Special offer

RIS Media Says - One in Four Agents Should Go

By
Services for Real Estate Pros with Morgan Stanley
OK this is two times in a row that I am posting a RIS MEDIA article but I know that some people do not get this in there inbox.  We just have a post about discount brokerages being the anti-Christ and the internet will continue to change the business. I would love educated debate on who is pulling the cart down.

This article suggests there are just too many agents for everyone to support themselves so they can not stay full-time.  This pressures and allows them to discount their services since real estate is not their sole source of income.  This will force full time agents to support themselves in other ways financially and to (OH NO) discount as well.

I have heard that the internet alone is the reason for the drop in commission.  Given the millions spent in "lead generation" I almost think this is a counter argument.

I am holding back some thoughts:

Where do you sit in the one in four?
Why do you get the full 6% or more?
Why do you believe 6% is artificial and you charge a flat fee and it works?

We do not live in an 80/20 World - Try 93/7.

 Print this page Send to Printer

Average Realtor Productivity Collapses

Industry needs to lose one in four Realtors

RISMEDIA, May 18, 2007-We all know that 2000 - 2005 comprised one of the hottest real estate markets on record. During this period the country experienced a buying frenzy fed by low interest rates, a plate full of new mortgages, bullish customer confidence, low unemployment, strong economic growth and excellent price appreciation. Not only did home prices and the number of home sales surge but so did the number of Realtors.

As a result, according to the Swanepoel TRENDS Report, the industry is now burdened with too many licensed real estate agents and too many Realtors. Statistically the average Realtor sold about 30% fewer transaction sides in 2006 than in 2000 (see graph). Normal supply and demand would have resulted in halting the influx of new agents, but commission income was enhanced by the sharp increase in house prices. As a result, the number of agents and Realtors continued to grow past the market peak.

Transactions_per_agent.jpg

Along with the growth in broadband usage, cheap hardware and open-source software, the Internet is also rapidly creating a new home buying and selling playing field. In addition, as we saw this week on the CBS show, "60 Minutes" (‘Chipping Away at Realtors' Six Percent'), real estate commissions are also facing a strong threat of being sliced in half over the course of the next years. Add to that the fact that house prices are declining on a broad basis across the country and suddenly total commission dollars have a real possibility of a sharp decline over the next few years - maybe as much as $20 billion dollars.

So the real estate industry would actually be better off if we could reduce the number of agents and Realtors - say 25% over the next few years. If we don't see a reduction, there will be a large number of agents not able to make a living and the number of part-time agents will increase even more.

According to the 159-page Swanepoel TRENDS Report 2007, the 2000-2006 housing frenzy has spawned numerous additional issues contributing to a hangover affect. According to the Report, some side effects like the following will be part of the fallout:

Rise in the number of foreclosures
Increase in mortgage fraud

It's not that the real estate industry hasn't experienced a shifting housing market or any of these challenges before, but this time the added impact of the many new business models adds more pressure on the decline of commissions. It will certainly result in far more fundamental restructuring than ever before. "The residential real estate brokerage industry is shifting towards a new paradigm and the change can no longer be halted," said Swanepoel

Those real estate professionals that want to be the dominant players in the new real estate paradigm are going to have to rid themselves of yesterday's mindset and habits. The good news is that, according to Swanepoel, no single business model (traditional or new) has yet emerged as a clear winner. However, he strongly encourages brokers and agents to "to incorporate a strong online capability, a strong consumer-driven focus, offer a wide selection of services at a lower cost and above all remain current and knowledgeable about what is happening."

To stay on top of all of the trends and your options, get your copy of the encyclopedic 159-page 2007 Swanepoel TRENDS Report detailing the top 10 trends. Go towww.ReTrends.com and use the promo code RIS2007 for a 10% discount and free shipping.

RISMedia welcomes your questions and comments. Please send them torealestatemagazinefeedback@rismedia.com.


 
Laurie Mindnich
Centennial, CO
Jim- I missed this.  The assumption, when the market drops, is that the part time agents will disappear.  Evidently, that may not be the case- why should they?   As a person who works in real estate full time, based on this article, perhaps if companies eliminate the possibilty of part time Realtors at their companies, at least as the majority, it will be possible for those devoting full-time (as the customers deserve) to this industry to have the opportunity to rise to the top less impeded.
May 18, 2007 01:22 AM
Robert Whitelaw
Whitelaw & Sons Real Estate Services - Morgan Hill, CA
Broker, CEO, Realtor , ePro

If you took the word "internet" out of the equation these same kinds of things were being said back when I started in 1988.

As for the 1 in 4 thing, for my money, we could stand to lose a whole lot more than that if we just got ride of the agents who don't know what they are doing. 

May 18, 2007 02:38 AM
Jim Bishop
Morgan Stanley - Dublin, OH
Laurie -
I think the answer to your general question is yes.  However, the suggestion seems to be though MORE agents (%) will work or become part time in a down market.  This then created more discounting, forcing even more agents to work part time (with another basis for financial support).

In this world of independent contractors, what is part time and full time, don't leave out production in the question and answer.
May 18, 2007 06:23 AM