Shadow Inventory-What It Is And Its Affect on The Real Estate Market

By
Real Estate Appraiser with Thomas Horn, Real Estate Appraiser

To some, the phrase 'Shadow Inventory' conjures up dark images and impending doom, kind of like the Darth Vader character from Star Wars. You may not have heard of shadow inventory as it is not mentioned too much in the mainstream media. I've seen several definitions of shadow inventory, however it typically includes all the homes which are currently in foreclosure or those homes that are delinquent and will probably go into foreclosure, and which have not yet been put on the market for sale.Shadow Inventory can be as scary as Darth Vader.

In a recent article on their website the Wall Street Journal stated that it would take 103 months, or almost 9 years, to sell off shadow inventory. This is based on the rate at which banks are liquidating the inventory they currently have. Of course if the banks are able to streamline the process, and shorten the time to sell their REO (real estate owned) properties, this time period could be shortened.

You may ask, "What does this have to do with me? It can effect the value of your home because as these foreclosed houses enter the market, at their reduced prices, your homes value could also be reduced. As appraisers we measure value by comparing the home we are appraising to other similar recently sold homes. As more and more of these homes sell they will start to "make the market" and cannot be ignored. This has been happening already but could increase as this additional wave of foreclosures hit the market. Foreclosures could increase in the future.

As an appraiser one question I get a lot is "how can you use a foreclosure as a comparable?". Many times there are no better sales to use. In addition to closed sales we also look at active listings, and if the only homes listed for sale are foreclosures, and they are comparable in condition and physical characteristics, then a typical buyer would consider buying the foreclosure and it has to be analyzed. As appraisers we read and interpret the market and are subject to its various fluctuations.

The government is currently pushing its Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP), which could help more people stay in their homes and reduce the shadow inventory. If it is successful it would go a long way in reducing the Wall Street Journals recent prediction. We can only hope the force will be with us.

Comments (10)

Joel Gwillim
CIR Realty - Condo Specialist - Calgary, AB
Associate - REALTORĀ®

How about pocket listings? I'm finding myself with a good supply of these lately too.

Nov 05, 2010 02:37 AM
Tom Horn
Thomas Horn, Real Estate Appraiser - Alabaster, AL
Appraising The American Dream

Mike, thanks for your comments.  I'm not sure I've heard of pocket listings.  What is that?

Nov 05, 2010 02:39 AM
Dorothy Tanno
ReMax Realty 9 - Jackson, NJ

Very good explanation Tom, thanks for posting this.

Nov 05, 2010 02:41 AM
Richard L. Sanderson
Richard L. Sanderson Consulting - Kalama, WA
helping improve local property tax systems

Tom:

Thanks for your post.  The shadow inventory has a lot of people here in the Washington D.C. metro area concerned. The residential market picked up this summer and fall but could be adversely affected if too many bank-owned properties came on the market too soon.

Nov 05, 2010 05:55 AM
Tom Horn
Thomas Horn, Real Estate Appraiser - Alabaster, AL
Appraising The American Dream

Richard,

The continual stream of foreclosures is unfortunate, however until the inventory is depleted, it is going to affect "normal sales".  I think people all over the country are worried.  Thanks for your comments.

Nov 05, 2010 07:52 AM
Jesse Skolkin
Independent New York State Certified Real Estate Appraiser - Fresh Meadows, NY

Since the market is based upon supply and demand, the "shadow inventory" will have an effect on some markets for many years to come.

Nov 05, 2010 12:05 PM
Marcy Moyer
eXp Realty of California Silicon Valley Probate, Trust, and Investment Sales - Mountain View, CA
Probate, Trust, and Investment Specialist

I have noticed a trend in the silicon valley, especially in the higher end areas with fewer distressed sles, that the banks are not selling at that much of a discount, and not approving short sales much under retail value if at all. While it drives listing agents crazy, it is probably better for the home values in the long run.

Nov 05, 2010 03:55 PM
Richard Glesser
North Country Appraisal Services - Gaylord, MI

A key factor with the "shadow inventory" in my market area is condition.  Prior to the big downfall, foreclosure homes were generally rare and in poor to fair condition with repairs necessary.  When the volume increased a couple years ago, this trend continued.  At that point, they could not be considered part of the typical market since they could not be financed through the secondary market due to needed repairs which require cash reserves by investors to make necessary repairs.  So the market became divided further into an investor market which purchased most foreclosures and an owner-occupied, traditional buyers market which bought homes financing-ready with no repairs.  Over the past year or two, more "strategic" default homes seem to be entering the market which are well maintained, requiring no repairs, and sell for a slight discount rather than the deep discount of the former REO sales.

Nov 07, 2010 03:29 AM
Tom Horn
Thomas Horn, Real Estate Appraiser - Alabaster, AL
Appraising The American Dream

Jesse- You are right.  As the WSJ suggests it could be years.

Marcy- I would think it would be better for the market if they were not sold at a discount.  When they are that just brings the other ones down.

Richard- I have been finding the same thing regarding condition.  Some of the foreclosures are nicer than the normal sales.

Nov 07, 2010 05:35 AM
Ann Allen Hoover
RE/MAX Advantage South - Hoover, AL
CDPE SRES ASP e-PRO Realtor - Homes for Sale - AL

Hi Tom, I agree.....shadow inventory is ominous stuff for all of us.  You've done a nice job of explaining why foreclosures are considered as comps.

Nov 10, 2010 12:48 AM

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?