Admin

Was the Home Buyer Tax Credit a Huge Waste of Money?

By
Real Estate Technology with Anywhere Real Estate

OK.  Take a deep breath.  The Home Buyer Tax Credit extension has expired.  Now what?

Many Realtors (and our association) argued vehemently that the tax credit was crucial to the housing recovery.    My contention is that the housing tax credit was a huge waste of money and did not come close to offering the gain in the housing market that it should have for what was spent. Moreover, we can't afford it.

Consider the following chart from the congressional budget office.  Notice that 60% of our tax dollars pay for three programs. 

60% of the money we spend goes to three things: 1) National Defense, 2) Social Security, and 3) Medicaid, Medicare, and CHIP.

What this chart does not tell you is that we are only collecting enough taxes to pay for 60% of the things the government spends money on.  In other words, we only collect enough tax money for the 3 things listed above.  Every other dollar we spend is borrowed from other nations, and to a lesser degree, private investors.

Imagine what would happen to your family if you put 40% of your monthly expenses on your credit card.  That's precisely what our nation is doing.  We are borrowing trillions each year to pay for these "Cash for "Clunker ," and "Home Buyer Tax Credits."

I would say that you and I are paying for folks to get new houses and new cars, but in actuality, the Chinese are paying for it, and you and I are just paying the interest on the loans they lend us to run these programs.

I'd be interested to hear your thoughts.

Comments(3)

Show All Comments Sort:
Mike Morrison
Will & Will Real Estate Brokers, The Woodlands, Texas - Houston, TX

Ray, well put! I asked several realtors in my office,"who's really paying for this tax credit"? The overall response

was, Who Cares, I'm making money. You can't get through to folks that think like that. That includes NAR and

my local association.

Mike Morrison

Realty Associates

Houston, Tx.

May 06, 2010 04:36 AM
Ray Garrett, Jr.
Anywhere Real Estate - Raleigh, NC
Director of Productivity and Innovation

@Mike, Well put.  Now that we have taken 2010s buyers out of the market prematurely, lets see how good of an idea they think it was at the end of the summer.

Their response is much like those who are the recipients of any governemnt program; "Who cares?  I'm getting mine!"

May 06, 2010 04:39 AM
David Saks
Memphis, TN
Broker / Industry Analyst

Home median value will be more impacted and fall in some regions without the tax incentives. Other creative measures will have to be pursued including some seller concessions regarding price or other options, i.e., warranties, repairs or allowance for such, Cash needed to close will have to be examined carefully considering the fact that no future offset or ROI will be committed by the tax incentive.

May 06, 2010 04:47 AM