old town: 421 William Street, Key West - Prime Property - 07/05/20 02:18 PM

I played "buyer" today and checked out the listing at 421 William Street in the Old Town area of Key West. Before we go inside, let's look at the way the house appeared in 1965 and compare basically the same view as it looks today.

A couple things are obvious: wrap around balconies were added on the first and second floor levels; a staircase was added to access the third floor space for one's brother-in-law; the concrete fence was removed and replaced by white picket fence and a gated off street parking space. Louvered windows and doors were replaced by wind resistant … (3 comments)

old town: 912 Fleming Street, Key West = Price Reduction - 04/30/20 05:20 AM

 
The asking price on 912 Fleming Street, Key West, was just reduced from $2,395,000 to $2,150,000. The historic house dates back to the later 1890s and has been updated and expanded. It now has six bedrooms and five bathrooms. There is a 750 SF legal apartment in the front that the owners do not rent but instead store their children's toys and bikes. This space could be renovated into a large main floor master bath by a new owner.

The house sits at the front of the 5,650 SF Lot which extends 115 Feet from the street. The view from the inside … (4 comments)

old town: 744 Windsor Lane, Key West - 02/08/19 02:35 AM
A hidden tropical paradise awaits behind the hand-carved Indonesian teak doors of 744 Windsor Lane. This extraordinary property presents an unassuming visage to the world: it looks like two classic Key West cottages joined together, and so it is. But once inside, prepare to be amazed. Behind the teak doors lies a secret interior courtyard with ponds and waterfalls and a multitude of exquisite plants. Gently rising blond stone steps lift above the water to a second grand entrance, and a second surprise: a home of enormous open spaces, clean modernist lines, and walls of windows overlooking a quarter-acre of manicured … (3 comments)

old town: 317 Angela Street, Key West - A New House in Old Town - 12/24/18 02:21 AM

Just listed, but not by me, 317 Angela Street, Key West. This is a brand new stick built house located in the Historic District. Locals and frequent visitors to Key West know that our old houses are protected and may not be torn down to build new houses. The explanation as to how this house came to be built is simple - the prior house (see the black and white photo below taken in 1965) was torn down in 2008 when the structure was declared "unsafe" by the city. The lot sat vacant for several years and was eventually purchased by … (1 comments)

old town: 605 Margaret Street, Key West - 09/02/18 01:24 AM

Buyers seeking an Old Town location should consider 605 Margaret Street, Key West  which the listing Realtor, not me, describes this way:
"This perfect Old Town Cottage is newly renovated as a single family 2 bedroom 2 bathroom home with a large bonus loft. The property can also be legally converted into two units per the City of Key West however the property is currently using one meter. This great location is only blocks away from Duval St and would make an excellent investment property."
 I searched through my old shoebox and found the above black and white photo taken in 1965. The … (5 comments)

old town: 1122 Whitehead Street, Key West - 08/12/18 05:26 AM

1122 Whitehead Street, Key West has an interesting history in usage. The building was built in 1880 when it was the Jos. Reves Cigar Factory and numbered 129 Whitehead Street on the 1889 Historic Sanborn Fire Map. The street number 1122 Whitehead Street appeared on the 1912 Map. It was the same property but it was then designated as a dwelling. For years and years the property was a legal duplex. The property has been renovated twice in the past ten years. When it sold in 2014 it had been awarded a certificate for excellence in historic preservation by the Historic … (2 comments)

old town: 713 Eaton Street, Key West - Price Reduced - 03/25/18 03:27 AM


The asking price on 713 Eaton Street in Old Town Key West was just reduced to $1,300,000. This truly is an historic home based not only on its historic construction also on its renovation by the iconic designer Angelo Donghia who personally resided here at the beginning of the Key West cultural and housing renaissance.   The listing broker describes this home as follow
"The house is a simple one story six room Conch house which was owned and renovated by Angelo Donghia,  I did not see the house before it was renovated, but I have seen so many old homes that I … (2 comments)

old town: 1109 Petronia Street, Key West - Just Listed - Legal Duplex - 12/08/17 05:25 AM

Just Listed - 1109 Petronia Street, Key West, Florida. This is a sweet legal duplex located on a quiet little block just east of the Key West cemetery. Petronia Street at this location runs only two blocks from White Street to Frances Street where it appropriately dead-ends at the cemetery.  A full time owner and/or tenants will love the location because it is near all the attractions around Duval Street and the historic seaport (it's within easy walking or biking distance to both), but it is far enough away not be a part of the hub-bub. I looked in my old … (3 comments)

old town: Key West - In the Wee Hours - 11/04/17 04:34 AM

I wish I were a better photographer so that I could share with you the views I see when I wake-up way too early most mornings.
 
Unlike the house above, my house sits behind a privacy fence obscured by a lot of palm trees and tropical foliage. I have Plantation shutters in the bedroom which I sometimes shut to block out the street light or maybe the moon. My office adjoins the bedroom. It also has shutters. I have tried but can't seem to take pictures from the inside looking out to the palms and the sky. My area of town is … (4 comments)

old town: 1126 Stump Lane, Key West - Open House - 09/03/17 02:56 AM

 Open House Today
12:00 to 2:00
1126 Stump Lane 
 
There is a lot of home built into this 570 square foot Key West cottage which the owners call "Little Shangri La". It has a formal entry hall that leads to the main living area with cathedral ceiling, Dade County Pine walls, a home office or spare guest room, and French doors which open out to the new AZEC deck. The bathroom has a Jacuzzi tub on the inside but there is an Outdoor Shower outside.

 
Offered fully furnished at $549,000.
 
