Should you sell your house or rent it out instead?

By
Real Estate Agent with Skinner Realty, Inc. 100014788





It's not uncommon for home sellers, especially sellers looking to move up, to ponder whether or not they'd rather just sell their current home or turn it into an investment that they rent out to someone else.

Some benefits of becoming a landlord

Your home goes from being a roof over your head to an investment, which if handled properly, can provide some nice coin for you throughout the life of the investment.

You don't have to go through the time, cost and hassle of selling your current home. (Yes even as a real estate agent I'll be the first to tell you selling your home is NOT cheap, easy or stress free - I like to think that I do whatever I can to minimize these costs but I know first hand what a pain in the rear it is to have your home on the market.)

If you're concerned about a soft market for sellers you can reap the benefits of
A. holding on to your current home until it appreciates more and
B. buying a home you really want now and take advantage of a buyer's market.

Some costs of becoming a landlord

You may not be able to rent your home right away so you'll be paying 2 mortgages or you may rent right away but find yourself tenantless (is that a word?) somewhere down the road and again, have to bear that cost.

There is always the possibility that you can run into some seriously bad apples as renters. They can stiff you on the rent, tear up your house and just cause all kinds of problems you never anticipated. On top of all that, some states make it extremely difficult to keep a tenant's deposit - yes, even when they have wreaked havoc on your home.

Realize that if you do rent out your home and then decide to sell later on, you may be subject to capital gains tax. If it's not a primary residence for at least two years (within a 5 year period) and if your gains are more than $250,000 for an individual or $500,000 for a couple you may be looking at paying capital gains tax.

Further Research

Becoming a landlord is a huge undertaking and while I certainly don't discourage it, I urge you to thoroughly educate yourself before jumping in. I am currently in the middle of reading these 2 (what can I say, I'm easily distracted) great books:

The Wall Street Journal. Complete Real-Estate Investing Guidebook by David Crook

The Millionaire Real Estate Investor by Gary Keller

Granted, they're not strictly based on being a landlord but they have a lot to say on investing in real estate which I think is important to learn whether you're renting out one home or 10 or even an entire apartment complex.

Finally, have a chat with your accountant, your insurance agent, your mortgage broker and possibly a lawyer to make sure your backside is covered (from several different sides!).

 

 

Comments (6)

Patricia Kennedy
RLAH Real Estate - Washington, DC
Home in the Capital
I think a lot depends on your local landlord/tenant laws.  I have people thinking about renting go to Blockbusters to rent "Pacific Heights", that classic real estate horror movie!
Jul 14, 2007 09:10 AM
Brad Snyder
Sierra Vista Realty - Sierra Vista, AZ
Five stars for you. Great post. In a cooling market there will be many people looking at the renting option and there are benefits for doing so and it depends on your situation. Very helpful post.
Jul 14, 2007 09:27 AM
Beth Skinner
Skinner Realty, Inc. - Broomfield, CO
World class service - with a personal touch!

Pacific Heights? I feel kinda out of the loop, I've never seen it! I better go get it.

I've definitely come across more than one landlord here in CO who just gives the deposit back and eats the cost because the tenant became such a pill it wasn't worth squabbling with them.

And I think (Boulder expert anyone?) in Boulder you have to pay a pre-determined interest rate, to the renter, on their deposit, NOT just the market rate? Sigh. Gotta love Boulder.

Jul 14, 2007 09:27 AM
Beth Skinner
Skinner Realty, Inc. - Broomfield, CO
World class service - with a personal touch!

Thanks Brad. I'm definitely considering it with my house - with a little dog (who I am certain would bite a stranger who walked into her house) and 2 cats I have no clue as to how I would ever show this house for starters. And then there's that whole making the bed every day thing... 

I also think there will be a number of high-income"ish" folks in the next few years, who got in over their heads with their own homes, had to walk away or short sale and will need a nice rental home for a couple of years until they're able to buy again. I'd actually offer them a very good deal on my house if they'd offer to clean the basement for me. Oh yeah, and the garage.

Jul 14, 2007 09:33 AM
Yolanda Hoversten
Self Employed - O'Fallon, IL
Broker - O Fallon, IL Real Estate

Hello, Beth!

We rented our single family home in C. Springs for over 15 years with only three tenants (yes, a miracle), and we decided to sell it last year without considering a 1031 Exchange.  Big mistake!  Lucky in tenants but not with IRS.  LOL  Very informative post--thank you!

 

Jul 15, 2007 01:52 PM
Beth Skinner
Skinner Realty, Inc. - Broomfield, CO
World class service - with a personal touch!
Yuppers! The Wall Street Journal book talks about the 1031 Exchanges. (Is anyone lucky with the IRS???)
Jul 15, 2007 03:49 PM

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?