Special offer

Extreme Makeover For Fannie and Freddie, Episode II

By
Real Estate Agent with DK Professionals Realty Lake Lure 174394

In  recent months, just about everyone involved in the housing industry has met with lawmakers to discuss the Fannie and Freddie makeover mandated by the same law that bailed them out to the tune of 134 BILLION of taxpayer money.

The government has helped would-be homebuyers by guaranteeing mortgages for a long time, since the 1930s.  But many Republicans blame Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac for the housing bubble and subsequent POP that took the US economy with it.  The two government controlled mortgage giants guarantee loans for private investors.  Some new members of Congress - especially Tea Partiers- see a clear mandate from the voters who have put them in office for less government intervention in the economy and for letting private capital do its work.  Representative Hensarling of Texas, fourth-ranking Republican in the House, recently said he would introduce legislation to transfer Fannie and Freddie's role entirely to the private sector within five years.

On the other side is the housing industry which worries that without government guarantees, mortgages will not be available for many Americans.  Investors and the industry argue that without government guarantee, mortgages will become much more expensive or simply unavailable whenever investors decide to back off mortgages as an investment. 

One possible solution proposed is an FDIC type insurance program that the mortgage industry would fund in exchange for government support.  But some say that any government guarantees eliminate an essential element of market environment: investors' risk analysis.  They worry that any government guarantee would lead us back to a repeat of the recent  scenario of deteriorating underwriting standards for mortgages and eventually, yet another bailout.

As a real estate agent with a decent background in economics, I am in a good position to see both sides. There simply is no easy fix.  Those with good credit and a solid down payment will get mortgages.  It is the young, the less affluent -often minorities - who will have difficulty getting mortgages.   Owning your own home is an important part of the American Dream and we should not let that dream disappear, yet there is no getting around the fact that those whose credit is less solid and who have less money to put down as a down payment represent a higher-risk group.  I suspect the solution is going to be a blend of higher rates for some mortgages and some level of continuing government guarantee for higher risk mortgages.

Learn about western NC and the Blue Ridge mountains towns around Lake Lure NC: http://www.DiscoverLakeLure.com

 

 

 

Tamara Elliott-Deering
Central Metro Realty - Austin, TX

Joelle,

That's a nice summary.  I personally favor government guarantees of mortgages.  If you look at guarantee programs that work and don't work the FDIC model makes sense.  The FDIC is industry backed and it is self-funded.  The student loan program is another program that has swung the full gamut, it was totally government funded, then it went private and because privatization failed the government is back in the driver's seat.  I believe that there are core services the government should provide and we as a nation need to decide what they are, but the neighborhood stabilization that homeownership provides makes that seem like a no-brainer to me.

Tamara

Jan 29, 2011 12:20 AM
Anonymous
Joelle van den Brrg

I can't see that government will be able to totally back out of guaranteeing mortgages in order to make sure they are available.

On the other hand, we have been in a cycle when people often continually sucked the equity out of their homes as soon as they appreciated in value, often to buy cars or pay off credit cards (which they immediately ran up again).

For me, a little discipline seems to be in order.  Homeowners need some skin in the game to make sure it is not easier to default than pay. The other place we need discipline is from the banking industry where salaries and bonused have reached the truly absurd level.

Jan 29, 2011 07:08 AM
#2