Special offer

How Much is Too Much?

By
Services for Real Estate Pros with Second Self Virtual Assistance

Facebook mugshotsWe have to face it...we live in the age of information.  Between 24/7, round-the-clock news coverage and Internet accessibility, we are constantly bombarded with images and info.  How much is too much?

I recently read about the City of Huntington Beach proposing to post names and mug shots of individuals arrested for DUI on Facebook in an effort to curb the city's growing alcohol problem (the city is California's #1 source of alcohol-related incidents, with 1687 people arrested for DUI in 2009 and 195 either injured or killed due to alcohol-related incidents).  Of course, privacy groups think this is an invasion of an individual's right to privacy, especially since these individuals have only been arrested and not convicted of a crime yet.

Many employers are turning to places like Facebook and Twitter to see what is posted by their current employees as well as prospective ones.  Having something like this posted could seriously harm an individual financially as well as socially.  But, if it keeps people from drinking, driving and hurting/killing someone, it could be a good thing.  I'm honestly torn on the issue.

Do you feel this is an invasion of privacy, a possible throwback to the public floggings that happened in Pilgrim times? Or could this serve as a more tangible deterrent for anyone looking at tying one on and then getting behind the wheel?  I'm interested in what side of the argument you fall on.  Please let me know how much you think is too much.

Heather Chavez, Real Estate Virtual Assistant - Second Self Virtual Assistance: When There Isn't Enough of You to Go Around!

Comments (5)

Christine R. Sutherland
Sun Realty USA, Inc. - Punta Gorda, FL
REALTOR - RSPS, e-Pro, TRC

Nobody is guilty until proven innocent.  Yes, publish anyone who hsa been convicted, but not people who have not yet been convicted.  That's seems fair!

Jan 21, 2011 03:13 PM
Richard Strahm
American Foursquare Realty - Lansdale, PA
Lansdale and North Penn Real Estate

In many areas, a list of local arrests (the police blotter) is printed in the local paper.  These are arrests, mind you, not convictions!  Putting the information on Facebook is just a natural extension of that in our Internet age.

Statistics show that most people arrested of something are guilty of it!

Jan 21, 2011 11:20 PM
Richard Strahm
American Foursquare Realty - Lansdale, PA
Lansdale and North Penn Real Estate

Christine in #1 - If you suspected your neighbor was a pedophile, but had not concrete proof, and then found out he was arrested for pedophila -- wouldn't you come forward with what you knew?  Or if you knew a friend had been arrested for a DUI -- but he was with you all day at a conference and you knew he hadn't had anything to drink -- wouldn't you want to help?   Keeping arrest data secret does neither society nor the arrestee any good.

Jan 21, 2011 11:23 PM
Renee Marrs Caperton
Marrs & Associates - Corsicana, TX
Realtor - Corsicana Texas Real Estate

We are blasted with too much information and invasion of privacy.  Convicted of a crime?  Sure, post them.  

Jan 22, 2011 01:12 AM
Michael Kitsch
Coldwell Banker - Katy, TX

Seems like WAY too much to me.  It is an invasion of privacy if you have not given specific permission to research you.  Unless you have a security position, or some other highly relevant position (in which written permission should STILL be needed), to me this is an invasion of privacy. 

Feb 14, 2011 08:09 AM