Special offer

My World: A brief lesson in Realtor Economics for Buyers

By
Real Estate Agent with RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc.

It's not normal for us to consider the impact of our requests when we hire a professional to perform services for us. We normally assume that they know what they're doing and understand how much to bill us and that they will do so fairly. This generally holds true for people who are billing us directly.

The problem comes up when we're not being billed directly and the payment for the services that we need is being supplied by someone else. If you've thought about this at all, you probably understand that when someone else pays, the consumer's best strategy is to use as much of the "free" service as possible. This is normal and very understandable.

The end result is the same in all such instances, the service which is over-used becomes less available and more expensive. This is the case in health care and we're preparing to see how this works on a national basis, but that's another topic.

In real estate, the Realtor is almost always paid by the seller on a commission basis. This means that they will do their best to assist the buyer to close a transaction. When the buyer over-uses the Realtor's service, the pay that the agent receives does not necessarily increase commensurately.

Here's an example to better illustrate the point:

A buyer contacts an agent wanting to look at houses. The agent meets with the buyer and determines on the basis of their conversation that:

  1. The buyer is not very serious and their need to buy is not urgent,
  2. The buyer is very picky and wants more than they can realistically expect to find given their budget, and
  3. The buyer expects the agent to show them a very large number of properties.

Given this scenario, the agent must rationally estimate the time they'll spend and the commission they'll earn. Let's say that the commission will be $3,000 and the agent has to show 50 houses and doing so will put about 500 miles on their car and take 4 days of their time. The brokerage where the agent works will take part of that commission and so will taxes. A large part of the remainder will go for various overhead items necessary for the agent to remain in business -- things such as board dues, MLS fees, E&O Insurance, auto expenses, even clothing expenses.

In this case, it might turn out that the agent decides that their time could best be allocated to another buyer. Perhaps they have the chance to work with a buyer who wants the same amount of service and wants to look at the same number of houses, but who will generate a commission of $6,000 because they're going to buy in a higher price range.

Would it surprise you, if the agent told the first buyer that they couldn't help them? What if the agent took the first buyer out for a day and then just sort of became too busy to take them out again? Does this sound familiar?

OK. What's the point of this post? If you're a buyer and you want the best service from your agent, no matter what price range you're in, take a moment to consider the economic results of your requests on your agent. While you deserve and need assistance and while they probably really want to help you, they can't afford to give an unlimited amount of help on what amounts to a limited budget.

Realize upfront that you'll need to have a specific set of needs that the house must meet and when those boxes are filled, you should be ready to buy, even if you haven't looked at hundreds of houses.  Your agent will appreciate it and you'll end up getting better service.

Namaste!

Kevin J. May
Florida Supreme Realty - Hobe Sound, FL
Serving the Treasure & Paradise Coasts of Florida

Eric, at first glance the conclusion is correct.  A $6,000 pay day is much better than a $3,000 one however if broken down further to an hourly fee wouldn't you agree that $80.00 to $100.00 per hour is reasonable?  In the grand scheme of things those customers have often repeated the process 7,9 and 10 or 11 times for much better returns.  The $6K customer may be just a fleeting moment proving a bird in the hand is so much better than two in the bush!

Jul 17, 2012 01:40 AM
Brad Rachielles
CENTURY 21 Peak, Ca BRE# 01489453 - Upland, CA
REALTOR, CDPE, Upland, CA

Eric,

Been there... Done that.... but didn't leave the buyer hanging. Proper care of the client explains how we work on the head end. If there are occasions when a prospect wants to see everything (and that may not be hard to do in this market with only 1.6 months of inventory in this market), it's time for a sit down review of their finances vs. wants list vsproperties seen or asked to see.Had one like this that was so immature that "Mom & Dad" actually stepped on child/buyer and said enough. Well said.

Jul 17, 2012 01:55 AM
Brenda Mullen
RE/MAX Associates - San Antonio, TX
Your San Antonio TX Real Estate Agent!!

I think this is a good thing for buyers to read; however, most probably aren't that concerned with Realtor economics and are more worried about their own. 

No matter the client, the $3000 one or the $6000 one, they will both get the same level of service from me, and both will get the come to Jesus talk if we start showing vast numbers of homes with no end in sight :).  Every buyer gets a needs analysis and gets homes in their search that will meet those needs. 

That's just my take on it :)!   Great post.

Jul 17, 2012 01:57 AM
Eric Martell
RE/MAX Properties SW, Inc. - Orlando, FL
Ph.D.

Good comments, all.  I wrote this from a generic perspective with an eye towards helping buyers understand exactly what they're asking for when they want a huge amount of time.  We've (my wife and I) often worked and worked and worked to help a buyer with a small budget, because we believe that everyone deserves help.  That is, as long as they're willing to let us help them.  If they won't listen to us (ever asked a buyer to get pre-qualified with a lender and then have them blow it off and subsequently miss out on the perfect property because they weren't able to make an offer?), then we do reevaluate and have a serious discussion with them.  Education is the key and they need to know what to expect from us and what we expect from them. 

Jul 17, 2012 09:27 AM
Jark Krysinski *PREC (Personal Real Estate Corporation)
REMAX CREST REALTY WESTSIDE - Vancouver, BC
TeamYVR Team Leader, BA,ABR,IRES,IMSD,LLB

Hi Eric - I'm getting my IRES Designation in Vancouver, BC, Canada today and I noticed that you have a IRES designation as well.  Look forward to chatting some more with you with respect to co-listing each other's properties.  Interested in speaking further?  Cheers, Jark.

Jul 25, 2012 03:16 AM