Special offer

New Appraisal Rules are increasing costs for borrowers

By
Mortgage and Lending with Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation NMLS #2289 Individual NMLS #74935

The new Home Valuation Code of Conduct that became de facto law on May 1st has already started to increase the appraisal costs to the borrower.   One of my lenders is now asking for $450 for an appraisal that used to cost $375.  Another one of my lenders, Idaho Housing is asking for a $500 check up front to order the appraisal.  In one case we have an appraiser quote $675 for her fee on one of our loans.

For those not yet familiar with the HVCC, it requires the loan officer to be disconnected from the appraisal ordering process.  Most wholesale lenders have taken this a step further and have a separatedepartment or an appraisal management company that orders the appraisal for the loan.  This eliminates the ability to choose known appraisers who have demonstrated a level of competence and service in the past.  The appraisal may not be assignable to other lenders should the loan have to be moved.  It is possible that a borrower will get stuck paying for multiple appraisal on a property.

How do we plan on avoiding this?  On purchase transactions, the bulk of my business, we submit the loan with out an appraisal. If the lender doesn't like it, too bad.  The appraisal will be ordered after we have underwriting conditions back and have reviewed the conditions.  This will slow down the process as I have typically sent in a complete package to the lender.

It sounds like a mess, but as ususal we will rise to the new challenges that our industry faces. 

 

Comments (4)

Ethan Carlson
Advantage Lending Corp. - Rochester, MI
Licensed Loan Officer

It seems it's another case of doing before thinking it through all the way - I would hope they wouldn't purposely want to stick borrowers with multiple appraisals at higher costs!

May 12, 2009 07:46 AM
Debi Braulik
www.roundrealestate.com - Maple Valley, WA
Selling Maple Valley to Fife WA Homes For Sale

I don't understand how/why it increases costs to buyer when the appraisals are now sent to a clearing house and the actual appraiser is only paid $275. If that. And when appraisers are not properly paid for their time and effort, how good is that appraisal really going to be?

May 12, 2009 07:49 AM
Robert Rauf
CMG Home Loans - Toms River, NJ

The only one that benefits from the AMC is the newly formed Appraisal mgt Companies.  Thank you to Big Brother Uncle Sam looking after us, there is 0 benefit.  It just sticks someone in the middle to raise costs since they need to take their cut.  It just slows things down, drops quality, drops levels of service and adds costs. It makes it harder to call an appraiser for an opinion on a difficult property prior to taking a deal as well. 

Andrew Cuomo has NEVER done anything good for the Real Estate industry.

May 12, 2009 08:16 AM
Roger Howell
Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation NMLS #2289 - Boise, ID
We do business the Fair way!

Ethan, its a case of the lenders not wanting to certify the new appraisals as HVCC compliant. In theory, they could accept an appraisal from another lender, like we used to do, but they don't want to take the risk of a buy back from Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. We just have to be dead certain about where we take our clients to so we don't end up in a multiple appraisal situation. Debi, the reason for the increase in appraisals is that the newly formed Appraisal Management Companies are taking up to 50% of the appraisers fee.  The appraisers are raising their fees to cover this "haircut".  Robert, you're right about Andrew Cuomo not being a friend of the Real Estate Industry.  I hope everyone remembers this when he starts talking about running for President.

May 12, 2009 08:35 AM