City”.

Those 3 phrases combined get about 1000 searches a month on Google, and Darryl 2 sets his first appointment as a result of the traffic he’s getting.

Fast Forward 3 months:

Darryl 1 writes 10 more blog posts, and continues to drive links at his site for the phrase “Big City real estate”.

He’s up to #125 on Google!

Still no traffic though.

After getting himself to #1 for dozens of phrases revolving around “Small Neighborhood”, Darryl 2 decided to write 10 posts about 10 neighborhoods, and is ranking on the first page of Google for 8 out of 10 of those posts.

Combined search engine traffic: 2500 visits a month.

Darryl 2 also has had 2 closings, has 3 clients under agency, and about 300 internet inquiries. As it turns out, even though it’s low volume traffic, his prospects are highly qualified and know exactly what they are looking for.

Fast Forward 6 months:

Darryl 1 has written a few more blog posts, but is still putting the majority of his efforts into link building for the phrase “Big City real estate”.

Still practically zero traffic (and those that are finding him seem to be “tire kickers”.)

But he’s close! He’s now #45 on Google for that high traffic phrase, and can’t wait for that day!!!  After all — Once he gets to page one of Google, he’ll hit the motherlode!!!

Darryl 2 has now written about most of the neighborhoods in Big City, and has now moved on to writing about neighborhoods in “Neighboring Big City”.

His listing presentations are now a piece of cake whenever he lists a home in one of the neighborhoods he has written about.  Surprisingly, when he tells the sellers that 80% of home buyers start their search on the internet, and then shows that he is #1 for “Neighborhood Big City real estate”, “Big City neighborhood real estate”, “Neighborhood Big City” AND “Neighborhood real  estate”, they cancel all of their other interviews with agents.

Total closings to date: 6
Listings on the market:5

Fast Forward 1 year:

Darryl 1 is up to #20 on Google, but has been out-Optimized by several competitors with deeper pockets. It becomes apparent that even though Darryl 1 is starting to see some traffic, making it to the first page of Google is going to take a lot of work. Making #1 is near impossible given the fact that more and more competitors are focusing on this market because of high search volumes.

If Darryl 1 ever does make it there, he’ll learn that although the traffic volumes are higher, the leads are of lower quality than the leads Darryl 2 has been getting for the past year.

Darryl 2 bought the “Waybury Inn” in “Small Neighborhood” to accomodate all of his out of town clients, and has 3 writers to continue to focus on Long tail topics such as restaurants in the area, hotels, etc.

As it turns out, because he has so many “low traffic, long tail blog posts” about areas within “Big City”, he is now ranking on page 1 for “Big City real estate” too!

Darryl 1 is now going to work for Darryl 2 on a 50% split as a showing agent until he gets his blog up to the first page of Google for "Big City real estate."

 

OK, OK — I realize that is a bit of an exaggeration, but the moral of the story is two-fold:

  1. Anyone can blog, and it doesn't have to be earth-shattering journalism. The important thing is that it is written with the reader's benefit in mind.  Optimize for the right long-tail topic and you'll rank with almost no effort at all.
  2. Cumulative traffic from dozens of long tail phrases with low search volumes can easily equal (or surpass) the traffic of one heavily searched phrase, and it could very well be higher quality traffic.

 

 
Post is included in group: Marketing 101
Post is included in group: Internet Lead Generation-How Best To Capture Your Audience
Post is included in group: Free Tools For Real Estate Agents
Post is included in group: Blogging & SEO
Post is included in group: Active Rain Newbies

46 Comments on Darryl & His Brother Darryl: A case study about "Long Tail" and Real Estate Marketing

FEB
11
454,812 Points 10 Featured Posts Outside Blog

You are right.  But you are missing one major point by being #1 on lots of small neighborhoods you become the expert and people think that you are "everywhere"

9:41am • #1
5 Featured Posts

Good for the Realtor in your office. Maybe you can send me the article that you used to get the first page ranking. stevensellsco@gmail.com

9:41am • #2
14 Featured Posts

Agreed Russ, you definitely have to map out a plan that fits with your market and your personal branding strategy.  However I think being an expert in several neighborhoods is actually a tighter focus than trying to be an expert of an entire city - that might have between 20 and 200 neighborhoods.  I also think getting exposure early on with very little effort in one or two neighborhoods beats taking months or years to get to #1 (or even the first page) for a highly competitive phrase.

Steven - Although I'm very proud of my agent and would love to share specifics of his success, I'm going to follow my own advice from yesterday & help him also get a few more slots in the top 10 for those keyphrases.

9:51am • #3
172,780 Points 1 Featured Post

Very cute way of making your point! Lot's of work too! Great strategy.

