My Door County Top 10 (or more) Restaurants this Season

Real Estate Agent with The Kellstrom Ray Agency, Inc. (Est. 1948)


My Door County Top Ten this week was completed after several delicious meals throughout the Door Peninsula this season. 

We are a resort community and the kitchen in the homes I sell, while very important in any purchase for future entertaining and for the simple act of eating or food preparation, are an afterthought when visited by children or grandchildren for an extended holiday, or if you are simply up for a weekend trying to unwind and get a few things done (other than wiping peanut-butter-and-jelly fingerprints off the granite counter tops). We like to eat out in Door County, and we have several nationally known restaurants that consistently “make the grade” year after year.  One of my favorite questions from people who are looking at property with me is “Where should I eat”????   My response….”Where should I startJ?”

If a certain establishment isn't on my list, that doesn't mean it wasn't memorable or isn't truly fantastic. We are blessed with an incredible wealth of eating establishments on the Door Peninsula, and to be brutally honest, I cooked more at home this year than in the past two (healthy eating here sometimes triumphs over convenience and the desire for a JJ's chicken burrito). But of the 40-odd establishments I can purchase gift certificates from, these were the ones destined for memorable closings during the past year. These are in no particular order; they are all favorites, so each one is worth a visit.  We have some GREAT new restaurants:  Grasse’s Grille, Wickman House, and CHOP.  Try them all.  They all deserve a shout-out.


Door County Dining


10. Northern Grill (Sister Bay). I'm not usually a creature of substantial habit, but if I go to the Northern Grill, I order two things. The Spicy Beef Sandwhich (Norwegians, Beware!) and a cup of their eclectic chili. The pizza is good, and the atmostphere is family-friendly, often with live music outdoors in summer. A good choice.


9. The Summer Kitchen (Ephraim). The menu was expanded a few years ago to include some truly delicous Mexican entrees, but my heart still lies very strongly with the breakfast menu here, the Benedicts, the quiche, and other homemade delights. Also some of the best chicken salad I've ever tasted, and those pitas are large enough for two meals, or to share. Definitely a favorite.


8. The Cookery (Fish Creek). One would think that maybe a devasting fire a few years ago would have daunted this fantastic establishment, but not. The new building is superb, and the food is as good as ever. I have been eating Tollhouse Pie here since a teenager, and I'm not about to stop now, especially after I've introduced the bakery items to my own girls. Delightful.


7. Pasta Vino (Ellison Bay). This "new kid on the block" isn't new---Pete D'Amico was just given the chance to expand his space and his menu, and he took that chance, ran with it, and scored a touchdown. I waitressed for Peter at one of his previous establishments in Sister Bay while I was in college, and his family's recipe for marinara sauce is the easily one of the best east of Sicily. The portions are huge, the menu is extensive, and you truly get your moneys' worth. Be prepared to wait, because Pasta Vino is not a secret anymore, and commands respectable crowds.


6. Alexander's (Fish Creek). Another prudent move, one that brought owners Bruce and Jill Alexander to Fish Creek several years ago when their old Du Nord lodge was purchased by a developer for condominium property. Fantastic food and beverages, great service, and a jovial atmosphere. Sunday brunch is fantastic at Alexander's.


5. The Wild Tomato.  Exceptional pizza, casual atmosphere, creative menu.  Central Fish Creek.

Door County Dining

4. The Shoreline (Gills Rock). One word. Yum. Most people come for the spectacular water view and turn the food into a secondary experience. However, I grew up on and around the shore, so I don't notice the view or the charming commercial fish tugs going by as much as a visitor might. However, I do note several consistent things---the food here is fantastic, the service is exceptional, and I always know to expect a wait unless it is a weekday in spring or late, late autumn. Worth the drive to Gills Rock!

3. JJ's/La Puerta/Waterfront (Sister Bay and Jacksonport). I could separate these establishments into their own categories (Christine and James Johnson own four Door County eating establishments, if you count the combined 'JJ's/LaPuerta' as two (and I remember when they were separate establishments)), but as the sum of the whole, you can't go wrong here (and I didn't include the Sugar Shack, which is a seasonal cabana on the water). If I want a fun meal, I go to JJ's, where I'll run into several dozen people I know and be introduced to several dozen new ones to become future friends. Waterfront is an exceptional dining experience on its own and the food bedazzles as much as the sunset. Always a favorite for my customers and clients, too.


