As a real estate professionals, you need to be aware that there are "secret shoppers" scouting open houses and rental vacancies trying to catch real estate agents in a fair housing violation. Those "secret shoppers" are fair housing testers.
Fair housing testing is an invaluable tool used in measuring the practices of housing providers relating to the Fair Housing Act. Some unlawful housing discrimination practices can only be discovered through fair housing testing. Information gathered through fair housing testing can be used as evidence to support a client's administrative housing discrimination complaint with the Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD") or a private lawsuit against a housing provider. The United States Supreme Court has recognized and affirmed the important of fair housing testing in fighting housing discrimination.
In order to enforce fair housing laws, the Housing and Civil Enforcement Section of the Civil Rights Division of the United States Department of Justice ("DOJ"), brings suit to enforce the Fair Housing Act, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, and familial status. The Fair Housing Act authorizes the DOJ to bring suits where investigations yield evidence of a pattern or practice of illegal housing discrimination.
In 1991, the DOJ's Civil Rights Division established a fair housing testing program and commenced testing in 1992. Testing refers to the use of individuals who, without any bona fide intent to rent or purchase a home, apartment, or other dwelling, pose as prospective buyers or renters of real estate for the purpose of gathering information, which may indicate whether a housing provider is complying with fair housing laws. The primary focus of the fair housing testing program has been to identify unlawful housing discrimination based on race, national origin, disability, or familial status.
The DOJ's Housing and Civil Enforcement Section employs various means to accomplish testing in local communities, including contracts with private fair housing organizations, contracts with individuals, and by using non-attorney DOJ employees throughout the country. The DOJ employees are volunteers who have been trained to participate as testers. Since 1992, the testing program has recruited and trained over 1,000 employees from various DOJ components throughout the nation to participate as testers. These are in addition to the numerous individuals retained by private fair housing organizations. The Housing and Civil Enforcement Section conducts numerous investigations simultaneously at any given time.
Testing is a method to determine whether or not a home seeker is treated differently in his or her search for housing. A person's race or national origin, for example, would be impermissible factors upon which to base a denial of an opportunity to purchase a home. Testing for housing discrimination involves individual testers posing as prospective home buyers or renters. Testers are paired and assigned profiles so that they are equally qualified to rent or purchase an apartment or home in question. They are similar in all respects except for one of the protected classes, such as race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, national origin, age, or marital status. The experiences of testers are used to compare the treatment of one home seeker (protected class) to another (non-protected class). In this context, testing measures the difference in treatment afforded a home seeker as determined by the information and services provided by real estate firms, property management firms, Realtors, rental agents and others.
If differences are found that relate to race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, national origin, age, or marital status, a housing discrimination is filed. Over the past thirteen years, the DOJ has filed 79 pattern and practice testing cases with evidence directly generated from the fair housing testing program. The vast majority of testing cases filed to date are based on testing evidence that involved allegations of agents misrepresenting the availability of rental units or offering different terms and conditions based on race, and/or national origin, and/or familial status. Of the 79 suits filed, 78 have been resolved. Of the 78 resolved cases, the Department has recovered more than $12 million, including over $2 million in civil penalties and over $10.3 million in other damages.
Don't be surprised if your next customer is actually a fair housing tester. And, don't be confident that you'll be able to spot a fair housing tester "from a mile away" as many agents think. As the fair housing testing program matures, the on-the-ground testers are better trained than ever and even more difficult to detect.
*********************************************************************************
To learn more about fair housing (and many other topics affecting Michigan real estate professionals), please visit us at www.123ConEd.com. We are the leading provider of online Michigan continuing education courses to real estate professionals.
Comments(4)