9:53am • #4
1 Featured Post

Interesting post.  I am very new to blogging and as yet have only blogged on ActiveRain.  I would love to learn more about blogging in general, but I feel like the old dog trying to learn new tricks.

10:11am • #5
14 Featured Posts

Karen - The biggest thing I was excited about was that getting my agent's post to rank #1 for his neighborhood search terms took no more than an hour or two.  He now has a formula he can wash/rinse/repeat and slowly begin to get more free internet traffic of his own - all while "under the radar" with everyone else putting tons of work into duking it out for "Big City real estate" terms.

10:12am • #6
14 Featured Posts

Richard - You're still WAY ahead of the curve considering only 5 to 7% of Realtors are blogging (and probably only 20% of them are doing it effectively).  Nice posts on your blog about Killeen TX! It'd be interesting to see how well a post about Chaffee Village or McNair Village would rank...

10:34am • #7
130,870 Points 24 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Joel -- This was one of the best descriptions of long tail I have ever read. I really cant say anything else other than that.

10:37am • #8
661,452 Points 108 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Joel - I love this explanation of the power of long-tail keywords.  Memorable and well-presented.  Nice job, buddy.

10:41am • #9
Outside Blog

Great Post and like the comparision you made...easy to understand and to see the results of both efforts and how powerful blogging can be.

Thanks

10:44am • #10
14 Featured Posts

Thanks Jason & Clint! That's a fantastic compliment comsidering you are both "upper crust" Active Rainers!

10:45am • #11
206,767 Points 26 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Great story ! - and good further explanation on long tail posts.

10:50am • #12
215,821 Points 1 Featured Post Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Morning Joel,  Either way it tales a lot of work and consistency.  Good selling to you.

10:52am • #13
3 Featured Posts

Great post.  I blog because I enjoy it and I learn from it.  I hope it is getting my name out there.

10:53am • #14
162,118 Points 9 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

This is very true. I have been focusing my blog posts on neighborhoods within my community, and as such, those posts are ranked on the first 2 pages of google, my flagship site gets link love from them, and I am now developing a multiple site (stealth site) on the first three pages with multiple search engine results.

11:02am • #15
655,536 Points 104 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Joel- wow! That is one consice and well researched post! I am all about the longtail. I get screamed at, made fun of, and ridiculed. Skeptics can do that all they want, I don't care. The proof is in the pudding! We get 2 to 3 listings every week from calls just from our Active Rain blog and those have translated into closed sales.

I would rather have fewer calls but they actually list and close than 100's of leads that you have to fish through and work your tail off for just to get those 2 listings or buyers! Hmmm, DO THE MATH! Katerina

11:07am • #16

Great story and exciting to hear how your agent had immediate success right out of the gate.  Focusing on several neighborhoods within a city definitely increases one's credibility as well as "google juice."

11:08am • #17
208,471 Points 7 Featured Posts Outside Blog

I just go after both. I realize it takes longer for more competitive phrases but if you never go for them you will never have a chance either. Do your research first.

11:08am • #18
655,536 Points 104 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Oh BTW- the longer the tail the better the lead. Also, the closer they are to making a decision. Why would I want leads for FLORIDA REAL ESTATE? They don't even know where in Florida they are moving to! Now, if they are looking for horse boarding facilities in Wellington Florida than I know they are getting ready to buy a house because horse people always look for horse facilities before they look for human facilities:) Katerina

11:09am • #19
178,248 Points 13 Featured Posts

Joel,

Thanks for clarifying and reinforcing this long tail phenomenon.

I am relatively new to blogging, and even newer to SEO, but I think I am finally understanding the game.

11:14am • #20
187,448 Points 3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor

Hi Joel,

I agree with all of the previous comments - this really is a superb job of making a very important point - mandatory reading for all who seek the holy grail of 1st page placement for Big City Real Estate.  Loved it and bookmarked it,

11:54am • #21
144,391 Points 13 Featured Posts

I am with Katerina.  I get leads off my neighborhood blogs and they are SOLID buyers who know what they want.  If you start to search by neighborhoods you are a focused buyer.  I like those...

 

 

11:57am • #22
Outside Blog Hit Router

Joel... Really great information and advice.  Glad you put it out there.  I, too, try to be like Daryll2.  great analogy.

12:13pm • #23

That makes me rethink my tags for sure.  Thanks for the info, Joel.

12:27pm • #24
157,011 Points 5 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Very interesting! Thanks for the links for additional reading as this subject as well.

12:38pm • #25

Another great way of bringing the point home.  I am beginning my blog campaign nd this is very useful information, thanks.

2:37pm • #26
263,053 Points 2 Featured Posts

Hi Joel -- Your example is so relevant in this confusing and emerging world of real estate blogging.  Hopefully, localism.com will ad some organization and even impetus to help us -- thanks to AR.  Regardless of platform, this post is very, very beneficial to know.  Thank you!