2. The Sister Bay Bowl (Sister Bay). Don't belittle this bowling alley that also serves food: it was recently featured in several "Best of Wisconsin" publications as well as a few national publications focusing on supper clubs. The perch is about the best I've ever had (I know the fisherman who catch it), the service is great, and the bartenders are as friendly and as large-as-life as you'll find for Door County characters. One of my buyers this year told me her most memorable Door County experience was getting a dance on the bar toward closing with her nanny. While I don't encourage that (bars tend to be slippery and you may fall), this is a FUN place with good food. Also great for quick business lunches.


Al Johnson's Server


1. Al Johnson's Swedish Restaurant (Sister Bay). What can I say about this little establishment that hasn't already been stated, other, does the Johnson family know what its doing with this business. From goats on the roof, to the thriving butik, to the waitresses and hostesses in their native gear---this is a Door County experience. The saddest thing? Many of the people I work with have driven by, have taken photos of the goats, but are too intimidated by the crowds to actually stop in. As such, this is almost always my favorite place to bring someone who is currently looking at Door County Properties, because nearly fifty percent of the time it is a first-time experience for them. However, they will be back. Large portions, exceptional service...and, of course, goats.


There are several places that I visited this year once or twice that are permanent parts of my life, also, deserve at least a "shout out" because they're fabulous, and that I plan to try to frequent more (I can only eat and go out so much). The A/C Tap, Fred & Fuzzy's, The Door County Ice Cream Factory, Husby's Food & Spirits, Pelletiers, Casey's, Blue Front, Inn at Kristophers, Mr. Helsinki's, Bayside, English Inn, The Viking Grill, Cornerstone Pub...this was going to be a short blog….sorry!


I don't really just sell real estate here, because this is mainly a secondary home community, but we also sell a lifestyle. There are fantastic food establishments up and down the Door Peninsula.


Posted by

All information is deemed reliable as of date of publication and is subject to change without notice.


 Thank you for reading!  MaryKay Shumway, ABR®, CRS®, Realtor® loves to laugh and enjoys working with people that love the Door Peninsula.  She is a full-time real estate Broker, mother of two and a senior Broker Associate at the Kellstrom-Ray Agency, Inc. in beautiful Sister Bay, Wisconsin.  She represents listings throughout the Door County Peninsula and also represents many Buyers that want to purchase the perfect property to make Door County a part of their lives.  CONTACT MARYKAY ABOUT YOUR DOOR COUNTY PROPERTY QUESTIONS TODAY.

MaryKay Shumway has a consistent multi-million dollar producer for over thirteen years.  Representing both listing clients and buyer clients full time, MaryKay is also a mother of two and active in the Door County community in the local school district, nonprofit groups and governmental affairs.  A member of the Door County Board of Realtors Honors Society from 2005-2016, the Door County Realtor of the Year 2008, a member of The Real Estate Group's Chairman's Circle in 2010-2015, and an member of the Coldwell Banker International Diamond Society for 2014 & 15.  She has served as President and Vice President of the Door County Board of Realtors  and as a member of its Advocacy Committee.  MaryKay is a top MLS producer and has held the position of top producer at The Kellstrom-Ray Agency, Inc. since 2016.


Contact MaryKay.  "As a multi-million dollar producer and senior associate at The Kellstrom-Ray Agency selling Door County real estate, I focus my balance on both  featured listings and representing Buyer Clients looking for the perfect Door County Property.  I turn Door County vacations into Door County traditions by helping you own your own Door County real estate, and I represent exceptional properties in all price points on the Bay of Green Bay, Lake Michigan, and all inland lakes and properties in between. Call, text or e-mail me today."


This entry hasn't been re-blogged:

Re-Blogged By Re-Blogged At
Real Estate General Information
Wisconsin Door County
Blogging & SEO
Posts to Localism
HyperLocal Neighborhood and Community Posts
door county dining
great places to dine in door county
where to eat in door county

Post a Comment
Spam prevention
Spam prevention
Show All Comments
Tamra Lee Ulmer
Arizona Resource Realty - Payson, AZ
FORCE~NRBA ~ Over 1000 REO Assets SOLD!

MaryKay, looks like some great restaurants you have around there, and a great place to live!

Sep 18, 2012 05:13 AM #1
Kathy Sheehan
Bay Equity, LLC 770-634-4021 - Atlanta, GA
Senior Loan Officer

Door County is a great place to explore in the fall.  

Sep 18, 2012 10:13 AM #2
Post a Comment
Spam prevention
Show All Comments

What's the reason you're reporting this blog entry?

Are you sure you want to report this blog entry as spam?


MaryKay Shumway

Door County Wisconsin's Real Estate Expert
BUYING or SELLING a Door County Property? Call Me Today!
Spam prevention

Additional Information