Special offer

The effects of a Short Sale on Credit Scores

By
Real Estate Agent with EXIT Realty Beatrice Associates 9506757

The following blog post is being reprinted from Short Sale- How Will it Effect My Credit.  As a Massachusetts Realtor who is heavily involved in short sales, many sellers want to know what effect a short sale will have on their credit. 

 

The effects of a Short Sale on Credit Scores

Unfortunately a short sale will effect your credit scores.  Make no mistake, the “ding” to your credit score can be very minimal (50 points) to much higher (150 points or more).  This is also the case in a deed-in lieu of foreclosure. While a short sale can have less of or the same impact as a foreclosure on your credit, it has the benefits to your future financial health.  Please do not think a short sale will not effect your credit it will and it is irresponsible for someone to tell you otherwise.  Remember the how the short sale is reported can effect your credit score but equally important is how many late payments did you rack up while going through the process of a short sale.

There are many variables to how much your credit score will be impacted by a short sale.  The number of rolling late’s on your mortgage how your mortgage company reports the short sale to the credit agency as well as what your original credit score was.  It appears that the higher your score the harder your hit. These will be some of the factors in determining how much of an impact a short sale will have on your credit.

A key point to remember is, that many times, while struggling with your mortgage, you may be experiencing trouble with other lines of credit.  Every late you may have on credit card, car or student loan payments or any other line of credit, will impact your credit score.  The more late payments, of any type, that is reported to the credit bureaus, the more impact it will have on your credit score.  Many times by the time you are considering a short sale, a home owner will have already have had some serious impact to their credit score.

There is one significant difference between a foreclosure and a short sale.  A foreclosure stays on your credit for 7 years.  While your credit score may improve over time with both a short sale and a foreclosure, the foreclosure will be reported as a foreclosure and when applying for a mortgage and some other lines of credit they do ask the question if you have ever been foreclosed upon.  A foreclosure may impact your ability to get future credit in the intermediate term.

So, yes, a short sale will effect your credit, how much depends on many factors.

The bigger question to ask yourself is do you have another alternative?  For many underwater home owners a short sale may be the best and only alternative to an imminent foreclosure.  And, while yes, a foreclosure effects your credit there are other advantages to a short sale that makes it a better solution to a foreclosure.  Here is a recent article I wrote, Considering a Short Sale.

In a nut shell, if you are facing a future foreclosure and you see no way to stay in your home or it is not financially practical to stay in your home, a Short Sale is probably your best option, irregardless of the impact on your credit score.

Other short sale articles:

Considering a Short Sale
How Does a Short Sale Effect My Credit
Tax Consequences of a Short Sale
Should I stay in My House During a Short Sale
The Deficiency Balance
When Should I consider a Short Sale?
Who Pays the Fees in a Short Sale?
Chasing the Loan Modification

This post was printed by Kevin Vitali of EXIT Group One Real Estate.  If you are struggling with your mortgage call Kevin at 978-360-0422.  Kevin can answere your questions and help you decide what route may be best for you and your family.

Lynn Tardibuono
Sun Pacific Mortgage and Real Estate - Santa Rosa, CA
Sun Pacific Mortgage and Real Estate

This is a fantastic and realistic article about short sales and how it effects your credit. Thanks for the refresher, great post. 

Nov 04, 2011 11:15 AM
James Lockard
RE/MAX Properties - Saddle River - Allendale, NJ
Realtor, Allendale, NJ

Kevin,

All true statements and this is usually the first question people ask when thinking about a short sale. 

I actually had a client's credit score go UP after he completed his short sale believe it or not. I guess his outstanding debt was relieved so his score jumped.

Nov 07, 2011 03:42 AM
Kevin Vitali
EXIT Realty Beatrice Associates - Middleton, MA
Helping Massachusetts Home Buyers and Home Sellers

Lynn and James- I see a lot of articles from real estate articles flat out stating the short sale will impact their credit score less than a foreclosure.  While a short sale can impact the credit hit less than a foreclosure I think it irresponsible to suggest that it will unilaterally impact it less than a foreclosure.   There are so many factors involved the it is hard to predict.  Quite frankly if you are at the point of considering the impact of a short sale there are other factors that are either as important or more important than a the credit impact of a short sale.

Nov 07, 2011 04:15 AM