2:46pm • #27

Thanks for the info.  I have not hear of the book so I'll have to check it out.

2:56pm • #28
119,477 Points Hit Router

Long tail is a great way to go.  Also using niche market terms as well.  "Big City Waterfront" works great for me.

3:23pm • #29
142,611 Points 8 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

As it turns out, even though it’s low volume traffic, his prospects are highly qualified and know exactly what they are looking for.

That is the big plus to long tail prospects - sure saves me a lot of time and effort when they know what they are looking for.

Great post.

3:31pm • #30

Great post, Joel.  I'll be thinking of you the next time I post on my blog!

3:35pm • #32
4 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Great story!  Creativity and persistence pays!

3:57pm • #33
104,073 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog Hit Router

Joel - Great presentation and I'll keep including more long tail keywords in my blogs

6:37pm • #34
143,092 Points 22 Featured Posts

Joel,

Let's throw in some numbers here. 60% of search's in google are targeted keywords, that leaves 40% for longtail or natural keyword searches. If you target the 40% chances are you don't have much competition. This also means people are searching for specifics with a target. If you are there target chances are your auctually what they were looking for. Great post!

-Lisa

8:50pm • #35
163,455 Points 9 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Joel, I write quite a few neighborhood posts and I'm all over page 1 of google...sometimes I just google the neighborhoods to see me there on the front page, lol.  I am an IDIOT when it comes to technology, so if I can do it, anyone can.  I've made money from my neighborhood posts and I'm thrilled!  I agree with you completely.

That's great that your agent made it to the first page, on their first attempt!  Way to go :)

8:55pm • #36
3 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Joel the long tail concept is one that I am currently working into my business plan.  Great read and thanks for making the concept an easy one to grasp!  Take care and happy blogging!

9:48pm • #37
Outside Blog Hit Router

Hey Joel, thanks for that explaination. You made it very clear. I see what I need to do, and I can do it, too. But, here's my question: to find out if it's working, I need to run a Google Alert for "Small Neighborhood" (or whatever neighborhood I blog about) to learn if what I'm doing is working, right?

11:34pm • #38
14 Featured Posts

Hi Marianne,

A google alert will alert you when ANY posts with those keywords come up on the web. 

To find out if it's working, you could simply search Google for the neighborhood you are targeting a week or two after you write the post.  If you're not in the top 10, you'll need to send more links to that post until you ARE on the first page.  (Hint: On google search results, click on "preferences", and set your preferences so they show the top 100 (instead of just the top 10).  Then, you can simply hit "ctrl-F" and search for your blog URL.)

There is software you can purchase to monitor your rankings for hundreds (or even thousands) of phrases, but that's another blog post entirely.

11:49pm • #39
FEB
12

Joel- this post is fantastic and extremely encouraging... I agree that long tail marketing about small neighborhoods is the way to go.

4:01am • #40

great post, very encouraging to this small time blogger

11:32am • #41
FEB
14
Outside Blog Hit Router

Hey Joel, oh my. There's just so much to learn. I'll check this out ASAP...been busy lately, but ASAP. Say, how are your open houses going up there? We're really getting good turn outs down here. I think we're going to see an improvement in our market, soon.

2:53pm • #42
FEB
21
295,731 Points 4 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

What a great post!!! My friend Gail Tassey told me about this blog. so you can thank her for my comment points! Cheers!

Betina Foreman, Austin Realtor

6:11pm • #43
295,731 Points 4 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

What a great post!!! My friend Gail Tassey told me about this blog. so you can thank her for my comment points! Cheers!

Betina Foreman, Austin Realtor

6:11pm • #44
APR
09
Outside Blog Hit Router

This is a great article and I am glad to see it endorsed by so  many on AR.  I am sort of doing this now, but I need to be even more long tail.  Thanks.

4:00pm • #45
JUL
13
152,235 Points 2 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

Joel, I bookmarked a blog you did in April linking to this. I've been so busy and not doing the "learning" that I know is important to my efforts. Thankfully I found it so I could come back and go to your links.

I guess this is where I need to be putting more effort. Thank you for teaching us about these things!

5:10pm • #46

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Joel McDonald

Castle Pines North, CO

More about me…

Joel McDonald -- www.AutomatedHomefinder.com

Office Phone: (303) 410-0077

Email Me

As the owner of a Colorado real estate company, I hope to be able to share my 15 years of real estate marketing advice with anyone who is interested. I also look forward to interacting with the rest of you in the AR community who have so much to share.

To receive email updates of my new blog posts, enter your email address below:

Delivered by FeedBurner





Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find CO real estate agents and Castle Pines North real estate on ActiveRain.