Special offer

LENDER FORBEARANCE? In Reality, It's a SHAM!

By
Real Estate Agent with Dean's Team - Keller Williams Realty Partners Chicago IL

Good Afternoon from Chicago, folks!  Hope you're enjoying the weekend.

A crazy turn of events this past week has left my head spinning regarding Mortgage Lender Priorities, and whether major banks really have the mettle, or any desire, to play a real part in getting the U.S. past our ongoing Housing Crisis.

Here in Chicago, short sales are everywhere.  In some Chicago Neighborhoods and Suburbs, they make up more than half of the available inventory for sale. 

Bank-owned Foreclosed Properties?  Drive through virtually any Chicago Neighborhood - affluent, in the middle, or economically depressed - and you'll see at least a couple of boarded up homes on every block.  These represent stark reminders that a true housing turnaround, with balanced for-sale and homes-sold inventory, may still be a long time off.

If you have ever been directly involved negotiating with a major bank on a short sale transaction, you know the time line has been, and continues to be, excruciatingly long.  Disrespect is rampant - lender to borrower, lender to real estate professionals, and, eventually, the distressed seller, to everyone else involved.

Buying a foreclosed home?  You know how arduous that process is well.  Often times, Listing Agents who represent REO Properties are not responsive to your phone calls or emails.  Presentations get delayed.  In some cases, included personal property even gets removed for personal gain of the Listing Agents themselves.

Like a Las Vegas Table Game, the odds favor the "house."  The house, in this case - the lenders. 

Despite the fact they were instrumental in creating this mess with their "creative lending practices,"  they seem act as if they would just as soon pretend that resolving the problems they created, is not their problem! 

Funny how major banks, who could often turn loan approval around in 10 days when the market was strong, and who would grant substantial credit line extensions to over-extended borrowers after a two-minute phone call, don't seem to want to come up with a system to help us get out of this mess!

YOU CANNOT TELL ME IT IS NOT POSSIBLE TO MOVE MORE QUICKLY!

This week, we have had one client who has waited nearly eight months for the Bank of America to respond to their short sale request.  Eight months!  We're on the second buyer, may go to a third.  Yet, still we wait!

The reason, they say - They have a "major backlog" of short sale transactions awaiting approval.  No staff to expedite them.  Thousands more pour in each day!  "Sorry . . . the delays just can't be helped," they imply.

But, hey - if all of these were new mortgage apps, when times were better - miraculously, they all got processed.  Quickly!  If they wouldn't have, the potential borrowers would have moved to another lender, who would have processed just as quickly.

Now, however - to much work, not enough hands!

We're working with another client, with four young children, including a newborn.  Unable to sell their home, the borrowed against a credit card to pay their bills, including their mortgage payment.  This, after heavy bank solicitation with those "teaser" checks to draw money from their credit account @ 1.9% for three months.

After the teaser period - the rate leaps exponentially - to 20.99%!

They are in trouble, but the solicitations for more credit keep coming!   Near instant approval promised, enticing them to bury themselves even deeper!

With four young kids, the temptation is strong to keep themselves "solvent," but they are intelligent enough to know this is only a sham.  They are sinking deeper and deeper into debt, with the "encouragement" of their lenders!

God-Fearing, religious people, these clients feel it is their moral obligations to live up to their financial responsibility.  Paying late runs against their grain.  They have asked their banks to help!

Their response - something like, "Come call us when you are really behind!  You're still current!  Why are you bothering us now?"

The old suggestion to contact your creditors BEFORE you get into trouble, but when you see trouble brewing?  It doesn't really work!  And, in some cases, it creates a flag on your file to watch your behavior with greater scrutiny!

Indeed, the truth can actually hurt you!

You buy a big-ticket item, like a major kitchen appliance, or a computer.  Indeed, the purchase process, and approval for any financing, may take minutes.

But the service call on a problematic purchase - likely, days, perhaps longer!  And at the sole convenience of the manufacturer!

It appears, here in 2010, the advertised promise of Forbearance is merely "face time."  Good Public Relations. With no true intent to help behind it.

Frustrating for all involved!

You agree?  Please share!

DEAN & DEAN'S TEAM CHICAGO

Comments(4)

Evelyn Santiago, Managing Broker Heart Realty Group, Inc.
Heart Realty Group, Inc.. - Oswego, IL
Passionate About Real Estate & Our Clients!

The "house" definitely has the upper hand in delaying the short sale, cutting our commission and not playing by the rules.  They disregard the investors guidelines as well as Fannie, Freddie and anyone else.  They abuse what power they give their service reps and negotiators and then they get offended if we lose our cool.

Boycotting is not going to work with them, stop doing business with them is hard when the 4-5 banks control most of the business.  I don't think public humiliation will even work because they don't care about their reputation any longer.  Just like a school bully they take advantage of the circumstances to suit their needs and their needs only.

All we can do is to continue pushing the short sales through and trying to be as professional as we can under very trying conditions.

Unless we can push someone that really knows the real estate business to get into politics and in a position to push the right buttons we are going to have to figure out a way to deal with them.

 

Jan 31, 2010 04:32 AM
Mark L. Ostrovsky
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services - Beachwood, OH
Howard Hanna Real Estate Services

Your observations are right on the money though deception as a lender business model hardly comes as a surprise these days. Anyway, keep fighting the good fight!

Jan 31, 2010 04:34 AM
Randy Schulenburg
Schulenburg Realty, Inc. - Pingree Grove, IL
Schulenburg Realty, Inc.

I have seen the same thing over and over again.  This also applies to the "hope" of a mortgage loan modification for a homeowner trying to stay in their house.  You would think a lender would want to move swiftly to help in this case.

One example:

Client contacted lender several months in advance of any late payments after realizing that their income was not climbing faster than their savings was disappearing.  Lender said, "You're not behind so there's nothing we can do.  Did you try refinancing?"

Couldn't refinance because no equity.  This was before HARP loans.  Also couldn't refinance because new job.  Couldn't verify what income can be considered until a two year history.

A few months later the call came again to the lender.  They still said the same things.  This time, however, the homeowner cornered the bank on a recorded conversation where the bank said "Don't make your payments for 3 months and we'll consider it."

So, after having 800+ credit scores, the homeowner made the decision to do just that.  They stopped making payments on their mortgage because there was no other choice.  I should also tell you that the homeowner did list the property and had been trying to sell their home for close to 9 months by this time.  No offers.  No lookers.

Three months later the lender said they'd consider a loan modification.  Client sent in all paperwork.  The bank put the client on a 3 month trial period.  After the 1st payment the client received foreclosure papers.  What's up with that?!?!

Fast forward today.  The client is still in the home, has made 5 mortgage payments on the '3 month Trial Plan', and is about to make a 6th.  The lender says to keep making the payments and that they are in final review.  "Ignore" the foreclosure papers.  The client has heard this for 4 months.

In the meantime the home continues down the foreclosure path.  Which will happen first?!

Jan 31, 2010 05:20 AM
Not a real person
San Diego, CA

Just stopping by to invite you to the ActiveRain Super Bowl Party. Stop by if you get a chance. Geaux Saints!

Feb 07, 2010 06:17 AM