Rookie VS Veteran- Which Agent Should Represent You?

By
Real Estate Agent with eXp Realty

As an agent coming up on my 8th year in the business, I continue to wonder how a rookie can even survive in this market. Make no mistake, this is the toughest market that I have seen and hope to ever see again. Gone are the days when listings would sell just because you had it priced right or it was the best house in the neighborhood. Don't get me wrong, this is a tough market but I am an over the top optimist that I can do a great job for my clients regardless of the market.

Yes, the market is tough but who can convey the realities of the market better, a veteran or a rookie? Who will be more excited to go to work for a particular client, a veteran or a rookie? While I am pretty sure of those answers, I just thought I would throw out my own observations on who will/can actually do a better job. If all thing were equal, here is my list.

                         ________________________________________________The Veteran          The Rookie

  • Who will have a better understanding of the market in general?                              
  • Who will be more enthusiatic about selling your home?                                                               
  • Who is more likely to do open houses every weekend?                                                             
  • Who will do a better job of keeping his/her seller informed?                                   
  • Who will be better able to negotiate on a sellers behalf?                                        
  • Who will have advantage with technology?                                                                              
  • Who is more likely to get the sale?                                                                      

In my opinion the veteran is more likely to get the job done but an enthusiastic rookie will get his/her hands dirty and jump in. I am most certainly not slamming the rookie but rather re-enforcing the benefits of using an agent that has seen both the good and bad market. A rookie will tend to get too over zealous, whereas an experienced agent will hopefully keep things in perspective. Either way, seller should look for an optimist or forget it.

 

Comments (7)

Wendy Montoya, REALTORĀ® Broker Associate, 254-315-4906
Towne Adams REALTORS - Waco, TX

So are you telling us that this is how you felt when you were a rookie? Just curious. Because I know many "rookies" that outshine "veterans" , up-to-date education, drive to succeed, very technologically advanced, etc.

There are great veterans and great rookies. It really all boils down to the person. Nothing can replace experience, but nothing can replace a conscientious, well-educated, hard-worker that knows his/her stuff either. Veterans and Rookies alike can be beat when it comes to everything you mentioned.

By the way, I think I am still technically a Rookie, 2 years into this, and I have seen both the pros and cons of each.

It never ceases to amaze me what lack of quality service I have seen from people both old and new to the business, and the excellent service I have seen from both old and new to the business. It goes both ways.

If you ask me, you can put a check mark in every box on my side. I meet or exceed all of those criteria.

Jul 15, 2007 01:57 PM
Sharon Simms
Coastal Properties Group International - Christie's International - Saint Petersburg, FL
St. Petersburg FL - CRS CIPS CLHMS RSPS
Sometimes the rookie will have more time to devote to their customer/client. Some people would rather be a "one and only" than one of the crowd.
Jul 15, 2007 01:58 PM
Chuck Christensen
Your Financial Coach - Bellingham, WA
Great comment Wendy and Sharon. Seems someone is full of themselves and forgot how tough it is to start out. I have seen alot of veterans that are so busy they don't have time for clients once the contract is sign. Then they always ask me to just call their client when I have Mortgage questions. I had a Realtor even ask me to stop by their house and get the key to let in the appraiser. I laughed so hard I hung up on her...and then called the selling agent who gladly did it....selling agent was a rookie...and still knows how to give good service....
Jul 15, 2007 02:57 PM
Doug Lindstrom
eXp Realty - Loveland, CO
Wow, so far, based on the comments, I'm taking a pretty good beating. As I re-read my post, I'm just not seeing how my post is apparently so one sided. Either way, the intent was to open up some discussion and more than anything else to maintain a level of optimism in this market (rookie or veteran).
Jul 15, 2007 03:09 PM
Darrel Quebedeaux
Evergreen Realty & Associates Inc. - Newport Coast, CA
I could make a case for the rookie too but I understand your point.
Jul 15, 2007 03:17 PM
Wendy Montoya, REALTORĀ® Broker Associate, 254-315-4906
Towne Adams REALTORS - Waco, TX

Doug, I think you are trying to foster some thought on Rookies vs. Veteran agents. Not trying to beat anyone up, but I am still curious to how you felt when you first started. I know I put my heart and soul into it and still do. I think it shows in the work I do.

I guess I really don't have the perspective of a true Vet yet, so maybe someone will comment with more time in this business than I.  I can see how experience in any situation may be preferable to lack of experience. But I guess since I feel pretty experienced in life, I just don't find experience to be a given good.

Jul 15, 2007 03:31 PM
Doug Lindstrom
eXp Realty - Loveland, CO

Sorry folks, I'm not talking about feelings or saying that the rookie is evil. I'm simply pointing out from a sellers perspective who would be better choice to list your home in this market. If my post was unclear, I will try to some it up. From a consumer point of view, who would you rather work with.....

A skilled veteran surgeon or a fresh out of medical school student?
An experienced accountant or a bookkeeper turned accountant?
Someone well versed in contracts or someone just learning how to write a contract?

I'm not against rookies and Chuck, I do know how hard it is to start out. I did it and had to overcome the same issues that rookies of today have to go through. Needless to say, buyers and sellers are the ultimate judge of whom they work with and more power to anyone who finds a way to convince a seller that you are the best agent for the job.

Jul 15, 2007 04:22 PM

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?