I will make this short and sweet, which is unusual for me, but anyone either in the market to buy or sell, or a real estate professional has an opinion on this current first time buyer tax credit. Now to debate the actual effects of the credit, good or bad, or how it is or is not market manipulation or control at some level is beyond the scope of this post, no matter how well founded or accurate they may or may not be. But like the cash for clunkers this is indeed creating a real shift in demand at least in the short term. Again the long term effect will be another matter all togeher for another time. So here are the top 3 pros and cons as I see it as a real estate professional and a property investor. And my idea to continue the plan so there is no cash for clunker type hangover period should it expire as set to do so in a matter of weeks.
Pro's:
1. Stimulates many on the fence buyers to go ahead an purchase property now rather than later
2. Helps to reduce the inventory available and in theory stabilize prices in the target price range.
3. Gives real a tangible monetary benefit to the average person, not an untangible corporation or group
Con's:
1. Limited to the typical first time home buyer target market and price range which may not address problems that created the current climate
2. Artificial inducement to act may create hangover effect in the future and creates minimum expectation standard for the future, and which may arguably be the root of the problem in the first place
3. By creating a hard deadline creates problems by rushing to act by too much of a sense of urgency to act.
My solution:
Now the numbers are arbitrary and can and should be adjusted as required for area and budget reasons. But here is a plan I think could be introduced to extend and most importantly expand the current credit.
The Ty Brown Real Estate Stimulus and Recovery Act of 2009
- $8,000 Federal Tax Credit in the first year for ANY owner occupied purchaser to be given to the buyer similar to the same current guidelines, except open to ALL buyers.
- and additional $1,000 interest credit towards federal taxes for each of the next 6 years the purchaser remains in the home.
- $2,000 incentive to purchaser to make home more energy efficient should home be in need, again similar to current guidelines -or-
-$8,000 principal reduction credit for a current seller that must sell their home that in turn purchases a new home that will lower their monthly mortgage payment by at least 20%. Then they would not be eligible for the $8,000 credit but would be eligible for the $1,000 interest credit and energy efficiency credit.
So this would be a great deal for someone that wanted to sell their home and couldnt because the value has decreased. They could lower their price by $8,000, the buyer could still use the $8,000 toward the purchase, and both could go to a new home and use the remaining credits.
The two biggest hurdles are 1. Who would fund the $8,000 principle reduction, and 2. Again is this TOO much artificial stimulus in a open market....
Comments(3)