The use of video in our business and personal lives has exploded in the past decade. From videotaping the children's recital to video blogging cameras seem to be everywhere. Many cities have even taken to placing cameras on streets, in police cars, and in holding cells. These are ostensibly to reduce crime, protect law enforcement officials, and suspects. There are the cries of big brother and the loss of privacy but apparently the benefit have outweighed this objections. I would hasten to guess that the video released late Friday afternoon will further protect law enforcement and suspects.

 

Here is the video. *BE WARNED THIS VIDEO IS GRAPHIC* After the video, I will give the explanation of the circumstances and the incident as related in statements from the police involved and the suspect.

 

 

The suspect who is in custody is a 15 year old female who was apprehended in a stolen car with another minor female. There have been no indications that the teenager resisted arrest at the scene nor at the Sea Tac City Hall (Seattle). There have been no accusations that the suspect was under the influence of any drugs.

The King's County Sheriff's deputy that assaulted the suspect is a 31 year old, eight year veteran of law enforcement. He has plead not guilty of a fourth degree assault for kicking her, slamming her to the floor, striking her, and pulling her hair in violence. Deputy Paul Schene could face a maximum of 1 year in jail if he is found guilty.

Unfortunately these types of videos are becoming much more commonplace on YouTube and other video sites. Aside from the violence being disturbing, the fact that a person in a position of control and authority can so loose control and abuse the authority entrusted to them is unsettling. I understand that law enforcement work in one of the most stressful professions one could possibly have. The added stress would be much too difficult for most ordinary people to cope with but law officers have training to deal with this stress. If the training is insufficient then that too must be addressed. Law enforcement officials are also aware of the stress that such a position holds before they choose to pursue that career. All of these reasons that can be given must pale in comparison to the overall negative impact such uncontrolled behavior, as that in the video, has upon law enforcement across the board.

And what of this 15 year old girl? We have civil rights, we have habeous corpus. Her guilt of the crime is irrelevant; she had not been found guilty and had not even seen a lawyer. Again, she was 15 years old and had been taken to Sea Tac City Hall to be booked.

 
This post has been included in Washington Information King County, WA Information
Post is included in group: Wrong Right Turn
Post is included in group: This Doesn't Belong On Active Rain
Post is included in group: The Lounge at Active Rain
Post is included in group: Proud to be a Liberal
Post is included in group: Blatant Politics

8 Comments on Big Brother, A Benefit?

MAR
03
203,138 Points 4 Featured Posts Outside Blog

Rich - a friend and I watched this video last night on the news.  He and I both worked law enforcement long ago and I can tell you this ... that deputy was out of control.

I'm not saying that a 15 yr old girl can't do damage, but in watching the tape she tried to run to the back of the cell when the door flew open.  She was not the aggressor at that point.  And once the deputy had her against the wall with his arm across the back of her neck ... well, she was under control.  The handcuffs (or soft cuffs, depending on what Seattle's jail protocol is) should have been used at that point.  No other action is required based on what is shown on that video.

I realize that the girl is probably not up for sainthood, but the deputy knew better than to act like that.  And he also knew it was being taped.  I am placing 99.9% of this on him.

Even if that girl did something horrendous (short of murder) she will probably be exonerated in court and set free because of his behavior.  He just contributed to the revolving door syndrome.

**Didn't the deputy claim that the girl "threw" her shoe at him?  All I can see is she kicked her shoe off, but not in a manner as to use it as a projectile.

 

1:16am • #1
137,609 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Carol - I hadn't seen it on the mainstream media news yet, I could have easily missed it. I came across it on the net yesterday. The girl did admit that she kicked her shoe off at him and that it struck him below the knee. Though the officer did instruct her to remove her shoes, I am sure he did not mean kick them off at him. I think the shoe was just an excuse as he told her repeatedly, from both parties accounts, that she would now be charged with assaulting him. Sad and scary situation as a citizen.

8:20am • #2
455,162 Points 28 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

Rich, I'm glad they're showing these videos.  It used to be a suspect's word against a policeman...now things are coming to light that wouldn't have before.  Sometimes people take a little too much power (or a lot).

4:27pm • #3
137,609 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Carole - It is important to know that law enforcement does cross the line sometimes. The girl was only 15 and he was a veteran trained police officer.

10:58pm • #4
MAR
05
287,948 Points 4 Featured Posts Localism Sponsor Outside Blog

While I don't want to live in a "big brother" state, and people need to be aware of what is going on. I was in London last summer and they have cameras EVERYWHERE. Our driver told us the average Londoner is caught on camera at least 300 times a DAY! mind boggling....

I have to agree this officer in the video was clearly out of line and should be repremanded. She followed his instruction and kicked off her shoe for God's sake, that is not an assault. How scared can a grown man be of a 15 year old girl?!? This is insanity!

7:58am • #5
137,609 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Betina - I too do not want to live in a Big Brother state. Those red light cameras, we have them here in Knoxville, are quite controversial and haven't been shown to reduce accidents. I don't mind if cameras are in jails, police stations, and other places where authority figures could abuse power; schools too maybe. I would not want it to be like it is in London.

He really was out of control. His behavior was just wrong.

8:21am • #6

This makes me absolutely sick to my stomach to watch.  I can not imagine anyone treating my 15 yr old daughter in this manner.  It looks as if she said something to the officer and he snapped.  I know my daughter can get mouthy at times but nothing warrants this kind of reaction.

10:13am • #7
137,609 Points 1 Featured Post Outside Blog

Marie - I hope a jury can see that. I can't imagine what his defense will be. His actions are indefensible.

7:07pm • #8

Leave a response…



(optional)
What does the graphic say?
 
Rainmaker_large

Rich Dansereau

Knoxville, TN

More about me…

Positive Real Estate Professionals

Office Phone: (865) 951-0522

Cell Phone: (727) 492-8389

Email Me

View Rich Dansereau's Profile on Stumble Upon

View Rich Dansereau's Profile on Digg

My BlogCatalog BlogRank

View Rich Dansereau's profile on LinkedIn

View Rich Dansereau's profile on Facebook

Clicky Web Analytics Clicky

Add to My Yahoo!

Add to Technorati Favorites

web tracker

Visit PREP


ss_blog_claim=fb1cc0f334b73851b8d1e4f0318db077



Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog

Find TN real estate agents and Knoxville real estate on ActiveRain.