I am working on a deal right now and though it wasn't required by county code, I encouraged my buyer to complete a septic inspection.  The water is city, not well - no inspection warranted.

The company who did the inspection is highly reputable but the recommendations begged another opinion, particularly given circumstances of a very heavy snow melt of a season's accumulation two days prior.  The downspouts on the back of the house were also submerged and not very far from the field.failed septic field

The verdict had been cautionary - septic field failure in one to three years.  The second and third opinions differed considerably.  This was the make or break part of the deal.  The sellers were already upside down in the mortgage, even with relocation company help, and the buyer was as far up in price as he could go.

Number two and three septic opinions turned in a different verdict and both said the field probably had plenty of life in it.  There wasn't true "failure" evident and the quality of the gravel/stone in the pit was evidence of that.  Most likely, water table conditions, clay soil, downspouts, flat lot, and the early spring thaw all contributed to the equation and initial verdict.

The lesson here?  When a buyer says they are about to throw in the towel on a deal, on a property they really like, seek additional advice!  There are so many variables in a situation like this that no one really can predict what might happen.  In this case, the family size will be decreasing from previous so right away there would be improved conditions in the field with less water usage.

This is a deal that could have fallen apart.  A reasonable buyer and additional advice is saving the deal.   All is well that ends well.  Now let's march to closing! 

 
This post has been included in Michigan Information Monroe County, MI Information
Post is included in group: Realtors®
Post is included in group: Posts to Localism
Post is included in group: Michigan Real Estate
Post is included in group: Investors
Post is included in group: Flipping Houses for Dummies!

6 Comments on So your septic field looks doomed?

MAR
01
258,669 Points 44 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Wow Susan, I'm surprised that the buyers would pay for a 2nd and a third opinion.  That is unusual.  Glad to hear though that the others showed a much different picture of the life left in the field.

4:24am • #1
4 Featured Posts

Kris, Both of the additional opinions were complimentary, luckily.  The buyer was willing to share his report with the experts.  One is a local operation the buyer would very likely now use for any work, particularly the pumping of the tank that he will do right away.  The second was someone I rely on regularly so he also was willing to look at the report/photos - he is a past Washtenaw County employee and knows just about everything!  If I have any sway at all, he is my go-to person.  I make sure he knows that.

4:34am • #2
1 Featured Post Localism Sponsor

Interesting - we deal with septic issues here on a regular basis and in the end, there is some risk involved no matter what the report says. Hope all goes well.

6:15am • #3
581,420 Points 95 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog Hit Router

 

It has to pass inspection of the Washtenaw Health Dept if it did, it is a non issue.

If it didn't then we negotiate who pays, sometimes the seller, sometimes both.

However, you must have that report to transfer the deed.

Glad it worked out and your buyers are comfortable with the sale.

8:37am • #4
MAR
02
4 Featured Posts

Hey Randall,  The buyer doesn't have any problem with accepting risk if there is any.  Two out of three inspectors said no to failure within the next couple of years, and they were the experts in the field, not home inspectors who were coincidentally licensed to do septic evaluation.

 

11:09am • #5
4 Featured Posts

Hi Missy,  The property is in Monroe County and they require no inspections or time of sale letter.  I wanted my buyer to get the inspection for his own sake and he agreed.  The mistake, in the end, was not using a specialist in septic inspections but just tacking it on to the home inspection.  One of the second opinions was from a former Washtenaw County septic specialist and you know if he said it was OK, it is OK - Washtenaw County has about the most stringent requirements around!

11:13am • #6

This blog does not allow anonymous comments

 
Rainmaker_large

Susan Walters

Ann Arbor, MI

More about me…

Keller Williams Realty, Ann Arbor, MI

Address: 2144 South State Street, Ann Arbor, MI, 48104

Office Phone: (734) 997-0337

Cell Phone: (734) 646-2081

Email Me

Generally anecdotal in style rather than a lot of statistics and facts. My goal is to allow fellow bloggers and the public to know who I am so they can comfortably work with me or refer business to me in the greater Ann Arbor, MI area.


Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find MI real estate agents and Ann Arbor real estate on ActiveRain.