Admin

Mold - To Test Or Not??

By
Home Inspector with StepByStep Home Services LC

 This is a question I ask myself at least once a year while looking into training and equipment for mold testing. Is testing for mold a good service to offer? So far the answer I've come up with each time is "probably not" but I always, at least partially, contribute my answer to lack of education on the subject so I read more. Each time I find myself searching for some information that will convince me otherwise but so far I've come to the same conclusion. This blog only covers a small area and I will not attempt to go over all testing types, mold types or health/property risks.

 

 

Mold MonsterA couple weeks ago I completed two basic courses on air quality testing/mold inspections as well as researched equipment needed to perform this service. After completing the courses I contacted a local laboratory that offers face to face training over over the course of several days and decided if I were to pursue testing I would take that training. But shortly after gathering all the information I thought I needed to move forward I found myself questioning the value of mold testing and once again I am unconvinced. I know I could add this service and do it, I'm asked about it all the time, but I can't justify performing a service that I don't really believe in just because I can make money off of it. My stand on mold has always been to eliminate the source, water intrusion, and clean/remove materials to prevent possible damage to the structure. The issue of health related mold problems is there I know but I am not convinced that these are as common as some are lead to believe. I do believe the general public has a fear of mold because they are taught to fear it. On the other hand I've read articles discussing serious illnesses cause by exposure.

Some say technically you should not say the substance is mold without having it tested first but really if you can see/smell it why not just correct the conditions, what's the point of testing it? On the other hand air samples can tell you if the indoor air quality is consistent with the exterior air quality. If the indoor sample shows higher levels of mold you would technically have a mold problem in need of correction. One of the problems I have with that method is the fact that most people do not want to pay for the number of air samples that would, in my opinion, provide a good answer. Contractors will often take one to two outdoor samples and perhaps only one indoor sample. The cost of a "proper" mold test, as far as I can tell, would be extensively more than most buyer's are willing to spend.

As I said before I am no expert but I am looking for opinions on mold testing. I've spoken to several inspectors about this and of course I get two responses. Those who test for it of course stand behind it and those who don't take a similar approach to mine. What is your opinion?

Comments(8)

Show All Comments Sort:
Cheryl Dickson
Retired Realtor / Retired Home Inspector - Enid, OK
Retired Realtor, GRI / Retired Home Inspector

I'm having the same dilemma! Lots of training and attending classes, have certifications, but still on the fence. Still undecided about offering Mold Testing. Good luck on this tug-of-war decision!

Nov 15, 2011 10:42 AM
Vince Santos
StepByStep Home Services LC - Canton, MI
Southeast Michigan Home Inspector

Effie - Here's a link that can better answer that question. EPA Mold/Mildew

Cheryl - Sounds like we are in the same boat. As of right now it is unlikely that I will ever offer it but who knows, with more training my mind might change.

Nov 15, 2011 11:49 AM
Ed Gillespie
WealthWise Mortgage Planning, a Division of American Pacific Mortgage Corporation NMLS #1850 - Folsom, CA

I have some non-professional experience on this one.  My wife was made very sick by a water damaged building.  Her specialist relayed that one quarter of the population is susceptible to illness from water damage.  We have to have an ERMI test on our current residence as part of her treatment plan.  Knowing if toxins are present and what kind is vital.

On the business side, I have encountered properties that not only have mold but it is the toxic kind, and present to point where the home is unliveable and beyond remediation.

So, to your post, it truly is a significant health concern.  I'm assuming that there are no mold specialists in your area nor places homeowners can take samples for analysis?  

Nov 15, 2011 11:55 AM
Vince Santos
StepByStep Home Services LC - Canton, MI
Southeast Michigan Home Inspector

Ed - Thank you for your post. Sorry to hear about your wife, I hope she makes a full recovery. There are several laboratories around here that offer equipment as well as analysis. A large portion of HI's in my area do offer mold testing services.

Nov 15, 2011 12:19 PM
Charles Buell
Charles Buell Inspections Inc. - Seattle, WA
Seattle Home Inspector

Vince, I am totally unconvinced and my opinion that most of the industry is fear based hype.  When you dig into the science much of it is anecdotal and just plain "junk science."  If you have a moisture problem---fix it---end of story as far as I am concerned.  Mold spores are just a fraction of the crud in air assoicated with homes with moisture problems---dust mites is a far bigger component of that same air sample.  But as they say Mold is Gold----more about the money than any truth.

Nov 15, 2011 01:07 PM
Ed Gillespie
WealthWise Mortgage Planning, a Division of American Pacific Mortgage Corporation NMLS #1850 - Folsom, CA

Vince--thanks for your kind words.  I see your dilemma: expend the time and cost to offer the service or be not as competitive among your fellow professionals!

Nov 15, 2011 02:49 PM
Vince Santos
StepByStep Home Services LC - Canton, MI
Southeast Michigan Home Inspector

Charles - Thank you for your input. It does seem like the further I dig into it the more unconvinced I am. I think Ed's post though is an example of the potential for health issues involved in moldy homes. I also believe mold is the symptom of a bigger issue and that's a wet house. We as inspectors are trained to look for these conditions already as part of an inspection. If I were to offer mold testing based on conducive conditions I'd say pretty much all of the homes I inspect are candidates for mold testing.

 

Nov 15, 2011 10:52 PM
Kevin Stripling
Home Inspection Professionals - Saint Clair Shores, MI
Home Inspection Professionals

Vince,

We at HIP do offer Mold Testing - but take the same approach that you've recommend.  If there is a moisture/mildew/mold issue - our first recommendation is to eliminate and correct the source.  Mold testing is available, but correcting the issue is most important.  Even once the substance has been tested and identified - it still has to be corrected and properly cleaned (remediated). 

We've been requested several times for Mold Testing to identify the type and best remediate the situation.  We've been requested by private owners as well as investors and property managers for similar information.  We've been called upon by home owners experiencing health issues and need to know what type of mold they've been exposed to and provided that information to their health professional.  Nearly all have come to the same conclusion - it has to be corrected. 

While there is business in mold testing, there is also expense in training, accreditation, continuing education as well as tools & materials.  We do our best to recommend correction and remediation rather than focus on the available testing that always comes with additional charges.  We always take a very non-alarmist approach and provide the best facts available.  Most often, the knowledge and experience of the inspector is more valuable than the lab test results themselves.

Even as your "competition", it's nice to see that we agree that addressing the issue and providing the client the best information and service is more important than collecting additional fees!  Kudos!

Sep 25, 2013 12:30 AM