 
(6 comments)

old town: 702 Catherine Street, Key West - Potential Vacation Rental - 05/04/17 09:29 AM

Just Listed. but not by me, 702 Catherine Street, located in Old Town Key West and about two blocks away from upper Duval Street where the cool people hang out. There several near by places like Frenchcies, Bab Boy Burrito, and the infamous LaTeDa where you can eat, drink, or be entertained, and walk home within a few minutes.  South Beach is nearby as well. Your guests can walk to a fun beach and not get lost nor get blisters on their feet for having to walk a couple of miles. South Beach is only three blocks away. At the same … (1 comments)

old town: 1509 Pine Street, Key West - Price Reduction - 04/07/17 12:20 PM

 
1509 Pine Street is located in the quiet Meadows Area of Key West. It is located a couple of blocks north of Bayview Park, the main city park in our little town. Many of the homes in this area were built around the turn of the Twentieth Century. While 1509 Pine may look like one of the historic older homes, it was built in 2008. It was built to the State of Florida's rigid building code and offers substantial reduced costs for insurance, maintenance, and power consumption. The asking price was just reduced to $1,299,000 or $797 per sq ft.  Read … (0 comments)

old town: 903 Eaton Street, Key West - Potential Renovation and More - 04/05/17 06:39 AM


Just Listed by yours truly, 903 Eaton Street in Key West, Florida. If you look at the above photos you may see a big open lot and maybe that's all. Maybe you see the beautiful home across the street and think maybe this is a good location where you might build an equally beautiful home. It's what you cannot see from the street that may make this property more interesting to you because there is an existing two bedroom, one bath home located at the rear of the property.


One of the great features of 903 Eaton Street is the lot size … (3 comments)

old town: 912 White Street, Key West - 03/24/17 11:34 AM

In 1886 an entire village for cigar makers was developed in one corner of Old Town Key West. The Pohalski and Co. cigar factory was located at the corner of White and Truman. Cottages lined the nearby streets and lanes as was typical of the other parts of town where other cigar factories were located.  The cigar maker cottages were simple in design and construction and provided basic shelter to factory workers. In his book The Streets of Key West, J. Willis Burke writes about Pohalski Village: "On the other side, off the western [should be eastern] side of the cemetery … (1 comments)

old town: 812 Fleming Street #5, Key West - Classic Key West Architecture - 03/22/17 09:13 AM

I have been selling houses and condos in Key West for twenty years. I remember a conversation I had with an agent in my office at the beginning of my real estate career. The lady agent had made a remark about a particular house as if she had just been inside. That puzzled me because the house was just listed that day. I asked her how she knew so much about the new listing. She said something like "Gary, there are only so many houses in Key West. We keep selling the same houses over and over again."  I got it. … (0 comments)

old town: 806 Virginia Street, Key West - A Treat of a Retreat - 03/04/17 06:25 AM

A couple of days ago during Realtor Caravan I got to see a house that I never knew existed. I had driven by it many times and I have written about other homes on the same block. But for some reason 806 Virginia Street in Key West had never caught my eye. But after having seen it, I really want to find a buyer for it. It is an unexpected treat which could be the right buyers special retreat. Let me tell you why.
I went to my old shoebox and found one of my favorite photos of old Key West. It … (2 comments)

old town: 730 Windsor Lane, Key West Florida - 03/01/17 09:00 AM

The listing Realtor describes 730 Windsor Lane this way:
"Have your morning con leches on the large front porch of this sweet two bedroom and two bath conch house located on Solares Hill. Many recent improvements including new kitchen, updated bathroom, sliding “barn” doors, bamboo flooring, and landscaping. Cute front yard and private rear deck. Home is currently configured with a mother-in-law suite but is easily converted back to a large first floor open floor plan."

I got to see this home a few weeks ago during Realtor caravan and realized I had not only been inside before but had also written a … (0 comments)

old town: 1013 Southard Street, Key West Florida - 02/28/17 11:43 AM

Just Listed 1013 Southard Street, Key West. This a classic Key West grand conch house which just been restored and which is awaiting new owners to create new memories of life on this little island out in the middle of the ocean.

I dug into my old shoebox and found two black and white photos of 1013 Southard Street. The top photo was taken in 1965 before renovations were made by a prior owner. The lower photo shows the house looking in much better repair presumably a few years later. The Monroe County Property Appraiser records show the house sold in 1971 … (0 comments)

old town: 611 William Street, Key West - 02/21/17 08:37 AM

The listing Realtor describes 611 William Street this way:
"Located on one of the most sought after streets in Key West, this Classic Revival Home has endless possibilities. The home boasts 3336 sq. feet of living space with wonderful porches both upstairs and down, this three-unit property could quickly return to its grand dame single family home roots. Or you could maintain it as it is. Move in today, live in one of the units and continue renting the other two. The property, with Dade County pine throughout, includes three units: a two-bedroom, two-bath owners' home on the ground floor, opening onto … (1 comments)

old town: 1019 Elgin Lane, Key West - 02/17/17 07:38 AM
This owner did everything right. This place is move-in ready and should sell quickly. The place has all new everything - mechanical, interiors, roof, pool, and so forth. The spaces and uses are well thought out and attractively done. The materials are contemporary in style and functionality. Most of the home on this block have been renovated in the past decade and would be considered as up graded when compared to many homes in the Old Town area. This house would make a good monthly vacation rental because of the three bedrooms, three baths, pool, and parking plus the terrific location … (1 comments)

 
Gary Thomas, Realtor to the Dreamers (Preferred Properties Key West)

Gary Thomas

Realtor to the Dreamers

Key West, FL

More about me…

Preferred Properties Key West

Address: 520 Southard Street, Key West, Fl, 33040

Mobile: 305-766-2642

Key West Real Estate That's what this blog is all about


Listings

Links

Archives

RSS 2.0 Feed for this blog