Special offer

Yeahhh! We got an offer!

By
Real Estate Agent with DPR Realty LLC.

This morning I received a call from my office informing me that I got offer on my listing. I thought to myself, "Really?, I didn't get a call from the REALTOR, letting me know to expect one, I didn't even know that the home was shown". So I scurried on down to office, eager to see what I anticipated to be a low-ball offer, and guess what?, the offer was far beyond what I could have ever imagined. This was the mother of all low-ball offers, $85,000 under the asking price. Now, if we were talking about a home listed over half a million dollars, that might make sense to me, but this home is listed is the mid 200s.

Of course this offer is coming from an investor, and it did cme attached with a short sale addendum, so they were obviously under the impression that my clients are trying to avoid foreclosure, which is definitely not the case.I had no idea that investors were making such low offers, I expect the usual $30,000-$50,000 under asking price, but I'm think that $85,000 might be a little extreme. Or am I wrong? I do a CMA on all my listings and I also update my CMAs every month or two, but I know it's buyer's market, so realistically, I expect to see offers that may be lower than we anticipate.

I plan to present the offer to my clients, and I will definitely encourage them to make a counteroffer, one that is fair to both parties, because that's what we as good agents do. No offer is a bad offer, right? I don't expect that we will come anywhere close to meeting in the middle but at least we will try. 

So, am I wrong? I need your feedback.

John Walters
Frank Rubi Real Estate - Slidell, LA
Licensed in Louisiana
I would make a counteroffer.  I think you should counter them all basically. 
Jan 07, 2008 05:06 AM
Israel Barden
RE/MAX Big Bear Village - Big Bear Lake, CA
I typically advise my clients to start at 10% under the listing price. They don't always listen. Some people are just stuck in the low ball mindset and are willing to put in numerous offers until they finally find that person who is desperate to sell. A call to the listing agent can usually save all parties involved a great deal of time and effort.
Jan 07, 2008 05:06 AM
Leesa Finley
RED Properties - Wake Forest, NC
RED Properties - Raleigh NC Real Estate
Are you wrong to do your job? NO!  Definately open the lines of communication.  I was just talking to a seller this morning about some of the offers I have seen lately.  Now, we all know that there is low but COME ON - then there is "Are you kidding me?"  I feel your pain!
Jan 07, 2008 05:08 AM
Jennifer Esposito
JenRan Realty, LLC - Woodstock, CT
I always try to use the initial offer (even when its 'bad') as the starting point.  Getting your sellers to look beyond that 'insulting amount' is the tough part.  We also find it helpful to do CMA's on a monthly basis just to keep up with the changing market.   I'd say you're on the right track.
Jan 07, 2008 05:11 AM
Rick Tourgee
Robert Paul Properties, Inc. - Provincetown, MA
Provincetown and Cape Cod

I guide my Buyer Clients to offer the true market value.  If the property is $100,000 more than the true realistic market value, then we are going to come at least $100,000 under list price.

I never go by a "percentage below list", because that still could be higher than market value.

Sometimes, you cannot blame the Buyer for trying.  After all, that's what the Buyers are hearing from the news media- that the market is bad so put in low offers.

My local paper even had an article about low ballers actually getting offers accepted!

Jan 07, 2008 05:12 AM
Mary Bowen
Coldwell Banker United, Realtor - The Woodlands, TX
Real Estate At Its Finest!!!
I closed an contract once on an offer that was initially considered too low by the seller.  Eventually, 2 mos. later we ended up in the middle and made the deal.  I think the only reason it closed was becuase the "wife buyer" really wanted that house.
Jan 07, 2008 05:17 AM
Joe Pecoraro
REMAX- Big Bear - Big Bear Lake, CA

I believe a good agent gets their clients to counter every offer, even if it is full price.    I would say you are doing the right thing. 

Just curious, why did the investor think your client was in danger of a foreclosure?  Did they have a default recorded on the deed? 

Jan 07, 2008 10:05 AM
Cynthia Tilghman, RealtorĀ® Onslow County NC Home Specialist
Kingsbridge Realty, Inc - Hubert, NC
Hi Vinnie,
Wow!  That hurts...$85,000!  Counteroffer is definitely in the pipeline and hopefully the two parties can find a meeting place.  Lots of luck.
Jan 07, 2008 09:05 PM
Matthew Rosov
Amerisave Mortgage Corporation - Laurel, MD
Certified Mortgage Planning Specialist

Reminds me of a TV show where something like this happened.  The counter was higher.  Every time the buyer tried to go lower, the counter went up.

Way to get an offer!

Jan 08, 2008 05:57 AM