Warning The FHA Reform Act (H.R. 5072) Contains Very Dangerous "Strategic Default" Provision
I thought this was a very interesting post by Fred Martin from San Jose, CA. I thought this information would be intriguing for others. Enjoy!
Warning The FHA Reform Act (H.R. 5072) Contains Very Dangerous "Strategic Default" Provision
The "Strategic Default" Provision inserted in this bill has potentially very dangerous implications due to its current complete lack of any definition of what constitutes a "Strategic default" was tacked onto the bill at the last minute would make homeowners who "strategically default" ineligible for an FHA-insured loan in the future.
The rider was introduced by Rep. Chris Lee (R-New York). " The provision passed in a voice vote, without opposition.
It would require when and if passed by the Senate and Signed by the President that the HUD Secretary devise a strategy for defining and pinpointing "strategic defaulters", and then implement screening procedures to ensure these past foreclosed upon homeowners are not granted an FHA Backed loan in the future
The FHA Reform Act is supported by a wide coalition of organizations, including the National Association of Realtors, Mortgage Bankers Association, and National Association Of Home Builders.
"The FHA reform bill, including the Agency ban on "Strategic Defaulters", has not yet been approved by the Senate. The National Association of Realtors needs to move rapidly and strongly be sure that this very dangerous Strategic Default Provision is either dropped from the bill or very carefully defined and restricted in the Senate Version
My concern regarding this provision is that it will as currently drafted would give the HUD Secretary the unrestricted power to wipe out any possibility of future FHA backed financing and the possibility of home ownership for a large group of American citizens for the rest of their lives without any limitations or definition of what is a "Strategic Default". This provision could subject millions of Americans who are part of the 25% of the population currently under water on their home loans and looking at a possible foreclosure to a life time banishment from home ownership and being sentenced to being a renter for the rest of your life after losing your home in this national economic crisis. Think of the social, political and economic implications of this Draconian provision passed by the House without any restrictions or definitions.
Potentially millions of middle class Americans losing their homes and then being forced to rent for the rest of their lives. Future property and home ownership being limited to those current home owners with current equity in their homes and enough income or cash reserves to survive this recession. Future buyers and owners could be limited only to the wealthy. institutions and international investors.
Am I over reacting?
What is the definition of the Strategic Default" provision of this Bill that could subject potentially millions of Americans to these extreme life time economic sanctions and associated Nationwide transfer of home owner property rights and ownership privileges.
If the home owner had tried to a loan modification and failed would he or she be a Strategic Defaulter ineligible for an FHA-insured loan in the future.
If the defaulting home owner had been given a high interest rate variable rate loan on their now upside down home which increased to the point that they could no longer afford to keep up their payments and keep their children in College and or make their Medical Insurance Premium Payments would that be a "Strategic Default".
If the home owner had tried to do a short sale and the bank would not agree since their loan was covered by PMI or they would not agree upon the value what then?
If the home owner owed $500,000 on a non recourse first loan on their home and its current market value was $200,000 and tried to do a short sale but the bank would not release without a recourse note. If that home went to foreclosure on the advice of the owners accountant or attorney would that be a Strategic Default" with a life time FHA Credit Ban penalty.
If the lenders holding the foreclosed notes did not make a "good faith effort" to work with the home owner attempting a loan modification or Short Sale including a principal reduction on a home in a area that might be under water for the next 20 years. Would that be a "Strategic Default."
Feel free to use your own imagination to develop a list of all the possible different areas of potential abuse and conflict of interest between lenders and millions of underwater American home owners facing the potential of future foreclosure on their existing homes.
Let's look to the actual wording of the bill passed out of the house to the senate for guidance to see what it says about these issues and my concerns.
34
HR 5072 RFS
1
SEC. 25. PROHIBITION OF MORTGAGE INSURANCE FOR
2
BORROWERS WITH STRATEGIC DEFAULTS.
3
Section 203 of the National Housing Act (12 U.S.C.
4
1709), as amended by the preceding provisions of this Act,
5
is further amended by adding at the end the following new
6
subsection:
7
‘‘(z) PROHIBITION OF MORTGAGE INSURANCE FOR
8
BORROWERS WITH STRATEGIC DEFAULTS.-
9
‘‘(1) PROHIBITION.-The Secretary may not
10
newly insure any mortgage under this title that is
11
secured by a 1- to 4-family dwelling unless the
morgagee has determined, in accordance with such
13
standards and requirements established by the
Secretary, that the mortgagor under such mortgage has
15
not previously engaged in any strategic default with
16
respect to any residential mortgage loan.
17
‘‘(2) STRATEGIC DEFAULT.-For purposes of
18
this subsection, the term ‘strategic default' means,
19
with respect to a residential mortgage loan, an
intentional default having such characteristics or
21
under such circumstances as the Secretary shall, by
22
regulation, provide.''.???
23
SEC. 26. PROHIBITION ON TAXPAYER BAILOUT OF FHA
Well I guess it's all been very carefully thought out and defined so Americas current and future Home Owners have absolutely nothing to worry about..............
Fred Martin
Comments(1)