Special offer

Poor Cell Reception in the Apostle Islands Area Needs to be Improved

By
Real Estate Broker/Owner with Madeline Island Realty 50317-90

I often tell prospective buyers visiting northwestern Wisconsin and the Apostle Islands area that the very reason why they wish to buy here can also become a source of frustration.  A remote area can be pristine and peaceful, but the inability to phone for fire, police or ambulance service can be annoying or even dangerous at times.

As with other parts of the country where population density is low, parts of Douglas, Ashland and Bayfield counties suffer from poor cellphone reception.

The Mobiledia website offers a section devoted to cellular coverage "deadspots" across the country, organized by state.  You'll read reports and reviews by consumers who have personally experienced problems with cell reception.  The Mobiledia site requests that contributors specify their service provider, location of report and the number of signal bars displayed at that location.

On Madeline Island, the lack of cellular reception north of Big Bay State Park is a concern to both tourists and residents. A stranded motorist would have little choice but to wait for assistance or begin walking for help.  It's also a personal safety issue.  Just a couple of months ago, I was driving a client around the Island to look at properties when we spotted a trio of tourists just north of Big Bay.  One of the three had fallen off a moped and her leg was injured.  We tried several phones, each with different service providers, but we could obtain no cell reception at that spot.  We wound up flagging down a passing motorist who drove to the town of LaPointe and sent EMTs to the scene.

Excluding the Ashland, Wisconsin area, about half an hour away by car, there are only three cell towers in the Apostle Islands.  One is in the hills above Bayfield, less than a mile north of the Apostle Highlands golf course.  Another is on Madeline Island, a short distance east of the Madeline Island golf course.  And a third tower is situated near the Madeline Island Airport.  Most, if not all of the towers in the area were designed for analog signal coverage, rather than digital.

The Chequamegon Bay and Apostle Islands area is beautiful and remote, but the lack of cell coverage puts both residents and visitors at risk.  As tourist traffic and the number of second homes in the area increases, our municipalities need to consider personal safety and the wisdom of building additional cell towers as needed, in order to improve existing cellphone service.

Comments (4)

Danielle V. Lewis
DDR Realty - Newburgh, NY
DDR Realty
I was thinking the other day how we all managed without cell phones, but they've become a very real necessity.
Oct 26, 2007 12:44 AM
Eric Kodner
Madeline Island Realty - La Pointe, WI
CRS, Madeline Island Realty, LaPointe, WI 54850 -

How true, Danielle!

Our Madeline Island community is a recreational area, with low population density and thousands of acres of woods.  If a forest fire started on the north end of this Island and there was a delay in reporting it due to lack of cell signal, the outcome could be tragic.  Ironically, cellphone towers are often opposed by those who think of themselves as environmentalists.

The same thing is true of accidents and injuries.  The day will come when someone will die because they could not call for medical attention.  An ensuing lawsuit may teach people a great deal about the need for reliable emergency communications in a recreational community.

Oct 26, 2007 01:15 AM
Repeaterstore .com
Repeaterstore.com - Dana Point, CA
Hi,

My name is Sam and I am a founding partner of the site Repeaterstore.com. I do not normally mention my site on forum posts, but the previous comment by Eric on safety compelled me to at least mention the products that we cell.

Cellular Repeaters are small amplifier devices that can boost cellular signal. Although they cannot create a cellular signal from nothing, areas of low signal quality can be amplified. If you frequently drop calls, or your phone shows service but you cannot make a call, then a cellular repeater can help. They also boost signal if you can only connect to another carrier and you phone displays "Emergency Calls only".

Cellular repeaters range from small desktop units and in-vehicle kits to devices covering thousands of square feet.

Best regards,
Sam
www.repeaterstore.com
Oct 26, 2007 06:02 AM
Eric Kodner
Madeline Island Realty - La Pointe, WI
CRS, Madeline Island Realty, LaPointe, WI 54850 -

Sam, thank you for mentioning that cellular repeaters do help in situations where a user is dealing with limited signal. 

I'm still concerned that the average tourist or visitor to our remote area will be without cell service in the event of an emergency.  There are still large areas of the United States where cellular service is minimal.  I do think that the circumstances in our area warrant more attention to this problem.

Oct 26, 2007 06:41 AM